by Dan Efran profile


Web Site

Return to the game's main page

Reviews and Ratings

5 star:
4 star:
3 star:
2 star:
1 star:
Average Rating:
Number of Ratings: 18
Write a review

1-18 of 18

- Edo, November 25, 2021

- kierlani, June 9, 2020

- Zape, April 28, 2020

- Arkaedi, October 18, 2018

- lkdc, March 11, 2017

- Mr. Patient (Saint Paul, Minn.), January 28, 2017

- E. W. B., March 18, 2016

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
An escape-the-room parser game based on Egyptian mythology, February 3, 2016

This was a short-to-mid-length enjoyable parser game. You awake from your slumber, buried in the egyptian way, and must progress into the afterlife.

The games takes the form of an escape game. You are given a spellbook of sorts, which you must use, but then you must solve a sequence of puzzles. Many of the puzzles seemed unintuitive to me, but because the game is short, it may be possible to just keep plugging away until you get it.

The atmosphere is very good. This game was recommended to me based on its characterization of Egyptian mythology, and this was the most entertaining aspect of the game.

Recommended for fans of mythology or escape games.

- Aryore, December 13, 2015

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
A mood piece, really, December 7, 2015
by Sobol (Russia)

Ka is a puzzle game; as the other reviewers pointed out, its overall aesthetics are quite close to some works by Andrew Plotkin.

And the puzzles are good. The last one felt particularly satisfying: "Oh my, a riddle. What the answer could be? Is it some common and well-known thing? Something specific to Ancient Egypt?.." - and then it dawned on me. (Spoiler - click to show)Kudos to the monster for not eating me up after the first wrong guess - like the Greek Sphinx used to do.

But the best thing about playing Ka is not the puzzle-solving, but the mood - and in this aspect, I think, it sometimes even out-Plotkins Plotkin. The familiar feeling of solemn loneliness, being surrounded by indifferent mechanisms, the calm and melancholy dream-like atmosphere - are mixed with a strong sense of transition, of leaving everything behind, untying all the bonds, abandoning your past and your earthly possessions which don't matter anymore; standing on a threshold of some new spiritual life.

We don't get to see this new life of the protagonist: that's left to our imagination. But we get a wonderful finale, in which, for one move only, the soul gets to interact with non-mechanical characters - and is no more alone. A short glimpse of divinity; making it longer would have marred the experience.

There are many interesting details along the way. The rhymed sestains are well-written and in the general vein of spells from the real Egyptian funerary texts; and typing >WEST in this game always feels special because of the symbolic significance of the West in Egyptian religion.

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Quite Disappointed with Puzzles, but Neat Atmosphere, June 17, 2013

This game is composed of a set of completely linear, self-contained puzzles: your goal, in a nutshell, is to solve puzzles in order to get through each and every obstruction preventing you from going west.

Now, none of the puzzles really stood out. There was one that was way, way too similar to a puzzle from Andrew Plotkin's The Dreamhold, and another one involved a very vaguely described board game being played, which totally broke the immersion for me. The magic system never really added much to the game: it was just there to provide an extra obvious move for you to do before continuing on with a puzzle. But, these puzzles may be great for people who are still getting used to IF.

But, this game is saved enough to get three stars from me by the very impressive atmosphere. There are very, very few (if any) objects or locations in this game that I didn't have a detailed picture of in my head, something that I cannot say even for many of my favorite works of IF. The atmosphere also gave a strange feeling of emotion that I can't really describe in my review and must be experienced through the game to understand (assuming it works on you).

I think this is a good game to show people getting into IF, and a good game to study if you want to think about describing your world. But, for puzzle design, it isn't impressive.

- Artran (Prague, Czech Republic), November 30, 2012

- Andrew Schultz (Chicago), April 29, 2012

- Ryan Veeder (Iowa), July 15, 2011

- Carlo, June 29, 2011

- perching path (near Philadelphia, PA, US), July 14, 2010

- Patrick M. McCormick (United States), June 5, 2010

13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
Egyptian-style puzzling, February 20, 2010

I had a lot of fun with this, and got stuck enough to check the walkthrough only once. It's a nearly pure-puzzle work, in which you play a soul moving towards the afterlife after a ceremonial Egyptian burial. The setting combines plausible historical detail with some surreal mechanisms and imagery; the writing at times feels a bit zarfian. The first few moves and environments are not actually the game's strongest and may feel somewhat underdeveloped, but the setting becomes more interesting later on.

The puzzles are neat set pieces, self-contained and linear; they are mostly not terribly hard. Early puzzles may seem almost *too* easy, but they teach needed techniques to solve the later ones, and should possibly be regarded as something of a tutorial.

There were one or two solutions that I thought could have been better clued or could have accommodated a larger range of vocabulary. Most are really rather elegantly imagined, however, and most suggest some kind of metaphorical or spiritual progression of the soul as well as the manipulation of physical objects.

I also noticed that there were some scenery objects that were unimplemented. However, when I played, Ka was undergoing some upgrades and polishing to make up for some remaining awkward bits, which may resolve my other objections.

Overall, Ka is an enjoyable lunchtime-sized puzzle fest with a coherent concept and some memorable details and imagery.

1-18 of 18 | Return to game's main page