Have you played this game?

You can rate this game, record that you've played it, or put it on your wish list after you log in.

IF Derby

by Sarah Willson (as 'Hedda Deadline') profile

(based on 14 ratings)
Estimated play time: 5 minutes (based on 3 votes)
Members voted for the following times for this game:
4 reviews — 18 members have played this game.

About the Story

And they're off! Get in on the action as the competitors jockey for position. Who will be the big winner this time? Place your bets and find out!

Awards

Ratings and Reviews

5 star:
(0)
4 star:
(3)
3 star:
(10)
2 star:
(1)
1 star:
(0)
Average Rating: based on 14 ratings
Number of Reviews Written by IFDB Members: 4

3 Most Helpful Member Reviews

4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
"So, what cool titles did I miss in this game? I mean, comp?", October 25, 2026*
by Andrew Schultz (Chicago)
Related reviews: IFComp 2026

I guessed wrong on Hedda Deadline's identity (up there with Ruderbager Doppleganger, pseudonymous author of "Last Minute" in my Pantheon of Best IFComp Pen Names, placement be hanged) and IF Derby's main point at first. But I don't feel particularly dumb. I think it should've been anonymous, not because it was an Alan Smithee sort of production, but because it could be construed as "Hey, vote for me and my positive message about not worrying too much about comp placement," whether or not the author submitted another game.

IF Derby reminded me of very old Pascal programs on the Apple II(!) where you could watch horses racing and they'd go forward a few random pixels each turn. But the horses did not have cool names. Here they do. Gameplay revolves around constant betting on horse races. While I loathe gambling and how it's permeated itself into our culture (prop bets in sports events that cause people to send profane messages to college basketball players who score a "meaningless" basket or, worse, betting if Nicolas Maduro would be removed from power, which seems ripe for manipulation) betting does have a pull to it. I'm smart enough to know I can't beat the House. There's something horrid to me about the House getting a 5% advantage and slowly squeezing its "customers" out. I've seen ways to outsmart the betting syndicates by getting the best odds each way on a sports contest. If I could, I would.

There's nothing much to do except enjoy the names. Each horse pays out for even odds, but there are eight in each race, so I grasped quickly that relying on the RNG was not the way to go. What was, then? Was it a scoldy game about how gambling is bad? Somehow, I doubted this, with the amusing horse names. The horse name "Jugglenauts" particularly made me smile as it's a word I'd thought of but would never use, so I'm glad it has a place. Also included, a riff on a New York Times best-seller with grawlixes in its title, many takeoffs/pastiches of popular text adventures or TV shows or classic books (e.g. The Island of Dr. (redacted–play it yourself!)), what not to do with a sword (I won't spoil it!), some deliberately reductive titles, and a creative main character name in the title. Perhaps the only downside is that the horse names seemed to appear randomly, thus creating a reverse coupon problem for "did I see everything?" (I'd be glad to be wrong.) Perhaps a weighted randomizer, where names you hadn't seen for a while bubble to the top, would be a cool post-comp tweak. Because you only have finite money, so the RNG can sting you, if you bet $20 of your original $500 at a time and don't pick up on what to do. (Fortunately the names are in the source! I enjoyed looking. I forgot Arbelos was a word. It reminded me of long ago math contests. Mysterious word until I found out what it meant! The titles have enough variety, they might do that for you, too.)

I wouldn't have minded losing but I wanted to be able to say I had my thinking cap on and rose to the challenge, and rise I did. I followed a few false trails and enjoyed seeing others'. Some very smart people appeared to have trouble, and that made me feel better about the patterns I thought I saw but didn't.

My main takeaway at first was about how gambling etc. is exciting until you know what to do, then it feels unfair in your favor, which doesn't make up for it being unfair against you. And how much/what sort of success/failure balance do we need to feel accomplished? Once I knew what to do, I got tired quickly. The excitement was gone. I kind of nodded through the end, which felt like fluff. (It was late.) I felt constant worry the game might change the rules on me and leave me broke. Was this some sort of mean massive long con? Would I get arrested for knowing insider secrets, or would the racetrack not pay out because of "suspicious betting irregularities?" (Again, it was late. But I felt like I'd had good luck figuring what to do. And luck doesn't last.) As I piled up dolla bills, I stopped paying attention to the names. Part of this is due to seeing most of them, and part of it was a "just win baby" attitude that overtook me. Even in a game that didn't ultimately matter. A sobering psychological experiment, whether or not it was intended.

Then on replay I read through the dialogue more carefully, and I got what the author was really trying to say.

We don't want to get too far into the weeds at "Look! Metafiction!" here. There's always a chance that metafiction is a pure copout, or it's what you write when the story you really want to write falls through. (It sort of felt like that in my own 2026 entry.) In this case the author nods to having a deadline and wanting to write something good even if it wasn't what they wanted, and I think they put something fun out there, without being all "HEY LOOK I WROTE SOMETHING RANDOM BEFORE THE DEADLINE, IT WAS FUN, IT TOTALLY HAS MULTIPLE INTERPRETATIONS AND NOT GROSS INCONSISTENCIES OR OVERGENERALIZATION."

So my first time through I felt the game touched on themes of cheating to win, whether or not you'd be happy doing so, how tough a game should be, and whether or not a walkthrough would improve the experience. (Here, it would have taken away.) It's not new to say it's no fun to be told the right answers to an exam or to getting ahead unfairly in life (people still search for them anyway), but this is very cheerily done for a black and white game, and it's always good to have a new perspective on the questions the game brings up.

And the game is under no illusions it is being brilliant and profound. It's not being stupid, but it does address questions we have had before, of the "should I bother" sort. It makes us feel the struggle to do or write or be more is worth it, and if it came too easy, it wouldn't be worth sharing. It touches on the struggle to be creative without wallowing in frustration or begging others to like it, and it leaves us with this question among others: how do we help the player feel like they've won, without making it too hard or too easy? It even gives us a few answers and examples without being one.

I felt a bit silly having missed the author's main point, or what seemed to be the main point based on others' discussion. Its message, or at least what the crowd agreed its message was, boiled down to something cliched if someone said it: (Spoiler - click to show)Do your best, and that is good enough. But, of course, there's no best way to say that, even if there are plenty of good enough ways to, and they add up.

Short entries like IF Derby need a huge a-ha moment to place in the top half, and missing out is not due to lack of competence or effort on the author's part. It has no applause line. The positive message reaches no dramatic heights. The messages I found had that "I've seen/heard this" before. They don't blow you away. You figure you should have known them, and you feel bad half forgetting them, or not focusing on them enough. The long dialogue with an NPC at the end does not move mountains, but it reminds us why we're here. It made me want to go look at other entries that I might not match up well with on paper. The author admits they'd rather have written something longer, but I'm very glad they did what they could. And it reminded me of other entries that did what they could and did well. And just having the random horse names and calculating the likelihood I missed one made me think: what IFComp gems did I miss that would have made me happy? Which entries/horse names would other people find dumb that I loved, and vice versa? I sort of wanted to read more horse names, and yet, there might not be time or money to appreciate them all. (Well, in-game.)

I didn't really act on or live out these thoughts during the judging period, alas. I didn't review nearly as many IFComp entries as I meant. But I appreciate this motivation to see and do and connect more without full-on FOMO. So I think IF Derby gives us something we need, in a different guise than we are used to, and maybe you will find more if you follow sporting events or whatever. The conflict between trying to win and enjoying the horses' names stayed with me. Eventually, trying to win won out, and even when I was piling up money, a part of me didn't want to win too soon because what if there was one more horse, but I felt silly not using the strategy I figured. This is not a great moral dilemma of our time, but I enjoyed reflecting on it. I found it very good value for the time, with the interface and graphics and names, and I can see people recalling it fondly or taking motivation from it after games above it have sunk out of memory.

* This review was last edited on October 26, 2026
Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
I'm So Meta, Even This Acronym, September 5, 2026

An IFComp game about gambling on which horse will win the horse derby - er, which game will win IFComp. There are some fun references in there, like "Type Quit", "Fortnight", or "Uninteractive Taco Fiction". If you're lucky, you might even be able to bet on the game "IF Derby". And there are some interesting games I'd check out if they were real, like "Could You Be an AI?", "Sun Staring Simulator" (playtime: >2 hours), or "Hypnotic Brainwashing Tool (Do Not Play)". Someone make "Hypnotic Brainwashing Tool (Do Not Play)" into a real game so I can play it.

Direct link | View comments (2) | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Going off-piste, November 3, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

I’ve been playing, reviewing, and rating the Comp for more years now than I care to contemplate, and while some thing have become second nature, I still do struggle with that last element when it comes to judging the incredible range of games on offer according to a single ten-point scale, especially where length is the primary axis of difference. Is there a principled reason to rate two games of comparable quality differently when one lasts five minutes and the other goes well beyond the two-hour judging window? Does it even make sense to talk about “comparable quality” when the difference in what a super-short game can do and be good at, and what a longer game can do and be good at, often yawns so large that it becomes a difference of kind, not degree? I dunno, man, it’s tough. But what I do know is that when it comes to these amuse-bouche style experiences, I’m more than content if I get a single moment of intense engagement, which could be an “aha!” at a clever gameplay trick, or a laugh at a committing-to-the-bit joke, or just deep appreciation at one or two haunting, poetic lines of writing. Even if I’m not sure how to score such things later, I’m clear that that’s more than enough for success in my book.

IF Derby confounded my well-honed framework, though, by offering two distinct experiences of intense pleasure. But before getting to those, I have to describe what’s admittedly a pretty baroque setup for a piece of micro-IF. See, this is a meta game that transposes the action of the Comp into a literal horse-race: upon opening up the game, you’re presented with an octet of game titles – some of which are recognizable riffs on real games or genres, some of which are pure, entertaining nonsense – each of which is assigned to a different, lightly-animated horse (the game runs in Decker, and makes good use of the system’s pleasing Game Boy aesthetic). You start with $500, and are prompted to lay some or all of your stake on the horse of your choice. To help make your choice more informed, you’re given a smattering of data, including the number of reviews the game has received, both overall and on IFDB, as well as the IFDB average rating, and the all-important length of the game. And then you see the race, and if your horse comes in first, you pocket the winnings and get to try again.

This is a pretty basic set of interactions, elevated by the way the names create a rooting interest (I was personally very invested in Manly Napoleonic High Seas Adventure’s success, and vacillated on whether it was worth taking a flyer on dark horse Flying to Sydney in Real Time) but still clearly the purest trifle. Except that somehow this trifle managed to make me smile broadly to myself two different times, for two entirely different reasons.

The first is because as soon as I saw the oddmakers’ sheet of data, I thought to myself “hang on, is this implementing Autumn Chen’s ranking-prediction algorithm?” But I didn’t content myself with a laugh, I went and tracked down the original spreadsheet, extracted the formulas, and created my own Excel doc that I could plug IF Derby’s entrants into in order to see whether this helped my luck (which I confess had been quite poor until I took this step). I won’t spoil the outcome of this little bit of extracurricular activity, but I will say that it’s always a good thing when a game makes me create a spreadsheet, so it wins plenty of plaudits from me on this score.

The second is perhaps more in line with the game’s intended effect. I won’t spoil this one either – though for those who just played a round or two and bounced off, it’s worth going back and looking for something that appears slightly different in the post-race screen after you’ve been around the track a couple of times – but suffice to say that there’s a bit of writing that constitutes the game’s real ending, and while it’s as short, funny, and allegorical as the rest of IF Derby, I still felt like it had something real and worthwhile to say about the Comp, authorship, reviewing, and why we all keep going around doing this crazy thing year after year after year. If anything, that means I’ll have an even harder time than usual coming up with a rating – but believe me, I feel very, very happy to be faced with this particular dilemma.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.


Tags

- View the most common tags (What's a tag?)

(Log in to add your own tags)
Edit Tags
Search all tags on IFDB | View all tags on IFDB

Tags you added are shown below with checkmarks. To remove one of your tags, simply un-check it.

Enter new tags here (use commas to separate tags):

Delete Tags

Game Details

IF Derby on IFDB

Recommended Lists

IF Derby appears in the following Recommended Lists:

IFComp 2026 games playable in the UK by JTN
In response to the United Kingdom's Online Safety Act, the organisers of the 2026 IF Competition geoblocked some of the entries based on their content, such that they could not be played from a network connection appearing to originate...

RSS Feeds

New member reviews
Updates to external links
All updates to this page


This is version 5 of this page, edited by Dan Fabulich on 25 October 2026 at 11:52pm. - View Update History - Edit This Page - Add a News Item - Delete This Page