Kerkerkruip by Victor Gijsbers 2011 (62 ratings)

Pytho's Mask by Emily Short 2001 (62 ratings)

Hunger Daemon by Sean M. Shore 2014 (61 ratings)

Robin & Orchid by Ryan Veeder and Emily Boegheim 2013 (59 ratings)

Aotearoa by Matt Wigdahl 2010 (57 ratings)

Nightfall by Eric Eve 2008 (56 ratings)

Color the Truth by mathbrush 2016 (56 ratings)

Best of Three by Emily Short 2001 (56 ratings)

Narcolepsy by Adam Cadre 2003 (56 ratings)

Foo Foo by Buster Hudson 2016 (53 ratings)

Alias 'The Magpie' by J. J. Guest 2018 (52 ratings)

Oppositely Opal by Buster Hudson 2015 (51 ratings)

Three-Card Trick by Chandler Groover 2016 (51 ratings)

Chlorophyll by Steph Cherrywell 2015 (49 ratings)

PataNoir by Simon Christiansen 2011 (49 ratings)

Earth and Sky 2: Another Earth, Another Sky by Paul O'Brian 2002 (49 ratings)

The Wand by Arthur DiBianca 2017 (48 ratings)

Rover's Day Out by Jack Welch and Ben Collins-Sussman 2009 (48 ratings)

A Beauty Cold and Austere by Mike Spivey 2017 (47 ratings)

Bigger Than You Think by Andrew Plotkin 2012 (46 ratings)