Ratings and Reviews by NothingPersonnel

View this member's profile

Show reviews only | ratings only
View this member's reviews by tag: Great Play Marathon 2026
1–10 of 41 | Next | Show All


WITHOUT corporation, by MAXFOG (from Without corp.)
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
Command line-heavy metafiction with sci-fi flair, October 18, 2026

I was expecting this game to be harder than it actually was based on Mathbrush's review, so I was pleasantly surprised to find it was very stable, didn't crash when it wasn't supposed to, and in general behaved as I expected it would, with some nice twists along the way. I played on Gargoyle, not online, and took copious notes, which helped.

There was a popular indie game going around some time ago called Dr. Langeskov, The Tiger, and The Terribly Cursed Emerald. In Dr. Langeskov, you come in expecting to play an ordinary 3D video game, but are instead roped into the behind-the-scenes action and forced to help set everything up, making sure all the props are in the right place, and all the light switches and weather dials have been properly tuned. It's a betrayal of the promised concept, but what it delivers is much more interesting. WITHOUT Corporation is just like that too; instead of playing the game yourself, you're roped into the behind-the-scenes work of manipulating game objects and routines so they run when they're supposed to, all so the actual player can have a good experience. You even get to see the actual player's review when you're done, and the score they assign to your game.

The game combines several ideas I've seen in other places in a stylish way. Dr. Langeskov is one, but there are others. One key difference between Dr. Langeskov and WITHOUT Corporation is that WITHOUT Corporation's fictional game-within-a-game, Climbing Up the Walls, is made with the assistance of generative AI, and you're tasked with fixing things up behind the scenes so the bugginess of the result isn't apparent. An echo of how real-life AI systems are backed up by humans who step in to intervene when things go haywire, such as with Waymo driverless cars.

I've been seeing more and more sci-fi stories about generative AI lately. Not stories written by generative AI, but stories by humans about its impact and the potential future it could hold for us. Unsurprisingly, most of these stories are bleak, and this one has some bleakness in it, though with a surprisingly hopeful ending.

I've always had a thing for AI and stories about AI even before real AI started spreading like kudzu, and the AI boom has led to even more stories about its various real and potential impacts. I'm thinking of Everything in Their Hands, which I played and really liked the first act of, and other short stories about AI like Turing Test (warning: contains slurs) or Emotional Intelligence Amplification. All of these stories have a common theme of making the reader question how human they are, if they might also be playing the role of a machine. Which everyone is, in a way, if they have to go to school and work a job and so on. People work themselves into a specific shape to get approval from the algorithms that determine success or failure, slotting themselves into the machine, pass the blunt etc.

As far as 'slotting themselves into the machine' goes: though I've never played Type Help, I have played (without finishing) Dunnet, which is a very programmer-ish parser game where you have to use actual terminal commands to win, necessitating a basic understanding of Bash among other things. This game is similar, very technical. You're not playing the game but behind the scenes of the game, setting things up for the actual player (who in a twist of irony, is of course a construct of code in our real world, where 'WITHOUT Corporation' is just Max Fog's 2026 IFComp entry). The game is very metafictional in that sense. It claims to use generative AI, but all the actual 'generative AI' is just human writing and action, specifically you and your sometimes-acerbic AI assistant. In fact, I'm familiar enough with generative AI and its writing style that I found the story's insistence that it was produced by generative AI to be very funny, given none of the telltale signs are there. Though I also don't like AI writing, so we all win here.

I think that part of the reason I had a surprisingly easy time with this game is that I spend a lot of time with various command lines, thinking about the outputs of various commands, so moving to a quasi-fictional command line and having to interpret those commands wasn't a big deal for me. I liked the general setup, though I think the backstory, for both WITHOUT Corporation and Climbing Up the Walls, was a little vague. Probably the AI backstory could've been tightened up by having more focus on a vastly reduced cast of characters, and (Spoiler - click to show)more detail on the personal life of the employee whose diary we get access to - as a form of humanization and characterization - instead of just talk about the AI project. Similarly, I think the story for Climbing Up the Walls was kind of vague, and despite the postive 'reviews' the game got on our fictional Intfiction, I felt like the ending was really abrupt and didn't answer any of my burning questions, which made me wonder if I was missing something or if there was a second part of the game that I never got access to. I did upgrade using the (Spoiler - click to show)ZILF update.wit -A command, but I'm not actually sure what that accomplished. I thought an upgraded interpreter might mean the game would crash less, but maybe it was just a necessary milestone for progressing the meta-story that had no effect on Climbing Up the Walls itself.

Having to go through the same setup for Climbing Up the Walls did get tiring, and I think I figured out the right sequence of actions within the first one or two playthroughs, so if there was a faster way to skip the intro, that would've been appreciated. I played Climbing Up the Walls maybe three or four times in total to get to the true ending, I think four times; (Spoiler - click to show)I got kicked out the 2nd time by the AI for failing to move Felipe, and once the player did the UNDO thing at the end that made the screen glitch out, but my first and last runs went surprisingly smooth. I also really didn't like that there was no 'wait' command for you to wait for the player to do things. I ended up using 'x sky' instead, which doesn't print much text, but.

I thought the metafictional aspects and AI aspects were cool, but since I'd seen them before, I wish there was more bite to them, something that went above and beyond what those other stories did that I'd already read. On reflection, I think another part of it is that a big issue with modern AIs is that they really don't have interiority, they really aren't conscious or sentient, they just act like they do and in that sense 'hook' humans into relating to and depending on them. An emotional hyperstimulus. But despite this game using a lot of the language around modern generative AI and LLMs, it still plays with more old-school scifi tropes like (Spoiler - click to show)'accurate digital recreation of a human mind' and 'AIs with genuine emotions, feelings and interiority', something I believe is firmly out of the reach of modern LLMs - despite the proclamations of many to the contrary - and furthermore something I believe will always be out of reach of modern LLMs, as long as there's no drastic change in the technology. Mixing those oldschool tropes with modern LLM terms uncritically, without ever delving into or playing with the possibility that the AIs featuring in this story are totally nonsentient, nonconscious philosophical zombies, bothers me since it implies that modern LLMs, too, could be conscious or sapient on some level, which is an idea that annoys me. End digression.

If you're interested in AI or metafiction and don't mind screwing around with some heavy programmer-type command line stuff, playing this will be a fun two hours.


Walkthrough for Climbing Up the Walls, from what I figured out:

(Spoiler - click to show)

[On starting the game]

queue wake-up 5

[Wait until wake-up happens]

queue wind-whips -1

move gown to dresser

queue felipe-waits -1

[Wait until the player goes to the entrance hall]

move felipe to entrance-hall

[Wait until the player goes to felipe's bedroom, this usually happens 1 turn after]

move felipe to felipe-bedroom

[Wait for player to go to front yard? or before?]

move torch to front-yard

[Then just wait.]

And the ending command, which took me around three failed attempts to figure out because I didn't realize what I was supposed to do and ended up just brute-forcing the (Spoiler - click to show)ZILF command with every combination of target files and letter flags until I found it: (Spoiler - click to show)ZILF MFog.zip -C

Also, the password for each secret file is (Spoiler - click to show)the first three letters under ROT13, and then the month and day it was edited. Though I could never figure out how to get to the .docx file, maybe I just typed in the password wrong for that one?

I think Josh Grams got to a lot of this stuff before me, but writing it down anyway for people who check IFDB in the future.


It also occurred to me that the description of each Climbing Up the Walls command could be useful, so here they are:

(Spoiler - click to show)

LIST (syntax = LIST ROUTINES/GOALS/ROOMS/—)

Lists all subjects from a certain category. If category not specified, ROOMS willbe applied.

Alternative syntax for LIST ROOMS: LIST/LOOK/L. (Because I know you’re going to never learn otherwise.)

Alternative syntax for LIST ROUTINES: ROUTINES.

Alternative syntax for LIST GOALS: GOALS.

=

EXAMINE (syntax = EXAMINE/X [any])

Provides limited information on a game object or a routine.

Example uses:

> EXAMINE AP

> X WINDOW

> X WAKE-UP

=

MOVE (syntax = MOVE/M [obj] TO [obj])

Changes the location of a single object.

Example uses:

> MOVE AP TO AP-BED

> M TORCH TO DRAWER

=

QUEUE (syntax = QUEUE/Q [rtn] TO/FOR/— [num])

Pushes a routine to run in a number of player turns. If the number in [num] is -1, the routine is run every round indefinitely, or until dequeued. Queueing an already-queued routine will overwrite the old queueing instead of adding a new one. To see possible routines, use ROUTINES.

Queueing routines for 0 or a number below -1 is illegal. To run a routine for the current turn, use RUN.

Example uses:

> QUEUE WAKE-UP TO 3

> Q WIND-WHIPS -1

=

DEQUEUE (syntax = DEQUEUE/D [rtn])

Pulls an queued routine from the game queue. Only applies if a routine isqueued (for example, if “Wake-up in 3” is displayed, it is queued).

Example uses:

> DEQUEUE WIND-WHIPS

> D WAKE-UP

=

RUN (syntax = RUN/R [rtn])

Immediately runs a routine.

Example uses:

> RUN WEAR-GOWN

> R CLEAR-RTNS

=

GOALS (syntax = GOALS)

Lists all current goals.

=

FILES (syntax = FILES/DATA)

Opens read-only file accessibility mode.

=

KEY (syntax = KEY ON/OFF/—)

Toggles per-turn keypress, for accessibility vs. aesthetics.

=

COLOR (syntax = COLOR)

Allows editing of input colors. This is disabled in COLOR-OFF and SCREENREADER mode.

=

ASK

Provides limited information on a current goal or command. Also is used to prompt AI to diagnose function of a routine.

Example uses:

> ASK QUEUE > ASK WAKE-UP

> A GOWN

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Ḫattušumna Laḫḫa, by Daniel Stelzer, Daniel E. Gaskell, and Tim Leonard
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
A novel and fascinating game about the Hittite language, October 17, 2026

Some scattered thoughts:

  • A lot of work went into the UI and translation mechanics. It looks amazing. Awesome stuff.

  • The educational value of this game is off the charts. It does take a lot of mental work, between the puzzles and deciphering what's going on, but the result is worth it. My advice would be to resort to the clues early on when stuck.

  • During the second adventure, I ran into some memory errors that necessitated restarting the game, but the dev pushed an update right afterwards that should hopefully stop this from happening. I think it's tied to complexity of input and length of game history, so the best way to avoid it - if you're paranoid that it might still happen - would probably be to save frequently and resort to the walkthrough when stuck.

  • It wasn't immediately obvious to me that Bound Transcription in the settings is an option that can be changed to display everything in cuneiform. I knew that cuneiform display was an option because the main menu said so, but didn't realize that was the toggle for it. I wished I'd discovered it earlier, because it's fascinating to me to play through chunks of the game in cuneiform. My knowledge of it isn't good enough to play the entire game in cuneiform, however, and I found it made the 'double-click to insert' behavior more unintuitive since it was harder for me to decipher word boundaries. A lack of experience on my part.

Make no mistake, this is a very enjoyable game, especially if you're fond of linguistics and learning about different languages and writing systems. If I had to offer a main criticism, it would be that I wished the game focused more on grammatical features and aspects of cuneiform (e.g. what determines the cuneiform to Roman letter mapping? Are there certain aspects of cuneiform that get certain letters?) instead of puzzles, but this is bias on my part since I'm not hugely interested in puzzles.

Also, the second adventure made me hungry.

The comments below consist mainly of additional nitpicking.

  • Semi-playable on mobile, which I initialy tried. The interface, typing, clicking and all that seemed to work fine - the default layout is large and packed with a bunch of things, but I made it work by zooming out and using landscape mode. But the one thing that didn't work was hovering over the grammatical cases of the different definitions to see what nominative, dative, and so on actually meant. I gave up on mobile pretty fast since I didn't feel like wracking my brain to remember the grammatical cases, and didn't feel like I'd get the complete experience without them.

  • Can't copy-paste any in-game text. Annoys the part of me that wants to just put everything into Google Translate, but I just checked and Hittite isn't even available in Google Translate, so it's probably for the best.

  • If there are multiple translation footnotes (parser errors), the older ones fade so only the newest is available, which is mildly annoying but I can't think of a better solution. Maybe if you could hover over the older parser errors to see them in full.

  • First adventure took me about an hour. Fun, but I dislike that you can only (Spoiler - click to show)use the water in the pithos one time before it disappears (why?). The first time I accidentally used it to extinguish the torch instead of extinguishing the fire. Then I had to go to the riverbank and fill it again. Some experiences I had during the first adventure were akin to 'guess the intended command' (no 'guess the verb', as all available verbs are listed) since commands like 'put water on fire' didn't work and I had to use 'put pithos (with water in it) on fire' instead? Also, the aforementioned confusion between 'extinguish fire' and 'extinguish flaming torch'.

  • Second adventure had more unintuitive puzzles in my opinion that made me resort to invisiclues. The part I got stuck on was (Spoiler - click to show)making the reeds last long enough. I forgot about the oil and became fixated on the idea of relighting the door bar with a flaming reed, since lighting the door bar worked in the first adventure. Then I couldn't understand why that didn't work.

  • Third one I admittedly gave up on since it had been 3 hours at that point and I was tired. I actually identified the perpetrator on the first try, but didn't realize (Spoiler - click to show)I was supposed to dance towards him. I think I misinterpreted the tablets and thought that the king would kill anyone who danced or bowed, no matter who they were doing it to.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

when i was shot by elephants, by no m3rcy
NothingPersonnel's Rating:

Money for Girls: Amortized, by Porpentine
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
A full-fledged commercial visual novel, September 26, 2026*

Money for Girls may be my favorite Porpentine game I've ever played. I've played all of their major IF games, though some of it was many years ago and imperfectly remembered by now. Their more recent short stories and novels I'm more familiar with and have read a significant number of. The writing style is dense, elaborate and lurid. There is beauty and grotesquerie intermingled (along with significant sexual references, though nothing explicit in this particular story). MindApe called the writing style Ballardian, but Porpentine's recent fiction always makes me think of the one Poppy Z Brite short story collection I read, Are You Loathsome Tonight?.

I think this may be Porpentine's first Steam game, though I'm not sure. It costs around $10 depending on your location. You could call it Porpentine's return to IF after a while focusing on static fiction, though the game is a visual novel with heavy emphasis on the visuals, so not only pure text.

Porpentine's earlier IF, as I remember it, has a dissociative quality, with characters glimpsed only hazily and never in full, including the protagonists. Not true of this story, where our protagonist, the unfortunately named Cancer Prize, is a full-fleshed character with her own full-fledged relationships to the other characters. There are only five named characters in the cast, by my counting, and the game is long enough that you can spend hours with each of them, gradually learning their quirks and foibles, their dark secrets and shames. Given this is a visual novel, there's emphasis on dialogue and a lot of script-formatted dialogue, but it works. A coming update, planned for October, will hopefully add even more story to the characters who currently don't get so much screen time.

The story is generally slice-of-life, set in a bizarre tropical fantasy setting where parasitic fibers and their aristocratic hosts run rampant, along with the "agents of INNOCENT" trained to counter them. There's a time sim aspect: You have a limited number of weeks to save your mother from debt, and in each week you can choose from two activities to do. An activity might be shopping, or spending time with your crush, or trying to get money through various dubiously legal means. Character customization options add unique dialogue and potential for replay. I especially liked Endometriosis, essentially the "hard mode" option, and something rarely depicted in fiction.

You can really just look at the Steam reviews if you want an idea of what this game is about and whether it will appeal to you. There's a lot more to be said about the game, but it's been said there by people who are more dedicated to it than I could be.

A last note: The protagonist's relationship with her mother is wonderfully depicted and heartfelt. I particularly appreciated that (Spoiler - click to show)Cancer's mother was an emotionally abusive alcoholic in the past, who hurt her daughter very badly but is trying to make amends, and is actually succeeding at being a good parent. As you might expect from Porpentine, the story is told with cold-eyed lucidity and no naivete, without shying away from the darker aspects of what her mother did. Which only makes it better. It's hard here to draw a clear-cut line between 'abusive' and 'non-abusive', hard to reconcile past behavior with present actions. As it should be, because fiction mirrors life.

* This review was last edited on September 27, 2026
Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

The ecology of the waterways of Mars, by Liza Daly
An old-school science-fiction utopia, September 26, 2026

I think this one is best appreciated if you know something about Sara Weiss, the real person whose work this game is based on, and her real book this game is based on: Journeys to the Planet Mars (1903). Liza Daly has written an analysis of the book, which serves as a companion to this game. It's something of a retro-utopia. An interesting bit of history. The illustrations do well bringing it to life.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

how to make a personal game, by Anna Anthropy
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
Was it a cynical cash grab or a personal game?, September 26, 2026*

A. It was a cynical cash grab that was totally transparent about being such.

B. It was a personal game that used the frame of a cynical cash grab to discuss personal themes.

This game was written more than a decade ago. Anna Anthropy was part of the early so-called "queer personal games" Twine scene, which I think fell apart after some controversy (it was before my time, but I've heard undeserved harassment from Gamergate played a big part in it). The past notwithstanding, I liked this game, which is to some degree about the pains of being known solely for "queer personal games". Everyone is talking about how brave you are for making them, even though you may be increasingly cynical about whether it's just another marketing niche you've been pigeonholed into, the "brand" that defines you and your audience. And bad things result when your online "thing" becomes taking all your secrets and personal life details, all your trauma and painful memories, and publishing them for your audience. Making yourself vulnerable for profit. But you have to do it to live, and so many people aren't even famous as artists, and aren't you lucky?

"why are you still in this field when most of the women in games you know have already quit? do you ever worry about being left behind? do you ever feel like you'd be accomplishing more in another field?"

"must you always compare yourself to other women? isn't that exactly what the patriarchy wants us to do, to set us against each other?"

"if you're making games "for yourself," why do you care so much about who else plays them? (hint: you're not making games for yourself. don't even.)"

There's self-awareness and self-hatred about how this seems to be the only path forward. But what other paths can there be?

* This review was last edited on October 17, 2026
Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

EMPATHY MACHINE, by Merritt Kopas
What is empathy?, September 26, 2026

As described in the ending, this game by Merritt Kopas was directly inspired by Sophie Houlden's response to Ben Kuchera's review of Gender Swap, which runs on a system called The Machine to Be Another. I don't know any of these people and haven't played Gender Swap, so already we're deep in the rabbit hole here.

Empathy Machine takes less than five minutes, if even that, to finish. The short length necessitates brevity, and I didn't like that you have to click each short line to progress, since repetitive clicking is hard on me. But the concept was interesting. There's an "empathy machine" that lets you experience life as a different gender; you're able to try it out and are asked if it worked. Are you more empathetic now?

The Machine to Be Another, as described by Sophie Houlden, is "a couple of VR headsets with cameras on them – each headset displaying the view recorded by the other". Gender Swap uses this technology to let you experience being the opposite gender in VR. Seems cool, but Kuchera got a lot of flak for essentially implying that playing Gender Swap would make cis men more empathetic to the trans experience because they get to experience what it's like to be in the body of a women. Houlden says:

"It’s not about swapping gender, it’s about tricking your brain into thinking you’re a different sex – for a few minutes, in a safe environment where you can quickly step out if things aren’t going how you please. Sure you can put your eyeballs in the head of another for a few minutes (and yes, this is really interesting stuff!) but you’re not in that head yourself. You don’t know what it’s like to have had to live with that body.

You haven’t had to experience with how people treat that body. You haven’t felt pressure to change based on the expectations of having that body. The bodies we are born with force us to have experiences which are outside our control. These experiences shape us as people and who we are in our minds is not so easily separated from them. You can put on the headset and look at a mirror, but you have no idea what life the body’s owner will return to when you take the headsets off. Like I say, it’s an interesting idea but it’s important nobody thinks “Oh, so this is what it’s like to be X” because your life is more than what you see – it’s also years of other people seeing you, speaking to you, touching you AND how they do all that. It’s what you see happen to people who are like you and people who are not. It’s your own head thinking for years on end trying to come to terms with all of this. You can’t be someone else without going through this."

All of this happened more than a decade ago and I'm sure the people involved have thoroughly moved on by now. But the internet, or the Internet Archive in this case, never forgets.

The overall message is that while it may be useful or educational to spend a little time in someone else's shoes, whether it's through reading a book or playing a game or what have you, it will never capture the full experience of what it's like to be someone else, and you shouldn't delude yourself into thinking it can. Especially when it comes to wanting to "emphasize with" and "help" vulnerable groups, it's better to talk to people from those groups instead of just assuming on behalf of your technology.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

The Game Formerly Known as Hidden Nazi Mode, by Victor Gijsbers
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
A game that works against itself, September 25, 2026*

A metafictional exercise. It's hard to say anything that hasn't been said already, particularly in Drew Cook's excellent and lengthy analysis. But it's crucial to me that, as pointed out by others, the game does have a hidden Nazi mode in it: (Spoiler - click to show)all you need is to type "join the ss".

I basically agree with Cook's essay linked above; I think the version of the game without the hidden Nazi mode would be more compelling. The actual Nazi mode is badly done and punctures the fear, the horror, and the elaborate, multilayered metafiction with jokey references to the Holocaust. Compared to what's there, it would've been better if the Nazi mode was left to the reader's imagination. Nonetheless, I do think the game has spawned some interesting discussion and analysis.

* This review was last edited on October 18, 2026
Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

10 Games We Played on Long Car Rides and in Standby Lines at Disney, by Harper Shen
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
Short autobiographical game about a college romance, September 23, 2026

I think your appreciation of this game will be based on how easily you can fit yourself into the shoes of the two main characters, the starring couple. There's not much detail given as to who they are, and to some extent you're expected to insert yourself into their positions, playing both one and the other. The characters are vague, to facilitate this, but I wish they were less so since I wanted to know more about them.

We can presume the "you" is Chinese, since they bring up certain topics like the 2010 Expo, which took place in Shanghai. But we don't know much else about these two people and how they came to be in Florida. Not even what college they go to. I very badly wanted to know about how they met, what their families are like, why they decided to go into game development instead of another life path, and what happened to them later on.

It's possible that the vagueness is because the author wishes to safeguard their privacy, since the game is autobiographical, but I'd rather read something that diverges heavily from the truth, while still drawing on the author's own experiences, than something that sticks close to it while remaining light on detail.

Something that affected my personal reception of this game is that I've never experienced a relationship like this and don't want to. The memories that came to mind, for me, had uncomfortable and discomfiting associations. This made it hard for me to participate in the game's vision, to imagine myself as either protagonist. I kept wanting something darker. The hidden resentments stewing beneath the facade. The game addresses this in the ending, to some degree: (Spoiler - click to show)can you believe that something like this really happened, or is it a lie too good to be true? Is a perfect relationship nothing more than a game, a story we tell ourselves, a fantasy inevitably sundered by reality?

I liked this, but felt like there wasn't enough of it. We only get so quick a glimpse beneath the facade, and ultimately the story is a light and pleasantly cozy one about a romantic relationship. Reader mileage may vary.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

IF Derby, by Sarah Willson (as 'Hedda Deadline')
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
I'm So Meta, Even This Acronym, September 5, 2026

An IFComp game about gambling on which horse will win the horse derby - er, which game will win IFComp. There are some fun references in there, like "Type Quit", "Fortnight", or "Uninteractive Taco Fiction". If you're lucky, you might even be able to bet on the game "IF Derby". And there are some interesting games I'd check out if they were real, like "Could You Be an AI?", "Sun Staring Simulator" (playtime: >2 hours), or "Hypnotic Brainwashing Tool (Do Not Play)". Someone make "Hypnotic Brainwashing Tool (Do Not Play)" into a real game so I can play it.

Direct link | View comments (2) | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.


1–10 of 41 | Next | Show All