Return to the game's main page

All Member Ratings

5 star:
(279)
4 star:
(199)
3 star:
(73)
2 star:
(22)
1 star:
(3)
Average Rating: based on 576 ratings
Number of Reviews Written by IFDB Members: 45
Previous | << 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >> | Next | Show All


- Sergio (Trento, Italy), November 30, 2017

4 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
sentimental drivel, poor writing, but brilliant use of the medium, October 24, 2017

I really wanted to enjoy this. As far as I understand it, the game was fairly groundbreaking use of the medium at the time. As it stands now, I would not recommend this piece to anyone I would want to get interested in interactive fiction. The writing is genuinely bad, the overall theme of the story feels like someone beating you over the head with cheap emotional shots, and it isn't very interactive at all- text heavy and slow to move into anything resembling action. I have trouble understanding why so many have resonated with this piece, why there's a sense of reverence around it. I have a feeling it's related to timing on my part-and I don't wish to slam anyone who related to or was moved by the piece--I just can't see it.

The interwoven nature of the game is brilliant. I'm sure it is, because everyone has said so. But in my opinion, this is a really good example of telling, not showing.

Cadre's other works are breathtaking, so I will say that I feel I must be missing something-- the rave reviews regarding this work make me want to understand the appeal.

You can log in to rate this review, mute this user, or add a comment.

- jakomo, September 21, 2017

- xochie, September 17, 2017 (last edited on September 18, 2017)

- enkaye (usa), August 31, 2017 (last edited on September 1, 2017)

- ja, bo ja, August 28, 2017

- karlnp (Vancouver, BC), August 22, 2017 (last edited on August 23, 2017)

- Wanderlust, August 3, 2017

- Ivanr, August 1, 2017

- doodlelogic, July 27, 2017 (last edited on August 19, 2021)

- gilhova, July 18, 2017 (last edited on July 19, 2017)

5 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
Thoroughly disappointing, July 11, 2017

At the beginning of the game, there is a sense of intrigue: shifting perspectives are used to spiral around a single character, building up hype for a grand conclusion. The story's direction and pacing is held on a tighter leash than in your average IF game. At first, this was exciting. However, it soon became clear that the plot was headed nowhere.

While the story was outright bad, the storytelling just failed to live up to its potential. Exploration was frustrating. Although the puzzles are easy, when I couldn't figure out what to do, it became maddening very quickly due to the bleak, dull and unresponsive environments. However, these worlds were still the most interesting part of the game.

The game can be ultimately seen as a character study. The main character is a pretty, creative, nice, mysterious, hardworking, middle-class girl with a nice family who is loved by everyone around her, and faces no meaningful challenges. She is also not only smart, but a genius. I hated this character. I could not believe in her struggle. Throughout every scene with her I inwardly pleaded the writer to give her some dialogue or trait that I could actually connect with, but this never happened -- almost everyone else in the story existed to further highlight how wonderful she is. Parts of her life read like a bad teen movie. Since the whole game revolves around such a nondescript, almost mythical figure, I couldn't bring myself to like the game.

Nonetheless, I would have appreciated it in hindsight if it went somewhere thematically. But sadly, (Spoiler - click to show)I predicted the story's ending very near to the start -- which made everything tedious. I resented the lazy attempts at emotion, I resented the (Spoiler - click to show)fact that Ally died in a car crash of all things -- the most cliche and unimaginative sort of death, and not even the most likely, as if good people can only die in random car crashes -- and I resented the characterization of Rob as a textbook villain, as this took the away any philosophical meaning that could have been gleaned from the event. The (Spoiler - click to show)lack of an ending was the final nail in the coffin for me.

To be fair, this game is technically fine. I would have dismissed it as "decent" had I played it at the time of its release, with lowered expectations. But playing it today, I oscillated between feeling bored and irritated, curious and let down. You might like it if you are an absolute beginner to the medium, or if you are easily moved by sob stories, but otherwise, don't get your hopes up.

You can log in to rate this review, mute this user, or add a comment.

- Targor (Germany), June 4, 2017

- ly2000, June 3, 2017 (last edited on June 4, 2017)

- Cory Roush (Ohio), June 3, 2017

- Kyriakos Sgarbas (Hellas (Greece)), May 25, 2017

- pox, March 18, 2017

- Pegbiter (Malmö, Sweden), February 14, 2017

- lkdc, February 11, 2017

- RoboDragonn, January 31, 2017 (last edited on April 1, 2020)

- TheAncientOne, January 28, 2017

- John of Thornwick, January 11, 2017

- imelda, December 29, 2016

- Prosilire (New York City), December 16, 2016 (last edited on December 3, 2017)

- piffling-paka (State College, Pennsylvania), December 6, 2016


Previous | << 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >> | Next | Show All | Return to game's main page