Ratings and Reviews by Denk

View this member's profile

Show reviews only | ratings only
View this member's reviews by tag: ADRIFT 3.8 ADRIFT 4 ADRIFT 5 Adventuron AGT BASIC Browser C64 ChoiceScript Custom system DAAD Dialog Eamon emulator Google Forms Infocom Inform Ink Level 9 PAW PunyInform Quest STAC Strand TADS Telarium Text document The Quill Twine Unity ZIL zx spectrum
Previous | 141–150 of 809 | Next | Show All


ConText NightSky, by XxTheSpaceManxX
Denk's Rating:

Improv: Origins, by Neil deMause
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
Bugged but excellent puzzles and very funny, January 31, 2023
by Denk
Related reviews: Inform

This is a very funny, puzzly, one-room parser comedy. However, it is also very hard and in the version I played, I had to work around a bug.

I rarely give a game with a significant game breaking bug five stars. In this case I made an exception because I realized that it was a bug and managed to work around it. Also, the author should be working on a 3rd version and I completed the 2nd version after having given up on the first version. So I think it is a shame if such an excellent game will be forgotten because the author didn't fix the bugs in time for ParserComp, even though the author is of course "responsible" (no one got hurt I suppose). In addition there are some other bugs which may require you to restore an earlier save, but they are quite obvious. So save often.

So if anyone found the game disappointing during ParserComp I understand.

I just think that this game is a real challenge: You start out with some rather easy puzzles and they gradually get harder, really hard. The hard ones are only very subtly clued but they are clued. But if you do not notice the clue you may have to start over to realize it - not sure, didn't investigate that issue.

Unless you are in a hurry, you might as well wait for the third version which hopefully takes care of those bugs and you will be playing an excellent parser comedy, assuming you love hard puzzles. However, knowing that there are bugs will probably make you notice it and quickly experiment to see what is triggering that bug. To me, the puzzles were great and the humor very funny so it was worth it to work around that bug.

You can log in to rate this review, mute this user, or add a comment.

Foreign Soil, by Olaf Nowacki
Denk's Rating:

Kenny Koala's Bushfire Survival Plan, by Garry Francis
Denk's Rating:

Captain Cutter's Treasure, by Garry Francis
Denk's Rating:

Calypso, by Dave Footitt
Denk's Rating:

Carpathian Vampire, by Garry Francis
Denk's Rating:

Morris, by Dee Cooke
Denk's Rating:

Wry, by Olaf Nowacki
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
I don't recall playing a better 1-room game, January 27, 2023
by Denk
Related reviews: Inform

Mild content warning: This game insinuates some adult situations.

This game is a one-room comedy parser game with a limited number of moves, multiple endings and you don't need maximum points to get a good ending. I managed to get 45/60 points before I gave up after starting over many, many times. Later I came back and reached 54/60 so the game is quite addictive.

Parser:
This is more or less the standard Inform parser which is always good unless the author by mistake ruins it. In this case it is good too. Also, there were no apparent ambiguity problems which can easily occur in a one-room game with many objects. The parser is as good as needed.

Atmosphere:
The writing is successfully humorous and gives the intended atmosphere I would expect.

Cruelty rating: Cruel
This type of game must be cruel. This is a game with a limited number of moves and you must learn from your mistakes by starting over and over again.

Puzzles:
There were nice, well-clued puzzles. If I had managed to solve all of them I would probably have given an even higher puzzle score. But as I don't know the unsolved solutions I can only evaluate the ones I solved.

Overall:
Everything in this game plays well together, resulting in a higher total score than each of the individual categories above. It is a well implemented, fun one-room comedy puzzle game where the goal is to get as many points as you can. Unless you get very stubborn and want to reach maximum points, there are not countless of hours in this game. But asking for more content is never a valid criticism but a compliment. However, in a competition like Spring Thing I think the longer game should win if I am equally entertained as long as it lasts. But rated as a short game, this was my favourite game in Spring Thing 2022.

You can log in to rate this review, mute this user, or add a comment.

Things that Happened in Houghtonbridge, by Dee Cooke
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
Atmospheric mystery, January 27, 2023
by Denk
Related reviews: Adventuron

This is a very well done game and one of the longer ones in ParserComp 2022, where you take the role of a studying teenager who is unravelling a mystery in the small, English town Houghton Bridge while you really should be studying. There will be indications of something supernatural (no more spoilers!). The story is overall pretty good.

Parser:
I never had a problem with the parser. Either the Adventuron parser is often improved or the author's programming skills play a significant role.

Atmosphere:
In some areas the atmosphere is decent whereas it is even better in others, e.g. creepy. Overall, a fitting atmosphere.

Cruelty rating: Merciful
There are multiple endings but you can apparently always reach some of them. I don't know if being locked out from some of the endings increases cruelty(?).

Puzzles:
All puzzles are fair and meaningful. The difficulty is around "medium", some a bit easier some a bit harder.

Overall (Rating: 9/10)
The story plays very well with the puzzles and the implementation is close to flawless. As a consequence, the resulting game is better than the individual parts. Very much recommended.

You can log in to rate this review, mute this user, or add a comment.


Previous | 141–150 of 809 | Next | Show All