by Joey Jones profile

Episode 5 of Apollo 18 Tribute Album

Web Site

Go to the game's main page

Member Reviews

Number of Reviews: 2
Write a review

4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
Banality Of Evil Adventure, April 11, 2012

Mammal is a small-to-medium-sized treasure-hunt game with mild puzzles. As the human slave of reptilians, you are tasked with eradicating all traces of mammals from a museum.

(Spoiler - click to show)This is a fairly grim premise, since you're effectively a Sonderkommando. The wider context of the purge is never explicitly stated, but there's ample evidence that it has been a violent and chaotic process. The featureless protagonist shows no signs of emotional reaction, and dutifully goes about a set of simple tasks that are perfectly familiar to an IF player: find and identify the treasures, solve some mild puzzles to secure them, return them to the trophy-case. The PC is wholly subsumed by their role.

There are some obvious homages: the skip as trophy case is a throwback to Ad Verbum, and the reptilians bear no small resemblance to Dr. Sliss of Rogue of the Multiverse. (If there are any direct references to the TMBG song, I wouldn't notice them.) More generic stock IF devices are common, too: a crowbar to pry things with, a wandering cat. This is about the morally numbing effect of familiarity, of how having an excellent practical grasp of how to do something can make it seem less ethically troubling. That this is a mechanically unremarkable game is kind of the point. The puzzles are just fiddly enough to engage your attention and keep it away from the elephant in the room. Ultimately, you incinerate yourself for the lousy last point. (I assume; there's a point or two that I haven't found.)

Mammal is not an ethically deep work; it has a single trick to pull, a single point to make. But it's cleverly handled, and it delivers a mean little moment of realisation. And it's very clearly not about the rather tired point that players will cheerfully do atrocious things if shepherded by gameplay; rather, it takes that as read and takes advantage of it.

(There is one small bug: if you incinerate yourself while holding other mammals, the other mammals are not incinerated.)

Was this review helpful to you?   Yes   No   Remove vote  
More Options

 | Add a comment 

Comments on this review

Previous | << 1 >> | Next

perching path, May 24, 2012 - Reply
The game doesn't really work as a Godwin-dodging Sonderkommando scenario, because it rewards (Spoiler - click to show)a trivial escape attempt (walking away from the steps twice) with apparent success and the message "You Are Free". Pretty tasteless, once you have the metaphor in mind. If such a scenario is what it's trying for, it really needs to disallow any way out which doesn't lead to fairly immediate death.

Even assuming less ambition, I don't know what motivation there is to proceed once it becomes clear that there are living animals among those to be disposed of. The game tells me I'm a slave, but vagueness of potential consequence makes me feel more like a put-upon intern.
Sam Kabo Ashwell, May 24, 2012 - Reply
Hunh. I didn't find that. That does seem sort of weird, even if the Sonderkommando analogy wasn't really planned.
Andrew Schultz, April 18, 2012 - Reply
Since I tested this game I don't want to give my own full review, but to check off on your question, the game covers the mammals mentioned in the song.

I think having a fixed list of stuff to throw in was a great way to prevent the game from getting too unwieldy for the player, sort of like speed-if ideas.

In fact, it even fits into the Z5 format, which impressed me when I realized it. I'd expected the fingertips to and no regular songs to.
Previous | << 1 >> | Next