Ratings and Reviews by Canalboy

Stonequest is an archetypal "complete quest for king and usurp evil tyrant" adventure which would pass as unremarkable but for possibly the most turgid and unimaginative maze in text adventure history. The game itself is composed of 245 rooms, 200 of which are a stone maze with unclimbable walls; there is a magic word that takes you to the maze exit but as you have to thoroughly map it to search for hidden objects that doesn't soften the blow too much.

The game is split into three parts with a codeword issued at the start of parts two and three to enable quick transit to the section you were last in but in these days of emulators and saved game options it is rendered redundant.

Many of the puzzles revolve around pushing furniture, drinking magic potions or saying magic words although there a couple of more imaginative ones, particularly a problem revolving around a canister and a room with green smoke. Many of the commands seem hard coded to the rooms where they work; for instance the trade verb will only work in certain places when talking to one of the game's NPCs. You have to persist with one particular character which may be a clever way of bartering successfully through persistence or may be a bug.

All of your objects are automatically jettisoned when moving from one phase to the next so at least you don't have to worry too much about applying manifold items to a puzzle or an inventory limit. The parser is a two word effort - it understands TAKE ALL but not "oops" or "back." The writing is reasonable but most rooms are merely backdrops to the puzzles. The first section is the largest and has the most varied geography and character interaction. When playing on the Altirra 4.21 emulator in CIO mode the game crashed at the end of part one but worked ok via 4.30. You can soft lock youself out of winning; howeverv this will be evident soon after the erroneous action. Unusually for a game of this vintage there are no dark areas and no lamp timer and no thirst or hunger daemons so feel free to wander randomly without any time pressure.

The denouement features a nice homage to one of the most famous sketches from Monty Python's Flying Circus. Personally I've never pressed wild flowers.

Où sont les neiges d'antan? It must be said that I had many a Proustian moment replaying this excellent Level 9 offering. It is 42 years since I purchased it for my Atari 800 amidst my 'A' levels at school back in 1983. Back in those distant days of The Tube on Channel Four and Gabichi golfing sweaters as the iconic fashion statement of the time I loaded up this game on my dodgy Atari tape recorder. It took about a quarter of an hour to load, if it loaded at all (about half the time it crashed) and I spent many an evening battling against carnivorous jellies when I should have been studying. Chivers give you shivers.

The DOS version essayed here is an enhanced one on the old Middle Earth offering e.g. it understands EXAMINE and UNDO but the Tolkien references are gone in the repackaged game so no Minas Tirith; this does not affect immersion in a detrimental fashion. Dungeon Adventure proffers a massive map of over 200 locations, cleverly crafted puzzles and as Gunness from CASA has noted, an eerily evocative and claustrophobic feel is engendered - steps and skeletal hands crumble; rats, corpses and slime proliferate the dungeons; there are no friendly faces (with one exception) to share the burden here and the oppressiveness and sense of isolated choice works extremely well. The descriptions are broodingly evocative and there is barely a typo to wince at as you pick your way through the Dantesque devastation, although in one location a statue may only be recognised as a sculpture. Occasional shafts of dry humour pierce the oppressive prose. What do rats flee?

Having just completed the game again I think I would taxonomise it as a game of medium difficulty. At the time it was probably the hardest game I had played but subsequent sufferings at the hands of the Phoenix authors have made me reassess its difficulty quotient. Some puzzles have multiple solutions too and there are a few outrageous puns as well as a handful of sudden death locations as well as an appearance by Zorro.

There is a very clever set piece section of the game in the central dungeon which comprises a huge spiral ramp, down upon which the Demon Lord used to watch the Middle Earth equivalent of the Christians versus the lions battle a series of life or death puzzles; all this from the vicarious comforts of his Viewing Gallery. Collect 9 gems and escape. In all there are 35 treasures to ransack from the ruins all around you and many have a more than monetary worth. There is also a very useful teleportation system employing a hierarchical structure of coloured collars which save a lot of backtracking. If only the Epic games had this facility! Another user-friendly factor is the rematerialisation of your temporary light source when it expires. A more permananent source of illumination can be found deeper into the game.

The parser is an improvement on the original 1982 release. TAKE ALL, UNDO and EXAMINE all work as does RAMSAVE. Multiple commands may be entered and most items may be referred to.

The puzzles contained herein vary from the obvious to more laterally challenging set pieces and it is commendable that there is little repetition involved in puzzle solving.

There is much about the game which is even more user friendly in the repackaged version than the original 1982 offering as explained above. One particularly friendly feature is the fact that your entire inventory can be ported about with you inside a magical object. Add this to the teleportation system together with no solitary lamp timer and you have a very user friendly experience all round.

Four decades cannot wither the game, nor Twine stale its infinite variety. This remains one of the very best puzzlefests ever created.

This is another large and finicky Epic adventure with interminable dull paths and real-time elements; there are a whole host of winding underground tunnels and paths which need careful mapping. The number of redundant locations can't possibly have anything to do with making the game seem more attractive in the advertising of the day when room count was a major selling point. Oh dear me no.

The premise is that you find yourself on a country road next to a well after spinning a strange wheel you found lying in a country lane; to return to civilisation you must find 23 treasures and then...well, it should be fairly obvious.

There are umpteen ways of soft and hard locking yourself out of completion in this game so you must save in almost an anal fashion. Remember the lamp will burn in real time too so no dawdling or al fresco lamp lighting. Some exits are not clued so mapping is essential here; successful completion depends on not wasting precious lamp oil. It is not possible to refill your lamp as I eventually discovered, despite there being a large pool of oil in one location. Lubrication may be a prerequisite elsewhere.

The game has a number of split second timing decisions to make, mostly centering around when and where to interact with the various NPCs in the game as well as some one visit only areas. Discovering which objects to take with you into these areas and the order in which to visit them will inevitably lead to numerous reloads and restarts. The ten item inventory limit may sound ample but there are times when you will need to take that many items with you so there is no scope for getting it wrong.

The EPIC Operating system was co-written by the author together with D.M. Johnson and updated several times; while the parser in this game is not as sophisticated as the one in The Lost Crystal written three years later from the same stable I found it adequate and I didn't have much trouble in expressing my desire, with the exception of one set piece involving a farmer and a bull in a china shop. I came across not a single typo or other shrdlu which is refreshing.

As mentioned above there are a number of both obstructive and helpful NPCs including a policemen, a werewolf, a troll and a tramp who move across certain areas of the game map. As in many of the games from the seminal years there is ample scope for soft and hard locks, sometimes obvious straight away and sometimes not.

Squeezing 218 illustrated rooms into the 32K Beeb won't have been easy this side of Level 9 text compression techniques and overall the game is worth playing for the puzzles which are definitely the game's strong suit.

I played via the B-em emulator version 2.2 as I prefer the native font to the BeebEm program and upped the emulator speed to 300 per cent which gave smooth and fast game play sessions.

Remakes, flippin' remakes. Nicholas Cage in The Wicker Man? Bruce Willis in The Day Of The Jackal? No more questions, m'lud.

1981 was of course still a time when the text adventure was in its infancy. It was just five years since Colossal Cave hit the ARPANET and seven since Peter Langston's Wander lit its flickering light under the bushel of history. This review is based on the original and best version of Cranston Manor.

The games back then tended to be large, difficult and fantasy based and this game is certainly one of the best examples of the time. There is also a nice fricassee of James Bond thrown into the recipe for good measure. This first version was written for the North Star Horizon (a machine released in early 1977) by Larry Ledden and ported to the Atari as a text only game. A version for Dynacomp was written in MBASIC for CP/M in the summer of 1981 as well. A later version was written for Sierra On-Line which sacrificed textual depth, puzzle quality, story enforcement and atmosphere on the altar of the new text/graphical age.

It is unashamedly a "search the grounds and house of a long-dead eccentric and collect sixteen treasures" game but the muddy track of history had few tyre marks back then and the genre still works when done well.

As previously intimated there is a very well done denouement to the game when you penetrate the erstwhile owner's nerve center and the tension is upped as you suddenly play 007 dodging murderous tin soldiers and laser beams. This clever switch certainly kicks you out of your comfort zone after pottering about the mansion fiddling with ropes and desks.

The somewhat primitive two word parser understands about 130 words but I can think of only one place where I struggled to phrase my intentions in a way that didn't seem cuddly to the parser. The descriptions are very well done, often long and evocative making full use of the space afforded by a disk game without lapsing into dime novel territory. I particularly like the layout of the town near the manor which you have to traverse before the main game begins inside the manor - this certainly adds to the immersive feel of being alone in the city. This naturalistic idea was insensitively removed from the later version.

There are rather novel ways of recharging your lantern and the droid which you control (a unique conceit for the time) although I believe these clever innovations are also lacking in the Sierra rehash.

Much of the game is open from the start although there are a few hidden passages and locked doors; my favourite conceits in these kind of games. There is also an inventory limit of eight objects but as the map is fairly quickly traversed this is only a minor irritation and the game isn't top heavy with portable items anyway. The 134 locations seem somehow smaller to me and this is probably a tribute to the logistical planning that went into the map by the author. There are also none of those "traipsing along an identical rocky path for twelve moves" type of wearisome conceits that some software houses of the time demanded in an effort to flab out the size of their games.

I played via the Altirra emulator v 4.21 as the 4.30 version seemed to crash in enhanced text mode.

We've all done it - bumping into someone for the first time in years and barely clocking them but there are still some immutable features that we instantly recognise. And so it is with this half-remembered relic of Crowther's original.

I grabbed the executable for this via DropBox and I was pleasantly surprised. I was expecting a near exact copy of Colossal Cave but instead it is quite an interesting spin-off; yes it has a wellhouse and a grate and other plagiaristic nods to the original but most of the locations and puzzles are original and well done. Surprisingly XYZZY and the rest of the canonical commands aren't recognised.

It does have the traditional very nasty "maze of twisty passages, all alike" which must be thoroughly mapped lest you miss an item. It also has evidence of being unfinished as you can move through a door and be greeted with "Colossal Cavern is under construction in this area. Please return to this location at a later date for interesting Adventures."

You can however still attain 500 out of 500 points.

In common with games this venerable the two word parser can be annoying but at least it understands GET ALL and VERBOSE and you can save multiple games without the game exiting immediately afterwards.

It does ratchet up the difficulty level from Crowther's original but still falls short of the Phoenix games in terms of hardness.

Whembly Castle was shoved in my direction by Jason Dyer via his laudable and fascinating blog in which he intends to tackle every text adventure ever written. He is currently flailing along in the rapids of 1982 and can probably hear the tumultuous roar of 1984 some way up ahead where the currents are really deep and strong.

This particularly large area of whitewater is only playable via a North Star Horizon emulator which itself can be made to run from within DOSBox-X by mounting the relevant directory (in my case D:\Horizon) then typing HORIZON to run the emulator. You then need to select F7, choose RO and then select the .nsi file you should have saved in the Horizon directory {Whembly Castle.nsi}. You should after a few seconds receive the North Star DOS 5.0 prompt. At this stage type GO BASIC and when the prompt READY appears type LOAD CASTLE and the instructions will ask you if you wish to carry on a saved game or start a new one. It is worth speeding up the cycles in DOSBox-X though as it runs very slowly initially; one of the downsides of running an emulator within an emulator.

Once up and running you can explore the region around a lake and a nasty maze which will need dedicated mapping skills because any one direction missed could be the one that houses an item vital for your continuity. At least there is a handy collection of objects near the start which are ideally suited for the purpose of maze mapping.

Once this item has been gleaned you can make progress breaking into a cabin and a shack where oars and fuel are your ticket out of here and onto the mysterious lake and its castle set in the centre.

The castle in itself is a massive one with hundreds of rooms, secret corridors, paintings of Alice In Wonderland and Sir John Whembly there for you to admire and decipher as clues to where the missing sack of gold could be secreted away. Word puzzles, generators and wells all need to be maintained and brought back to life before any obvious deductions can be made. The maze below the well is a whopper consisting of over sixty locations that have to be thoroughly mapped as several items and tools are scattered about and each will be necessary to solve the treasure hunt. My map currently registers nearly 300 locations and I suspect I am nowhere near solving the thing. One nice touch is no inventory limit which makes dropping objects to map the mazes easier to do. And there are privies. Lots and lots of 'em. Maybe the author had a weak bladder but I am reminded of the Not The Nine O' Clock news sketch with Rowan Atkinson choosing a bathroom suite. Look it up on YouTube.

The game is unfortunately somewhat buggy and on my first play through I was unable to enter the boat. When I restarted however I could reach the area with the boat much more quickly and consequently I could enter the boat and make sail into the large lake. I suspect my manifold save game slots on the first assault had somehow corrupted the game file. The game also shows its age in only accepting upper case commands which is a bit of a pain as I fill in my trizbort map in normal upper and lower case so I am constantly having to toggle the caps lock when typing.

For the purist and completist text adventure fan this is a must play. Younger players probably won't like it but such is life.