Ratings and Reviews by madducks

View this member's profile

Show reviews only | ratings only
View this member's reviews by tag: IF Comp 1995 IF Comp 2005 Speed-IF -1
Previous | 31–40 of 41 | Next | Show All


Galatea, by Emily Short
madducks's Rating:

A Day for Fresh Sushi, by Emily Short
madducks's Rating:

Marble Madness, by Emily Short
madducks's Rating:

Common Ground, by Stephen Granade
madducks's Rating:

Shade, by Andrew Plotkin
madducks's Rating:

Ad Verbum, by Nick Montfort
madducks's Rating:

Book and Volume, by Nick Montfort
madducks's Rating:

Winter Wonderland, by Laura Knauth
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
A slightly over-rated puzzle-fest, September 5, 2008
by madducks (Indianapolis, Indiana)

I never understood how "Winter Wonderland" got first place in '99. For a puzzle-piece it does have it's charm, and it is very well implemented, but I found the map flat, and mostly just unsatisfying, the character interactions were shallow and grating. The treacle story and prose have been commented on in other reviews, and indeed, it only exasperated my distaste for this one.

This might be of interest to puzzle aficionados and children, but probably too difficult for the latter and bit ordinary for the former.

You can log in to rate this review, mute this user, or add a comment.

Photopia, by Adam Cadre
madducks's Rating:

Uncle Zebulon's Will, by Magnus Olsson
madducks's Rating:


Previous | 31–40 of 41 | Next | Show All