The Magpie Takes the Train by Mathbrush 2020 (31 ratings)

Map by Ade McT 2015 (30 ratings)

Mentula Macanus: Apocolocyntosis by One of the Bruces and Drunken Bastard 2011 (29 ratings)

Ether by MathBrush 2015 (29 ratings)

Dead Cities by Jon Ingold 2007 (29 ratings)

The Ascent of the Gothic Tower by Ryan Veeder 2014 (28 ratings)

Swigian by Mathbrush (as Rainbus North) 2017 (28 ratings)

The Life (and Deaths) of Doctor M by Michael D. Hilborn 2011 (28 ratings)

1958: Dancing With Fear by Victor Ojuel 2017 (28 ratings)

Dial C for Cupcakes by Ryan Veeder 2014 (28 ratings)

The Endling Archive by Kazuki Mishima 2009 (28 ratings)

Andromeda Apocalypse — Extended Edition by Marco Innocenti 2012 (27 ratings)

Adventurer's Consumer Guide by Øyvind Thorsby 2007 (27 ratings)

Alone by Paul Michael Winters 2020 (27 ratings)

Broken Legs by Sarah Morayati 2009 (27 ratings)

The Shadow in the Cathedral by Ian Finley and Jon Ingold 2009 (26 ratings)

A Rope of Chalk by Ryan Veeder 2020 (26 ratings)

Ollie Ollie Oxen Free, by Carolyn VanEseltine (2013)
(26 ratings)

Earl Grey, by Rob Dubbin and Allison Parrish (2009)
(26 ratings)

Mirror and Queen by Chandler Groover 2016 (25 ratings)