Under They Thunder

by Andrew Schultz profile


Go to the game's main page

Member Reviews

Number of Reviews: 2
Write a review

4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
Erwhelming Ovay, December 12, 2020
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2020

Friends, I have a confession. I have now played two Andrew Schultz games (this one and Very Vile Fairy File from last year), and they both have the same effect on me: as I stare at the words on the screen to try to make sense of them and respond in kind, my vision starts to swim, I begin to babble, language dissolves as words themselves decay into meaningless nonsense-sounds, and I feel the cold immensity of a vast, amoral universe that cares nothing for humanity and our feeble attempts to apprehend it through logic, mathematics, and language. Great Cthulhu can do his worst and Yog-Sothoth can get in line: I have played Under They Thunder, so all your threats are empty.

If the title doesnít give it away, the central gimmick of Under They Thunder is pig Latin: the player character embarks on an epic adventure to help a big-box retailer defeat an angry monster-fae army (I think? See above, my sanity as I took my notes was questionable), all through the power of inverting a word and adding a friendly ďay!Ē syllable to the end. There are relatively-simple fill-in-the-blank puzzles where you need to take the prompting of the name of an object or location and de-piggify it, guess-the-noun puzzles where given a certain pattern of phonemes, you need to run through all the options you can think of, and a set of more traditional puzzles where you need to read a particular book (or, I think, hum a particular tune) to teach you the lessons, or put you in the mood, needed to see off an overbearing interloper.

I should say, I can tell this is a very well-crafted game Ė both because itís huge, with the central puzzle mechanic run through its paces and ramified in every way imaginable (each language puzzle seems to be worth a point, and there are 144 of them!) and because there are a thoughtful set of helper gadgets, hint features, and speedrun options that try to meet every player where they are at. This is a game for a very specific audience, but the author also provides every possible on-ramp to help you figure out whether you might be part of that audience and just donít know it yet.

This is commendable, and I totally can intellectually see the appeal, but it just doesnít work for me. My mind doesnít bend the right way to make the puzzles comprehensible, and privileging wordplay over the merest sop to mimesis (do we still talk about mimesis?) takes me out of the world because the whole thing feels like chaos. I got maybe five percent of the way in under my own steam, looked to the walkthrough to eke out a couple of additional points, then used the fast-forward options to zoom to the end, though unsurprisingly didnít find the finale especially edifying given all I missed.

By all means, give this one a try Ė Under They Thunder wants you to like it, itíll invite you right in Ė just donít be surprised if your brains are running out your ears before too long.

Comments on this review

Previous | << 1 >> | Next

Andrew Schultz, May 4, 2021 - Reply
Thanks for this. I think you pretty much "got" my game and I was frustrated I couldn't make it easier to understand.

I think when starting it I figured a game with pig latin stuff in it couldn't be that big ... could it? But then I discovered one more thing, and one more, and so forth ... and it sort of blew up.

I wish I could've made it less forbidding. I was able to add some hints late, but I guess it wasn't enough. It's the sort of thing where I'm glad I explored things but I'm disappointed I couldn't make it clearer so more people would enjoy it.
Previous | << 1 >> | Next