Canonicity and IF - an IFDB Poll
by juliaofbathI'm interested in determining whether or not a clear canon has emerged within the world of IF/hypertext. Of course, there is a clear critical opinion regarding which works belong to this tentative canon, but I'm interested in what readers and fans of the genre feel. I mean 'canon' in the traditional literary sense. For the sake of clarity I will define it here less as a coherent, codified list of works and more as a loose assemblage held in the minds (and in this case lists) of readers, reviewers, and critics.
| Colossal Cave Adventure, by William Crowther and Donald Woods 19 votes "The original." [+]"The original.: Atmosphere, style, exploration, puzzles, structure, comedy, genre deconstruction. Practically everything in IF except for plot and characters can be found in the original Adventure." --neroden... "The original." [+]"The original.: Self-explanatory." --Chris Conley... (No comment) [+](No comment) --CMG... (No comment) [+](No comment) (   ) --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Tobias V. I. Langhoff... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Jade68... (No comment) [+](No comment) --cgasquid... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Adam Biltcliffe...  Vote for this game | |
| Zork I, by Marc Blank and Dave Lebling 18 votes "It launched a company and a swathe of imitators." [+]"It launched a company and a swathe of imitators.: This took Adventure's dungeon crawling puzzle game design, added a more in-depth combat system and humorous writing, and practically launched the commercial IF industry, at least in the US." --Chris Conley... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Denk... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Ivanr... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Emily Short... (No comment) [+](No comment) --E.K.... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Tobias V. I. Langhoff... (No comment) [+](No comment) --neroden... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --cgasquid... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| Galatea, by Emily Short 12 votes "Coming to IF in recent years," [+]"Coming to IF in recent years,: every resource I read, every thread I perused, made it clear that playing Galatea was essential to understanding where IF had gone in its post-commercial phase. While things have continued to evolve since then, I think Galatea remains essential." ( ) --Ghalev... "A very well-realized on-character conversation game." [+]"A very well-realized on-character conversation game." --Chris Conley... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) --E.K.... (No comment) [+](No comment) --jakomo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Ivanr... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Wanderlust... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --IFforL2... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --cgasquid... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| Anchorhead, by Michael Gentry 11 votes "Of course." [+]"Of course." --Ivanr... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Denk... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Emily Short... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --E.K.... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --jakomo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Wanderlust... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --tekket... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Jade68... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --cgasquid... Vote for this game | |
| Counterfeit Monkey, by Emily Short 10 votes "A whole game revolving around wordplay." [+]"A whole game revolving around wordplay.: An entire game revolving around wordplay, puns, and rearranging-letter puzzles. The kind of thing that could never possibly work as anything but interactive fiction." --Chris Conley... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --CMG... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Ivanr... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Billy Mays... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Sam Kabo Ashwell... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --tekket... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --IFforL2... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Jade68... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... "A game which..." [+]"A game which could only exist in this medium, never successfully imitated " () --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| Photopia, by Adam Cadre 10 votes "The first big famous "story" or "puzzleless" IF." [+]"The first big famous "story" or "puzzleless" IF." --Chris Conley... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Ivanr... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --jakomo... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Wanderlust... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Karl Ove Hufthammer... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Felix Pleșoianu... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| Spider and Web, by Andrew Plotkin 9 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) --Ivanr... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Emily Short... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --cgasquid... "One of the most..." [+]"One of the most significant early explorations of the narrator-PC-player relationship" () --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| Aisle, by Sam Barlow 8 votes "The One-Move Game's first move" [+]"The One-Move Game's first move" --Ghalev... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Anya Johanna DeNiro... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) --jakomo... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Wanderlust... (No comment) [+](No comment) --IFforL2... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| A Mind Forever Voyaging, by Steve Meretzky 7 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) --Anya Johanna DeNiro... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --jakomo... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --cgasquid... Vote for this game | |
| Blue Lacuna, by Aaron A. Reed 7 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Denk... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --IFforL2... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| Lost Pig, by Admiral Jota 7 votes "My first recommendation to newcomers." [+]"My first recommendation to newcomers.: And I don't think I'm alone in that. Lost Pig is welcoming, funny, deeply implemented and satisfying. If it isn't considered some kind of gold standard, that makes no sense to me." ( ) --Emily Short... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Karl Ove Hufthammer... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --IFforL2... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| De Baron, by Victor Gijsbers 7 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --CMG... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Chris Conley... "To my mind, the..." [+]"To my mind, the most affecting example of a story-focused parser game" () --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| Slouching Towards Bedlam, by Star C. Foster and Daniel Ravipinto 6 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --E.K.... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Ivanr... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Wanderlust... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Felix Pleșoianu... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| Trinity, by Brian Moriarty 6 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) --Emily Short... (No comment) [+](No comment) --jakomo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Fredrik... "IF to this point..." [+]"IF to this point has been funny romps, this is the first example to make IF into something more than that." --Mikalye... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| howling dogs, by Porpentine 6 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --CMG... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Emily Short... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) --cgasquid... Vote for this game | |
| Curses, by Graham Nelson 6 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Emily Short... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Ghalev... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Enchanter, by Marc Blank, Dave Lebling 6 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Emily Short... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Fredrik... (No comment) [+](No comment) --neroden... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| Hadean Lands, by Andrew Plotkin 5 votes "Canonically awesome." [+]"Canonically awesome." ( ) --Billy Mays... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --CMG... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Anya Johanna DeNiro... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| Rameses, by Stephen Bond 4 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| With Those We Love Alive, by Porpentine and Brenda Neotenomie 4 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Wanderlust... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Kinetic Mouse Car... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --cgasquid... Vote for this game | |
| Birdland, by Brendan Patrick Hennessy 4 votes "So weird yet so effective." [+]"So weird yet so effective.: A great take on character building. Well-written. The best entry in this Twine loose trilogy from BPH." --Chris Conley... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Anya Johanna DeNiro... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| Lime Ergot, by Caleb Wilson (as Rust Blight) 4 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --CMG... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| 80 DAYS, by inkle, Meg Jayanth 4 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --CMG... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Sam Kabo Ashwell... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Jade68... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| Shade, by Andrew Plotkin 4 votes "The first game that came to mind. Evey "great IF" list seems to at least include Shade." [+]"The first game that came to mind. Evey "great IF" list seems to at least include Shade." --Ivanr... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Emily Short... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| Savoir-Faire, by Emily Short 4 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) --Anya Johanna DeNiro... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Sam Kabo Ashwell... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Chris Conley... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Gun Mute, by C.E.J. Pacian 4 votes "What if Shadow of the Colossus, but text?" [+]"What if Shadow of the Colossus, but text?" --Chris Conley... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Anya Johanna DeNiro... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... "Early exploration..." [+]"Early exploration of what would become known as limited-parser games" ( Vote for this game | |
| The Hobbit, by Philip Mitchell and Veronika Megler 3 votes "A true classic" [+]"A true classic: I bring this game up whenever there is a discussion of classic or canonic status. It was extremely influential on the European 8-bit IF market, and it is probably one of the biggest-selling non-Infocoms ever. It also showed that you can make a complex game even with very limited hardware." ( ) --Felix Pleșoianu... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Adventureland, by Scott Adams 3 votes "Scott Adams' first" [+]"Scott Adams' first: I am surprised that I seem to be the first one to vote for this game. It was the game that started the whole IF thing for 8-bit computers, and showed that a game did not have to be huge or extremely complex to be fun to play." ( Vote for this game | |
| The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, by Douglas Adams and Steve Meretzky 3 votes "One of the hearts of the medium." [+]"One of the hearts of the medium.: Even if we're examining it as a study in how excruciatingly unfair some Infocom games could be when they were feeling playful." ( ) --Fredrik... Vote for this game | |
| my father's long, long legs, by michael lutz 3 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) --Chris Conley... Vote for this game | |
| Planetfall, by Steve Meretzky 3 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Main Hall & Beginners Cave, by Donald Brown 2 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Pick Up The Phone Booth And Die, by Rob Noyes 2 votes "My introduction..." [+]"My introduction to both one-move IF and joke IF, it maintains a place in the canon for me by dint of innovation, if not quality." ( Vote for this game | |
| Bee, by Emily Short 2 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| The King of Shreds and Patches, by Jimmy Maher 2 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Mentula Macanus: Apocolocyntosis, by One of the Bruces and Drunken Bastard 2 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --CMG... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Anya Johanna DeNiro... Vote for this game | |
| Everybody Dies, by Jim Munroe 2 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Anya Johanna DeNiro... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Worldsmith, by Ade McT 2 votes "A modern classic." [+]"A modern classic." ( ) --Denk... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --Laney Berry... Vote for this game | |
| Horse Master, by Tom McHenry 2 votes (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --CMG... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| The Gostak, by Carl Muckenhoupt 2 votes "The canonical..." [+]"The canonical language-puzzle game" ( ) --Adam Biltcliffe... (No comment) [+](No comment) () --EJ... Vote for this game | |
| Choice of the Dragon, by Dan Fabulich and Adam Strong-Morse 2 votes "The start of all things Choice of Games" [+]"The start of all things Choice of Games" ( - Full review) --MathBrush... (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Digital: A Love Story, by Christine Love 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Superluminal Vagrant Twin, by C.E.J. Pacian 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Edo... Vote for this game | |
| Choice of Magics, by Kevin Gold 1 vote "Way more reactive than you'd think." [+]"Way more reactive than you'd think.: A great example of how the linear Choice of Games structure can still provide a cohesive experience that reacts dynamically to the player's choices." --Chris Conley... Vote for this game | |
| Lydia's Heart, by Jim Aikin 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Denk... Vote for this game | |
| Captain Verdeterre's Plunder, by Ryan Veeder 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| Treasures of a Slaver's Kingdom, by S. John Ross 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Denk... Vote for this game | |
| Bugsy, by Priscilla Langridge 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| The Axe of Kolt [2014 ADRIFT version], by Larry Horsfield 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( - Full review) --Denk... Vote for this game | |
| Fish!, by John Molloy, Pete Kemp, Phil South, Rob Steggles 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Metamorphoses, by Emily Short 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| The Incredible Erotic Adventures of Stiffy Makane, by Mark Ryan 1 vote "An unpleasant and..." [+]"An unpleasant and poor-quality game which for some reason has made a disproportionately significant impression on the amateur IF scene" --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| Fallacy of Dawn, by Robb Sherwin 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( ) --Anya Johanna DeNiro... Vote for this game | |
| Thaumistry: In Charm's Way, by Bob Bates 1 vote "Not out till September 2017. I'm calling this one early." [+]"Not out till September 2017. I'm calling this one early." --Billy Mays... Vote for this game | |
| Risorgimento Represso, by Michael J. Coyne 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
| Eat Me, by Chandler Groover 1 vote "The go-to example..." [+]"The go-to example for limited-parser games" ( ) --Adam Biltcliffe... Vote for this game | |
| Scapeghost, by Pete Austin 1 vote (No comment) [+](No comment) ( Vote for this game | |
Poll created on July 27, 2017
IFDB Home |
Contact Us |
Code of Conduct |
Terms of Service |
Privacy |
Copyrights & Trademarks |
API
IFDB is managed by the Interactive Fiction Technology Foundation.
It is funded by the donations of IF supporters like you.
All donations go to support the operation of this web site and IFTF's other services.