Go to the game's main page

Review

Cartoon mysteries, November 17, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

(I beta tested this game)

“Deceit” is an apt first name in this game’s title, as – appropriately enough for a mystery – it always has something up its sleeve. That sleeve, unfortunately, can’t belong to its protagonist, a brain-in-a-jar superscientist, tasked with unraveling the tangled web of lies that resulted in the murder of the Superman knock-off who’s theoretically in charge of your unruly gaggle of heroes.

Often IF mysteries content themselves with sprinkling a bit of Holmesian flavor over a standard set of object-manipulation puzzles, but that’s not the case here, not least because you start game with the various arm-like devices you use to interact with the world on the fritz. Getting those up and running again so you can push buttons and rifle through desks in search of clues is one element of the gameplay, but a minor one compared to the focus on interrogating each character in turn and looking for inconsistencies in their statements to push them on. Indeed, the personalities of the heroes wind up being the game’s key source of content and conflict: they’re introduced as thinly-veiled Superfriends homages, and to be fair never become truly three-dimensional, but they each boast at least a few layers, including relatable hangups, grievances, and hopes, some of which they’re up-front about, while they guard others until you figure out a way to pry loose the truth. And there’s a lot to pry into, as everyone is keeping a suspicious secret or two that makes them the prime suspect at one time or another.

Add in some supervillains and frequent fourth-wall breaking (the characters all know they’re in a cartoon), and it makes for a complex, talky plot, but the interface largely makes proceedings easy to manage. You scoot around the eponymous base by clicking on a charming, RPG-Maker-style map, and the interrogation system allows you to keep easy track of what questions you’ve already asked of which characters, and what they said. Meanwhile, the physical side of thing is left largely streamlined; solving of the more traditional puzzles just involves clicking on the appropriate links so long as you’ve unlocked the relevant tool or capability – these come in at a steady pace, which helps make it feel like you’re making progress as you move through the long, twisty sequence of story beats.

I’ll blurry-text what I thought was the biggest twist, because I think it’s worth appreciating but also works best if not spoiled, but suffice to say this is a robust, well-designed game that is way more than a simple super-hero spoof.

(Spoiler - click to show)So, that last twist: as you investigate each of your colleagues, there’s more than enough sketchy business to make it feel as though Watchmen was as much a source of inspiration as traditional silver-age comics: there are hints of infidelity, substance abuse, embezzlement, collusion with the enemy… which is of course a legitimate and popular approach to superhero stories, albeit one that I think can come off as mean-spirited when juxtaposed too harshly with the innocent candy-colored version pitched more directly to children. But actually that’s not what Deceit is doing at all: all those crimes and sins are revealed to be misunderstandings that were deliberately engineered so the hero’s friends can make a big gesture to show how much they appreciate him. It’s a sweet swerve that I didn’t expect at the halfway mark, making for a feel-good climax that sends the player off with a smile.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.