Reviews by Mike Russo

View this member's profile

Show ratings only | both reviews and ratings
View this member's reviews by tag: IF Comp 2002 IF Comp 2003 IF Comp 2004 IF Comp 2005 IF Comp 2020 IF Comp 2021 IF Comp 2022 IF Comp 2023 IF Comp 2024 IF Comp 2025 IF Comp 2026 ParserComp 2021 ParserComp 2022 ParserComp 2023 ParserComp 2024 ParserComp 2025 ParserComp 2026 Review-a-Thon 2024 Review-a-Thon 2025 Review-a-Thon 2026 Spring Thing 2021 Spring Thing 2022 Spring Thing 2023 Spring Thing 2024 Spring Thing 2026
Previous | 51–60 of 873 | Next | Show All


Residual Income, by Coral Nulla
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Crime sucks, October 31, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

The Review-a-Thon is one of the community’s newest events, but it’s one that I already find indispensable, exposing me to awesome games that for whatever reason didn’t wind up in one of the major IF events. One of my real highlights from this year’s outing was Sleepless in the Sapphire City, an artsy, wildly subjective vampire story that smartly tweaked the central elements of the mythology to engage with the dilemmas of (post-)modernity, all rendered in incisive, polyvocal poetics (it is awesome and you should all play it). So I was excited to see that there was another installment of the story in the Comp, but also slightly worried on its behalf, because Sleepless is the kind of super-specific thing that tends to resonate super strongly with a portion of the audience but leave many others bemused, finishing somewhere in the middle of the pack with a high standard deviation.

Residual Income isn’t Sleepless Part 2, though, for good and for ill. It’s definitely a much better fit for the Comp, as it keeps the setting, a (different) vampiric protagonist, and razor-sharp wit, but tells a tighter, more cleanly-structured story with some light puzzles fleshing out the gameplay and the disjointed, fragmentary writing disciplined into more linear prose. This is a vampire on the make, speaking in clipped sentences and focusing on the positives of her condition:

I’m on the job. I’ve got work to do. I’m a businesswoman making a deal. I’m just like any other. I could be on the cover of a book or magazine, but I couldn’t, because I can’t appear in photographs. That’s good; it makes me less precious. Less precious people do more important work. I’m doing real work; I’m not worried about my image. I haven’t got an image. These are my gifts.

That job is an assassination contract; the game starts you out infiltrating the apartment of a successful writer of crime fiction, hired to break into his panic-room vault and put an end to him. There’s some briskly-paced exploration as you move through a quartet of locations, clicking to investigate the one interactive feature of each; depending on whether you go clockwise or widdershins, either one revolution or two will be enough to crack the central door and enter the endgame. This interactivity serves more as a pacing element and a justification for some light environmental storytelling than as a brainteaser, but it works well for what it is, providing opportunities for the protagonist to muse on the ways her life mirrors that of her target – one an author of fictitious crimes, one the author of real ones. There are hints of backstory that lend some additional weight to the climactic confrontation, a two-handed dialogue the twists interestingly around the question of who has power in this situation, what they’re doing with it, and why.

It all works very well, which is why I feel churlish saying I was a bit disappointed. The no-nonsense protagonist of Residual Income is a good fit for a neo-noir, but I liked her a whole lot less than the damaged, struggling heroine of Sleepless. And while the prose is quite good (modulo one use of “[he] nods loquaciously” as a dialogue tag) I didn’t find it as evocative as the poetry in that earlier game. This is all down to my expectations, I think – if I’d skipped the Review-a-Thon, I don’t think I would have felt like I was missing anything and found Residual Income a tight, compelling experience. So I think the thing to do is to say it succeeds on its own terms, while crossing my fingers that someday we get a Sleepless prequel to counterbalance this sequel.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Live and Get Pie, by Stewart C Baker (as 'Tame Spond/ee')
Down with poetry, October 31, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

Recently, I’ve had occasion to think about what the most unique feature of my reviewing style might be (the occasion is the use of paratext in WITHOUT Corporation). Sure, there’s the obvious stuff, like the opening anecdotes, monomaniacal focus on “prose quality” which I never even attempt to define, and abuse of conjunctions to make it seem like various disconnected arguments actually add up to something coherent. But beyond those stylistic tics, I also considered whether there were particular viewpoints I hold that are completely distinct, whether there are sentences no other reviewer active today could possibly write. And so it brings me a fair amount of pleasure to say “Live and Get Pie isn’t bad, but its opening act compares unfavorably to that of Constraints (2002).”

2002 was the first Comp I played through (and fully reviewed – the more things change…) and Constraints was my favorite game in that formative year. A triptych examining the limitations of parser IF through a series of different lenses, its first bit involved the protagonist plummeting helplessly towards the ground. But while nothing you could do changed the outcome – see “plummeting helplessly” – the player actually had a surprising amount of agency: almost every verb you could think of, and more besides, were implemented, allowing you to roleplay what you’d do in this situation (scream, cry, etc.), make various non-physical attempts to escape the situation, etc.

Despite having a notionally-similar start – you’re in free-fall, though here that’s because you’re a spy on an incredibly dangerous mission, albeit you don’t actually know what the mission is or why it involves parachute-less skydiving because you zoned out during the briefing – Live and Let Pie doesn’t boast the same reactivity. Here’s an excerpt from my transcript, right after the game told me I was plummeting past a clothes-line:

> take line

Now listen close: I fear that object is not here.

> close eyes

Alas! Alack! Aday! That verb has gone away.

> wake up

Alas! Alack! Aday! That verb has gone away.

> wake

Alas! Alack! Aday! That verb has gone away.

> scream

Alas! Alack! Aday! That verb has gone away.

> shout

Alas! Alack! Aday! That verb has gone away.

Now, Live and Get Pie is prioritizing different things. In particular, as those non-responsive responses show, the game is written in AA/BB/CC/DD/etc. rhyme. This is a hideously challenging feat, even for a short game, though there are some recent runs at the concept (Frankenfingers being the largest, and to my taste most successful), and it’s to the author’s credit that they mostly pull it off, or at least manage to throw up an entertaining shrug when they don’t:

The city’s growing near - it fills your heart with fear.
Most buildings far below, as you still fail to slow
But the highest stretch to where you are (you wretch).
Flag poles and anten(na) approach - are gone again(na?)

For all its low-key appeal, though, the game feels very thinly designed beyond the lack of alternate actions. There are two main puzzles to get through the game’s two set-pieces, both of which are pretty much guess-the-verb endeavors where you’re given various bits of prompting towards the solution, without those solutions feeling particularly reasonable.

Saying Live and let Pie is a bit slapdash isn’t saying anything the author wouldn’t cop to, at least. The – also rhyming, charmingly enough – blurb admits as much, saying it was written in a day and level-setting at the likelihood that that are bugs (though for what it’s worth I don’t think I ran into any). It doesn’t fully commit to the bit, in other words, which is of course fine given that the bit is a short doggerel-rhyming parser game that’s halfheartedly gesturing towards a James Bond parody. But still, I think it would have been both funnier, and more fun, if it had.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Ruined Temple, by Alex Crossley
Temple of Enervating Evil, October 31, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

A tribe of goblins who’ve heretofore only been a nuisance have stepped up their raids, indicating that a new, deadly intelligence may be directing them. A doughty band of adventurers – the heroic fighter, mysterious elf, dedicated wizard, and loyal dwarf – has come together and tracked them to their hidden lair in a desecrated underground fane; they will face traps, vicious foes, and dark magic, before they finally reveal the truth behind the evil artifact thazzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZzzz-snort

Huh? What? What was that?

No, I’m awake, I’m definitely awake.

So yeah I don’t mean to be mean, but this is literally the hoariest premise in all of video games, and so far as I can tell Ruined Temple doesn’t put a single unique spin on the narrative. Every single plot point is a trope that was old before there was an A in AD&D, from the sniveling turncoat goblin to the beautiful ghost sending you on a fetch quest, and while a world outside the dungeon must be presumed to exist, nothing in the action of the game or the perfunctory introduction or more-perfunctory ending would lead you to assign the slightest significance to this fact. This is the kind of game that knows you’re not going to type THADIVUS or LORCASSA more than a couple times; they’ll answer to DWARF and ELF without raising a fuss.

Where the game distinguishes itself is in the robustness and the opacity of its implementation. See, this TADS game has you control the whole party, who move as a blob, using the CHARACTER, ACTION syntax to pick the person best suited for any particular task (once you pick someone, they thankfully stay in the driver’s seat until you tag another party member in). They’ve all got their default weapons, but also have a trick or two up their sleeves – the dwarf (I told you I wasn’t retyping his name) can pick locks, the elf has a magic flute, and so on. A bunch of the challenges you run into are straightforward combats where just wading in will get you through, but most of them are puzzles that hinge not on object manipulation, but using the unique skills of each member of the group. There’s nothing especially novel here – again, it’s DnD tropes all the way down – but you’ve got a noticeably broader palette of action than is typical in this sort of game.

The flip side of this is that the player is left to grope their way to understanding what capacities they actually have, with just about no hand-holding. There are a few oblique hints in the descriptions of the characters that there are certain unique verbs that will allow them to leverage abilities that aren’t explicitly disclosed, and when this works, it can be undeniably fun: figuring out that the elven ranger can tame animals made me feel very clever! But it’s a superficial kind of clever, because there’s nothing diegetic about it; the elf and her friends all surely know that she can do this, so the fact that she didn’t for quite a while as I flailed about trying to figure out what to do lends the sequence an air of inadvertent comedy in retrospect (Ruined Temple compares unfavorably to the author’s previous effort, Imperial Throne, in this respect: in that game, you were often similarly trying stuff without any idea whether you could actually do it and what would happen if you could, but since that was simulating a fantasy version of pre-modern kingship, that felt like a reasonable simulation of the experience). And unfortunately there are many places where there just isn’t any prompting, and the player is left to rely on their genre-savviness or, more likely, the walkthrough (seriously, if there was any clue at all that ELF, CREATE MOONLIGHT was a possible action, I sure missed it).

What’s worse, the game is fairly buggy, which made me wary of too much experimentation. There are plot-critical items missing descriptions, a weird disambiguation prompt in the library led me to a confusing sequence-break, I got a stack overflow when searching a desk, and the inventory system – which isn’t pooled between the characters but tracked individually – sometimes seemed to move things around in confusing ways:

>kyra, give necklace to aedron

Kyra could not give the necklace.

>drop necklace

(first taking the necklace)

Lossdant was sure to keep the necklace, which was clearly an impressive piece of jewelry.

Dropped.

…OK but so where is the necklace supposed to be now?

There’s a kernel of something fun here, don’t get me wrong. In addition to the appealingly flexible implementation, the prose consistently lands at “better-written than a Forgotten Realms novel needs to be”. Here’s a random example:

Somehow, the magicienne was able to dodge the phantom’s swings enough to get close. Seizing her moment, she struck. With a furious cry, Kyra forced her blade into the black, formless void where the creature’s face would have been. The monstrosity let out a piercing shriek as it collapsed. Kyra, too, slumped back, drained by her sudden daring. With that, the last of them was slain.

In other words, with some more testing (there are none listed in the about text) this could have been a really solid take on a classic genre with a few pleasing mechanical innovations; as it is, it’s still easy to recommend to anyone who like this sort of the thing, with the caveat that you really shouldn’t hold back from checking the walkthrough as soon as you’re not having fun.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Quackpond, by Polaris Storm (as 'Quackpond Admins')
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Good weather for ducks, October 30, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

There is no shortage of thinkpieces arguing that parasociality is the defining ailment of our modern world; the internet has gotten everyone, but especially kids these days, way too focused on the travails of people they’ve never met, to the detriment of their ability to focus on the world as it is. This is, of course, rock stupid: Gen Z didn’t invent parasociality, just ask the Beatlemaniacs or medieval Catholics (I was raised in the faith and probably still bear it more affection than is objectively warranted, but man, folks got freaky about the saints). No, the main thing the internet does is make things more awkward, because you’re not just getting invested in stranger-drama, sometimes you’re a fly on the wall as it’s all going down.

Case in point: Quackenpond! With its Geocities-core presentation and cartoon-duck pet simulator gameplay, you’d be forgiven for thinking this is a piece of twee nostalgia bait, but nope, better buckle your seatbelt because shit escalates. See, the barebones duck-tending is attached to a DIY forum, which is where the main business of the game goes down. Early threads where other testers (the game-within-a-game has just moved into a very small beta) introduce themselves and engage in duck-based roleplay are quickly overtaken by other indicating that there are some tensions between the married couple who created Quackenpond – tensions that come out into the open in the space of just a few posts. And true to form, while most people quietly try to ignore the awkwardness, a few members of the peanut gallery can’t help but kibitz, gleefully stoking the flames of other peoples’ relationship issues until the whole thing collapses into a site-not-found error.

It’s a simple story, and the pacing is so tight that it doesn’t have much time to make an impact – even taking a lot of breaks to play with or feed your virtual pet, I think you’d be hard pressed to delay reaching the ending for more than ten minutes. Similarly, while the writing isn’t especially elegant or subtle, it does a good job aping the vernacular of these kinds of spaces, and provides more than enough foreshadowing of where things are going to go, from the lack of self-awareness displayed in the site’s rules (“Quackpond is intended for those 13+ …. mild swearing at times is okay, so long as you aren’t swearing at people or saying fuck every three words”) to the ominous fact that in the introductions thread everyone says they have anxiety, or are socially awkward, or aren’t good with people.

At least there are some nice touches along the way to the ugly, inevitably end. There’s a facsimile of a register/login/logout page, you can choose to reply to a few of the threads and then actually type in what you want to post (though the game unhelpfully doesn’t indicate when others have responded to you), and most importantly, the cartoon ducks are winsome creatures; I chose a skeptical mallard who seemed to be giving the world copious side-eye, and as I played with him while the screaming matches on the forum got louder and louder, I felt we were kindred spirits. I don’t know what’s wrong with humans either, Quackbush, but at least we’ve got each other.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Necromanceers, by C.E.J. Pacian
Nominative determinism, October 30, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

The disorienting, proper-noun-heavy opening of Necromanceers at first feels like it’s going to lead in to an anime-tinged science-fantasy Starship Troopers pastiche. Your combat unit has been inserted behind enemy lines via a missile-shaped dropship whose rough landing has left half the soldiers screaming in mortal agony, and everyone’s afraid of telling the eponymous protagonist their real name lest you use it to call their ghosts back to keep fighting this bloody, pointless war. Your mission is to assassinate an enemy Saint (there’s a bunch of Neon Genesis Evangelion-style religious labeling for stuff), and there’s no price too high to pay to accomplish it.

Happily, though, this is no grimdark embrace of redemptive violence. Things quickly go pear-shaped with the platoon, and you wind up in more of a found-family situation with a much smaller group of much more appealing characters. The vibe also reveals itself to actually be 70’s heavy metal album-cover (or 70’s Heavy Metal, if you prefer) sci-fi: you’ve got a vat-grown cyborg girlfriend who rides a gravity-defying manta ray into battle, an enormous undead worm can carry you through hidden paths, and terrifying enemies can turn into passive-aggressive companions without too much effort. Oh yeah, and when I said that you play a Necromanceer with the power to summon the spirits of the dead, I was oversimplifying matters: there’s a dual protagonist here, since the main character, Returne, is so easily-embarrassed and irresolute – fortunately, her friends find this cute – that she outsources most of her decision-making to Inward, the still-sapient twin she absorbed in the womb and who winds up being an avatar for the player.

I was also surprised that the focus of the gameplay wasn’t on what you choose, but who you call. Most of the game is played in a standard choice-based interface – you can click on some unfamiliar terms and names to get additional context, you can pick who to talk to and them decide on dialogue options, or just skip all that and move to the next scene, it all works fine. But sometimes you’ll see a name highlighted, which is confusing until you reach one of Necromanceer’s handful of set-piece decision-points, where you’re given a free-entry text box and can type in the name of anything or anyone you want to summon to help you out of your present predicament. There are rules – they have to be dead, you have to know their name – but they’re pretty broad ones; for example, you can cheerfully sequence-break by invoking someone whose name you only learned in a previous run. In fact the game is built around repeat plays; my first-run through I’d only learned of five or six of the almost twenty possible summons, and had only had a chance to try out two or three.

See, using the right summon at the right time not only can help solve your immediate problem in a new, possibly more impactful way, it can also reveal the name of an additional possible ally, which makes exploring the possibility-space a compellingly gotta-catch-them-all experience. Like, the fact that [spoiler]the author’s name has a halo around it in the credits[/spoiler] sure seems like it means there should be an Easter egg for invoking it, right? I couldn’t ever get that to work, but the fact that I spent so long trying is a testament to how well the design encourages you to try just one more thing – the game’s relatively short, and the UNDO link and chapter select make it easy to experiment. Sure, sometimes the more-obscure summons aren’t as compelling or thematically relevant as the easier-to-find ones – I’m looking at you, (Spoiler - click to show)farming robot who’s the single trickiest thing to find in the entire game – but the payoff isn’t about them as such, or even how they help you overcome an obstacle, since of course you get to proceed no matter who you pick. No, it’s that seemingly every new interaction you find rewards you with delightful bits of lore, about the origins of necromancy or the inhabitants of the moon or the backstories of your friends, delivered in pacey, evocative prose. I don’t want to spoil any of the actual examples of that, but to give a flavor, here’s an early interaction where an octopoidal radio-operator responds to your inquiry as to whether he needs a hand:

Gnar makes a happy piping noise and waves and coils a boneless arm at me. “Have not needed one whole life!”

“Um,” I say.

“Now not joking,” Gnar says, “do not touch crystal set.”

The downside of Necromanceers being a wonderful narrative tinker-toy is that the narrative can feel like a tinker-toy. The range of possible endings is vast, with friends, lovers, and frenemies variously dead, angry at you, or totally happy to hang out with you forever, in circumstances ranging from sky-piracy to desperate fights for survival in the depths of the seas to modern-day workplace romance to cottagecore domestic bliss, almost all of which turns, so far as I can tell, on your last one or two choices, with almost every final passage introducing wildly new characters, situations, and plot elements. In a few cases, these felt like they were calling back to seeds that had been planted in the earliest bits of the game (I was especially fond of the first ending I found, where (Spoiler - click to show)the first necromanceer separated Returne from Inward, which feels epic and an interesting resolution to the protagonist’s character dynamics) but mostly they’re just fun pops of flavor that come out of nowhere. As a result while I enjoyed the motley crew of heroes and was invested in their relationships in general, there weren’t any particular outcomes or plot beats that landed that heavily for me, since the blink of an eye could erase them and substitute something entirely different.

This is a long way of saying that my main problem with Necromanceers is that sometimes I was having too much lighthearted fun with it to take the themes seriously, like a hilarious, in-joke-laden Mad Libs session with close friends. Would that we all suffered from such flaws! Despite its portentuous opening and its flirtations with the gothic, there’s nothing lugubrious about this game: it’s fleet, funny, and fun, and more than worth playing with to your heart’s content.

And seriously, if anyone figures out if there’s an Easter egg, drop me a line, that’s been bugging me for days.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

9 Days in a Van with your 3 Best Friends, by Nathan Leigh and Nicole Orabona
Band aids, October 30, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

I am guessing that it would not surprise my readers to learn that I wasn’t especially cool in middle or high school; the traits that get you super into IF don’t to be the ones that get you celebrated by your peers in your teenaged years, after all, and I’ll freely admit that I had a bit of a superiority complex back then, which didn’t help matters. I went to a science and engineering focused college, so while nobody was a nerd, nobody, myself included, was cool either. But! For one weird period of about eighteen months in the early to mid aughts, when I was in law school and living in NYC, I found that I’d accidentally become sort of cool? I’d gotten heavily into indie rock, streaming Seattle’s KEXP 24/7, and since my lifestyle was entirely supported by staggeringly-high student loans, the $15 it took to go to a show in a mid-sized venue was a drop in the bucket, even when I was going to one or two a week.

I saw the Arcade Fire before everybody had heard about them, and then again when people were starting to hear about them at a gig where David Byrne joined them on stage and David Bowie was in the audience; I went to a Mountain Goats show where they played songs off the Sunset Tree six months before it was released; I saw the Yeah Yeah Yeahs open for Sleater-Kinney before they blew up, so everyone, myself included, was talking over their set. Going to so many shows meant I picked up a lot about what being in a band is like just by osmosis, and it made for a very odd period where e.g. my roommate’s cool sister came to visit him and I could actually keep up with her references and drop a few neat tidbits of my own. Of course, it wasn’t long after that that the world came to its senses and realized, correctly, that hipsters were annoying, and indie rock stopped being cool, which frankly came as something of a relief. But it was fun while it lasted!

9 Days in a Van with Your 3 Best Friends definitely has some nostalgic appeal to me, then – even though it’s set almost a decade and a half before the times I’m reminiscing about, the mechanics of tours, merch sales, and intraband drama are reasonably eternal. Indeed, the best thing about this game (and there’s a lot to like) is the way it focuses on those mechanics. Sure, the gigs themselves are high points, well-realized set pieces where you check out the other bands with a mixture of anxiety, envy, and genuine curiosity before taking the stage and hoping to wow the audience. But that’s not just from love of the game, it’s also because if the performance doesn’t drive enough t-shirt and tape sales to pay for the next day’s gas, you’re going to be in trouble. Often finding a place to park and a safe place to crash for the night loom way larger than dreams of radio airplay, and 9 Days in a Van also doesn’t shy away from depicting all the repetition, forced downtime, and boredom in between the moments of triumph and heartbreak. Luck will only take you so far, since this is a long game (and at least in the build I played, saving and loading didn’t seem to work), and so the stakes for your decisions feel appropriately high; I admit that I looked up a map of the Lower East Side for the bit where you’re looking for street parking based only on a vague description of where you should be heading, while you’re minutes away from show-time.

That focus on minutiae sets it apart from a lot of more traditional music-biz stories, even if some of the plot beats are the same. You’re a substitute drummer filling in at the last minute when the band’s regular one broke his arm just before their first big cross-country tour, and as you make your way from Boston to Oregon, you get to know the mercurial and charismatic frontman, the sensitive bassist who’s started writing some solo stuff, and the nerdy keyboard player who’s visibly relieved you’re here because now you’re the third wheel, not her. The game leans into your role as the drummer, too – just as the drummer needs to play the beat that keeps the other musicians locked in the right tempo, so too are you tasked with keeping the band together, mediating their little spats and feuds, making sure everyone gets where they need to get, and hopefully having a good time yourself along the way.

The writing is great, helping infuse what could be stock types with real humanity, and alternating (funny) jokes with more sincere moments. The social dynamics within the band ring true; they’re dense, tense, and always shifting, with you as a newcomer desperately trying to keep up:

Somewhere there’s a tape of the band as a trio with Rafa on drums and vocals but he insists they only ever did that as a joke. They have a lot of inside jokes that aren’t actually funny. You laugh anyway.

The references are dense too, appropriately so given that these people would be talking about music and their scene all the time, and while I probably only got half of them, my notes are still filled with bits I enjoyed, like radio taglines I swear I remember from when I was a kid to the bit about listening to Walk This Way until it’s totally clear that Run DMC isn’t going to be joining. Heck, I even lived in Boston for a while, so I’ve been to a couple of the venues that get name-checked. The only thing that struck a slightly wrong note for me was the way the game uses “indie” when in 1991 the appropriate word probably should have been “alternative”, but even that could be a concession to modern audiences (even at the time, “alternative to what?” was a common question). And this isn’t just name-dropping to sound cool; it all works together to create a verisimilitudinous backdrop for the drama, grounding the characters in their world.

9 Days in a Van also isn’t afraid to get a little loose. Whenever you’re riding in the van, you can read a different story in the sci-fi anthology you’ve toted along with you; there are dream that parody text adventure conventions or liken your journey to the Oregon Trail; and there are a bunch of (actually really good!) journal prompts where you can diegetically write the protagonist’s thoughts into a text box. Sure, just as the band says they play “sloppycore”, there are a couple places where this ambition means the game’s lo-fi aesthetic tips over into a few rough patches – besides the aforementioned save/load bug, the last act feels pretty abbreviated, so a few climactic beats don’t have much time to breathe – but if that’s the price of something with this much drive, energy, and pure cool, its one the audience should happily pay.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Uninteractive Fiction 3, by Damon L. Wakes (as Leah Thargic)
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Drummed out of polite society, October 29, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

In our irony-soaked age, there’s nothing as shameful as admitting you don’t get the joke. But as I get older I am intentionally trying to more and more embrace being cringe, so here goes: I’ve never really thought the Uninteractive Fiction games were that funny. The whole point is that they’re low-effort, so that’s not really a critique, but the core gag, of a game that just consists of a single button you push and either congratulates you or berates you based on authorial whim, just doesn’t land. On a conceptual level, yes, the “I” in IF is often only smoke and mirrors, but I’ve been playing games messing around with that fact since the y2k bug was a going concern. Even an old joke can be funny if it’s told well, of course, but here too the very brevity of the UF games works against them; the sound-effects were well chosen but that can only take you so far.

Points for defying expectations, at least: you certainly can’t say that brevity is one of UF3’s flaws. The troll-move here is to take the all-you-do-is-push-a-button gimmick and decompress the heck out of it: each passage is a sentence or two of text, with a 60 second timer that allows you to bang a drum when it reaches zero, at which point the next passage loads. And there are a lot of them – I kept the game running in a side-window while I was approving some expense reports and working on some emails (the timer pauses if you leave the game’s screen entirely) and it took me about two days to reach the ending, which understates the amount of content: per the blurb on the ballot page (Latin for “misery loves company”) it appears that any players’ clicking advances the story for everyone who’s playing, so my game picked up in medias res about a quarter of the way into the narrative.

Said narrative is a shaggy dog story that meanders without ever landing – or at least, if it did, I missed it or it didn’t tickle my funny bone (and let me state for the record I love shaggy dog stories). There’s some business with a dragon, a Dr. Who cameo, a Cookie Clicker parody (seriously, a Cookie Clicker parody in 2026)… Occasionally a graphic of an ape sweeps across the screen, because we all remember that video where you’re supposed to count how many times a basketball gets passed and you get so focused you miss the guy in a gorilla costume walking by the camera, right? It’s all fine, but there’s no plot drawing you through this illogical accumulation of incident, and the progression of action just alternates various forms of stasis (a loooot of the passages are repeats, so you’ll probably see each individual blurb at least three or four times before the narrative ticks over into the next phase) with arbitrary movement, usually violence. And “fine” stretched out over 6 or 8 hours no longer seems quite so fine, if you ask me. The game was also slowed down by its habit of interrupting the story, every six or seven minutes, to berate me for using Chrome instead of Firefox (I was actually using Firefox).

I know, I know – this is a troll game, I’m not supposed to enjoy it, just the delightful way it’s messing with me. Unfortunately, maybe it’s because of the depressing state of the world, or that wasting your time doesn’t seem so funny when there are dozens of other games to play, or that last year’s Violent Delight did a similar time-delay gag with far greater verve and wit, but regardless I just wasn’t any more delighted by UF 3 than either of its predecessors.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

When You Were Shot By Elephants, by Ellie G.
AT GUNPOINT, October 29, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

As the parent to a soon-to-be-five-year-old, I’ve had occasion to reflect on the dilemma faced by the creators of movies and TV for little kids: they’re almost always going to be watched by both the target audience as well as their parents, so how do you cater to those wildly different demographics? Often, the approach is to keep the main thrust of the story and action at a child’s level, but throw in some jokes and references for the older crowd that will go way over the kids’ heads (so to speak): your Velvet Underground covers in Shrek, or Buster Keaton homages in the latest Minions movie. The better stuff, though, doesn’t bifurcate things nearly so cleanly, instead telling stories that work for everybody, even if grown-ups and kids relate to them differently: for my son, the characters in Toy Story are toys whose job it is to make sure the kid they belong to is always happy, but for me and my wife, they look a lot like parents fretting over their child.

When You Were Shot by Elephants is not meant for children, despite the fact that the most over-the-top elements of the content warnings don’t appear to be in evidence in the game (sidenote: jokey CWs are a lame trick to pull, you should never do this), but it faces a similar dilemma: it’s a jokey fan-homage to a series of trollish games from the middle years of the Obama administration, and inasmuch as the most-played one of the group has 11 ratings, it’s fair to say that the author must have assumed that some of not most of the Comp audience wouldn’t have played the originals. So what strategy did they take to make sure everybody can enjoy themselves regardless?

Unfortunately, that was a trick question, because when I was laying out that taxonomy of kids’ shows, I left out a third category: those that are just for toddlers and thumb their noses at the idea that adults could possibly enjoy them (I’m looking at you, Paw Patrol). And When You Were Shot by Elephants defiantly takes this tack. I’m looking forward to reviews by folks who get the specific riffs the current game makes – hopefully they’re hilarious – but for those of us who don’t get the specific references, this is pretty thin gruel.

The idea here is that you’re an elephant (armed with an elephant gun, natch) whose goal is to shoot the player before any of the other elephants in the neighborhood can do the deed. You wander through an intentionally-confusing map more or less at random while the player does the same; sometimes they blunder into you and you can shoot them, sometimes another elephant does the deed first. You get a point if you succeed in ambushing the player, at which point they respawn and you can repeat the process. Sometimes the player UNDOes their action, though that doesn’t really make much difference. There’s not anything else to do, so far as I can tell – shooting the other elephants doesn’t appear to work, though the response is kind of confusing, and you’re not even allowed to examine the vanishingly few pieces of scenery (though since only thing notable about the authorial voice is that it likes to curse, this isn’t much of a loss). Maybe there are secret depths revealed for those who are willing to ride this particular merry-go-round longer than the half-dozen spins I took before giving up, but if there are, I can honestly say the game didn’t seem especially interested in providing me an incentive to do so.

Not all games need to be for all players, of course, and I sincerely hope that people who got a laugh out of the original games in between watching the first Avengers movie and celebrating Queen Elizabeth II’s Diamond Jubilee enjoy this one just as much. But as for me, I’d actually rather be watching Paw Patrol.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Thirst for blood, by Zeno Pillan
Red and sweet, October 29, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

This review was originally conceived as opening with an extended attempt to theorize a distinction between the zany and the whimsical. But I scrapped it when I realized a) I wasn’t really coming up with a compelling point of differentiation besides “stuff is zany when it’s random and I don’t really like it, but it’s whimsical when it’s random and I do,” and b) all the intro was doing was building up to saying that I found Thirst for Blood charming, which feels eminently bottom-lineable.

So yeah, this short parser game about being a mosquito in search of sweet, sweet blood also manages to hit a sweet spot. This is a fun conceit but also a potentially limiting one: obviously a mosquito should have a very different set of capacities and way of seeing the world, but they also can’t interact with the world in very many ways beyond flying and biting. Thirst for Blood wisely deals with this by keeping its running time tight and its playing field small (you’re looking to suck blood from a single human in a small hotel room), so that the novelty of being able to fly everywhere and being tiny doesn’t have time to wear off. The writing also does a good job of highlighting unique aspects of the mosquito’s perceptions, like its ability to taste carbon dioxide, while hewing to parser-game conventions to avoid needless disorientation – it winds up an effective balance, even if the idea of a mosquito navigating via compass directions makes me giggle. And while the central problem of getting food to grow your eggs is simple to resolve, there are also a few small surprises that unlock an alternate ending if you poke around a bit, offering enough beyond the critical path to reward exploration without getting bogged down in tedium.

I won’t spoil what those easter eggs point to, but to return to my opening theme, it’s something so bafflingly out of left field that I gave a happy laugh when I figured out the twist. So yeah: Thirst for Blood is thick with whimsy, making this small game punch well above its weight. Like, it turns out that the mosquito can read, but this absurdity is presented so matter-of-factly I couldn’t help but find it charming. And the writing is enthusiastic and gleeful about presenting its gags – some small idiosyncrasies of style make me wonder whether the author might not be a native speaker of English, but either way, the occasional typo is a small price to pay for some memorable turns of phrase and a real commitment to its jokes that makes sure they land:

> x door
The door is closed, there is no gap to pass to the other side and a key in the keyhole prevents you from passing there.

> x key
D minor.

Sure, there are some players who’d say that’s the kind of thing that tips a game over into the dreaded pit of zaniness, but by my lights Thirst for Blood stays on the golden path of whimsy, a lovely light little thing that knows it’s enough to create just a few moments of joy. Not bad for a tiny bloodsucker!

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

The Acquisition, by Jess Watsky
American psych-out, October 28, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

The Acquisition has enough specific date markers and references to contemporary events to make clear it’s not a period piece, but this blackly-satiric skewering of the vapidity of lite consumerism feels straight out of the 80s, and not just because its choices are labeled with a Choose-Your-Own-Adventure-aping “turn to page XX.” The decade of my birth was rife with movies and books reproving the yuppies for the crass, materialistic ideology they’d embraced as the idealism of the liberation movements of the Sixties curdled, and Paul, the Acquisition’s protagonist, would fit right into the rogue’s gallery. He’s a wannabe Master of the Universe (the Wall Street kind, not the He-Man kind – as someone who was a kid when both of these things were big, let me assure you that it was confusing back then too) who dreams of being an alpha-male cowboy, and attempts to bridge the gap between aspiration and reality by purchasing actually-not-all-that-expensive-in-the-grand-scheme-of-things artwork, while quietly quailing from his wife’s disapproval of his spendthrift ways.

He’s an unappealing, pathetic character, in other words, a sign and symptom of the decadence of the moneyed elite, and at least in the opening set of passages, the player is invited not to sympathize with him but to judge him. The prose is brisk and dry, well-suited for this clinical dissection:

No need to hesitate. It’s your money. Just buy the drawing. Just click pay. Don’t look at the VAT. You buy the drawing and you wedge the information in over grilled cheese sandwiches and a robust kale salad for dinner. In your delivery, you are firm, curt, and assertive.

“I bought the drawing and I’m going to put it in my office. There’s no way to return it. We’ll have to adjust.” You place your hands on the table and scoot back in your chair, as if you are finalizing a transaction. [Your wife] nods once and you hear her sigh in the kitchen, deeply.

So this stuff is well-realized, but I can’t say I found it especially compelling: the game flatly states its simple themes early on, and while it’s hard to disagree that consumerism is no substitute for values, and lies and steamrolling are bad for relationships, the writing here intentionally foregoes the kind of specificity and plasticity that can enliven these platitudes. Indeed, unlike many of the celebrate poison-pen novels of the 80s, The Acquisition doesn’t feel especially closely attuned to the foibles of the lifestyle it’s satirizing – the general vibe of wealth and the fact that Paul’s on an art-dealer’s list for individual outreach sits uneasily with the idea that $3,300 is a sufficiently big expense that can’t be managed with a bit of credit-card juggling, for example (he doesn’t have kids! What else could he be spending his money on!) The art-world references do provide some much-needed context, but there aren’t that many of them, keeping the overall feel rather high-level, glossy, and disconnected from human experience, even the human experience of soulless materialists.

The story structure also strengthens this sense that there’s less of substance here than one might prefer. Of the half-dozen or so major branches available from the opening few passages of the game, all but one terminate quickly, bringing the narrative to an abbreviated conclusion within two or three additional clicks. Those endings aren’t bad, exactly – they’re thematically appropriate, and boast some of the most viciously funny writing in the game, like the one where you suffer a fatal heart attack immediately after buying yet more art, this time an even more expensive customized painting tailored just to your preferences:

You do not experience the experience of knowing your final act was to saddle your most beloved with an irritating tertiary bill and an illiquid, smarmy asset.

There is that one branch that keeps the story going for longer, however, and here the Acquisition gets a little more ragged, which winds up helping it. The plot starts taking non-obvious twists and turns, and if they sometimes feel more like zany non-sequiturs than anything deeply connected to what’s come before, well, as noted the premise runs out of gas pretty quick so switching gears is probably the right call. I was unconvinced by the swerve into therapy, and the attempt to characterize Paul’s acquisitiveness as a form of OCD – beyond the details not quite ringing true, I’m not sure this is the kind of story where you really want the main character to be redeemable. But another way of saying that is that the last part of the story is notably more humanistic than the first, and if you had to pick one, well, I’d choose the messy, more compassionate one over the self-assured and detached one any day, much as Gordon Gekko might disapprove.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.


Previous | 51–60 of 873 | Next | Show All