(I beta tested this game)
There is to be said about Ḫattušumna Laḫḫa: its pedagogical aims and methods, its summaries and simplifications of the rules of Hittite grammar, the interface design and its approach to information-management, the cultural and narrative context it communicates, and how my CTL-C CTRL-V fingers get a workout whenever I write about it because I don’t know how to even start trying to type its title from scratch. But I’m deeply ill-equipped to speak to any of them (except for the last one) in the best of circumstances, and two months on from when I tested the game – and one day from the closing of the Comp, at long last drafting review number 71 – my memory and capacity are worn rather thin too.
So I’ll just say two things. First, this is a fascinating game even if you’re unlikely to use the smattering of the Hittite language you’ll pick up for any business or personal purpose, and that it’s been highly engineered to make for as smooth a learning curve as possible for what’s basically an immersion course in a thousands-of-years-dead language. I suspect if you’ve got some previous familiarity with a language with inflected nouns, like Latin’s declensions into the nominative, genitive, etc. cases, the barrier to entry will be lower, but even then, concepts are introduced gently and one at a time, with tooltips and sidebars always available if you need a refresher. I was definitely a bit intimidated when first opening up the game, but it’s very much trying, and I think largely succeeding, at pitching itself to an audience without any previous familiarity with much of anything.
The second thing is that playing Ḫattušumna Laḫḫa (there’s that CTRL-V again) is engaging in its own right, regardless of your level of interest in Hittite language and culture, particularly if you’re a nerd about meta analysis of how IF works. See, the typical piece of parser IF uses text to present a puzzle, with the player tasked with understanding and manipulating that text in order to make progress (seen in this light, it’s not surprising that games like Counterfeit Monkey, which literalize the text-manipulation part of that equation, are often among the most celebrated examples of the form). And to get a bit dialectical, from the player’s point of view the puzzles are the unknown – puzzle solving is essentially a process of developing understanding – while the text, that is, language, is a familiar set of signs communicating that unknown and guideposts pointing the way to the solution.
Ḫattušumna Laḫḫa neatly reverses that dynamic: most of the puzzles across its three chapters are deeply familiar ones to anyone who’s labored in the Zork mines for a spell – the first two hinge almost entirely on very traditional medium-dry-goods puzzles, while the last is built around a logic puzzle of the kind I remember reading in game and puzzle books when I was in middle school. Given how much brain power the player needs to devote to parsing the Hittite text, this was definitely the right decision, but it does invert what the game’s “aha” moments look like: instead of frictionlessly reading words in order to think up a novel solution, I found myself imagining familiar ways that IF puzzles tend to get solved and then laboriously working through the text, word by word, until I understood enough of the detail to snap the situation into one of those stereotypes. It was definitely a mental workout, but would have been fun even if the game’s language had been entirely made-up – admittedly that I picked up a smattering of Hittite, plus some snatches of deeper historical understanding of their world, was a decided bonus.
(I beta tested this game)
“Deceit” is an apt first name in this game’s title, as – appropriately enough for a mystery – it always has something up its sleeve. That sleeve, unfortunately, can’t belong to its protagonist, a brain-in-a-jar superscientist, tasked with unraveling the tangled web of lies that resulted in the murder of the Superman knock-off who’s theoretically in charge of your unruly gaggle of heroes.
Often IF mysteries content themselves with sprinkling a bit of Holmesian flavor over a standard set of object-manipulation puzzles, but that’s not the case here, not least because you start game with the various arm-like devices you use to interact with the world on the fritz. Getting those up and running again so you can push buttons and rifle through desks in search of clues is one element of the gameplay, but a minor one compared to the focus on interrogating each character in turn and looking for inconsistencies in their statements to push them on. Indeed, the personalities of the heroes wind up being the game’s key source of content and conflict: they’re introduced as thinly-veiled Superfriends homages, and to be fair never become truly three-dimensional, but they each boast at least a few layers, including relatable hangups, grievances, and hopes, some of which they’re up-front about, while they guard others until you figure out a way to pry loose the truth. And there’s a lot to pry into, as everyone is keeping a suspicious secret or two that makes them the prime suspect at one time or another.
Add in some supervillains and frequent fourth-wall breaking (the characters all know they’re in a cartoon), and it makes for a complex, talky plot, but the interface largely makes proceedings easy to manage. You scoot around the eponymous base by clicking on a charming, RPG-Maker-style map, and the interrogation system allows you to keep easy track of what questions you’ve already asked of which characters, and what they said. Meanwhile, the physical side of thing is left largely streamlined; solving of the more traditional puzzles just involves clicking on the appropriate links so long as you’ve unlocked the relevant tool or capability – these come in at a steady pace, which helps make it feel like you’re making progress as you move through the long, twisty sequence of story beats.
I’ll blurry-text what I thought was the biggest twist, because I think it’s worth appreciating but also works best if not spoiled, but suffice to say this is a robust, well-designed game that is way more than a simple super-hero spoof.
(Spoiler - click to show)So, that last twist: as you investigate each of your colleagues, there’s more than enough sketchy business to make it feel as though Watchmen was as much a source of inspiration as traditional silver-age comics: there are hints of infidelity, substance abuse, embezzlement, collusion with the enemy… which is of course a legitimate and popular approach to superhero stories, albeit one that I think can come off as mean-spirited when juxtaposed too harshly with the innocent candy-colored version pitched more directly to children. But actually that’s not what Deceit is doing at all: all those crimes and sins are revealed to be misunderstandings that were deliberately engineered so the hero’s friends can make a big gesture to show how much they appreciate him. It’s a sweet swerve that I didn’t expect at the halfway mark, making for a feel-good climax that sends the player off with a smile.(I beta tested this game)
Do I have a new favorite Andrew Schultz game? I’ve long since lost count of how many of his games I’ve played between the various wordplay series, the chess ones, the tic-tac-toe one… and after a bit of an initial hump as I figured to get on the right wavelength (I started with some of the rhyming games, which I think are among the trickiest) I’ve uniformly enjoyed the silly humor, clever mechanics, player-friendly design, and quietly pro-social messages that are a feature of his oeuvre; while there are certainly odd ducks and standouts (the poignant You Won’t Get Her Back, the thematically-coherent Beef, Beans, Grief, Greens) they’re much of a muchness.
And I’d be hard-pressed to point to anything Wait-Our-Way Tower does that’s radically different from what comes before – the specific wordplay mechanic, of turning a two-word phrase into a different one based on moving the space (like, in the title, “wait our” becomes “way tower” if you pause before the t-sound rather than before it) is one that I’ve definitely seen before, though one I tend to like since it allows for fun puns without blowing the possibility-space too wide open. Similarly, that key mechanic is supported by a few other small systems – there are some NPCs to interact with, including a light navigation puzzle, and a couple multi-step areas where you need to solve a number of wordplay puzzles to progress – but none of this amounts to changing up the formula. And it’s the same story with the, er, story; as is typical, there’s a lot of wacky cartoon business happening to support the wordplay, but the throughline is about the importance of breaking down self-made isolation and connecting with other people, which is a lovely idea that’s not gone unexamined in the author’s previous games. But despite this lack of obvious novelty, it all comes together into a really strong package that should please Schultz veterans and newcomers alike, and like I said, is a real contender for the crown in my book.
…OK, if push came to shove and I was forced to name something that is distinctive about Wait-Our-Way Tower, it’s the pictures. Moving to Adventuron means that Schultz is able to cram in more of the charming MS-Paint-style drawings that he’s used for covers all these years, and the unpretentious whimsy of these designs can make for a lovely lift when a tricky puzzle risks frustration, while also helping illustrate some of the more hard-to-visualize sequences. I imagine it significantly increases the workload, and wouldn’t be as easy to incorporate into games written in other systems, but the inclusion of all this art is part of what lifts the game into the top tier.
(I beta tested this game)
I’m not exactly proud of this, but there was a time when I’d 100%’d every Assassin’s Creed game there was. I haven’t kept up since the birth of my son – 100+ hour open-world extravaganzas aren’t really compatible with the amount of child care required of new parents – and I know there are plenty of well-taken criticisms of the games’ designs as well as Ubisoft’s corporate practices. Still, I found the formula uniquely compelling: the stabbing is fine, sure, but it’s the history tourism that really got me, especially in the era when you could get your hands dirty climbing all over various landmarks.
Last Voyage of the Warsaw Queen offers much the same pleasures: there’s a plot centering on unraveling the Cthulhian machinations of a distant ancestor, and a nicely-open puzzle chart to navigate as you find various ways to distract the baddie and foil his plans. But the main draw for me was the history, as it’s set on a lovingly-rendered Mississippi riverboat with period-appropriate details derived from contemporary sources. You can explore three decks, wandering through the passenger cabins, the various storage areas, the lavishly-appointed lounge, the engine room, while rubbing shoulders with desperate gamblers, lovestruck stewardesses, obtuse pilots, and barbers looking for a piece of the action. It’s big enough to make wandering around poking at the scenery satisfying, but sufficiently clearly laid out that once you get down to the business of solving puzzles it’s simple to get around (the well-rendered map feelie definitely helps with this, too). And there’s a deceptive amount of complexity – there’s a fully-rendered and period-authentic game of chance, for example (of course you can cheat to win), as well as an achievement system rewarding you for digging into the details.
The asterisk to the fun of historical exploration is that of course in this instance, the history being explored is that of the 19th Century American South, which was wholly bound up in slavery and its legacy. Warsaw Queen is up-front about this context – practically the first thing it does is encourage the payer to read the foreword, which acknowledges the resounding horror of the Peculiar Institution and its ongoing effects today – while being similarly up-front about the fact that it’s largely left unaddressed by the game, which is aiming for a more light-hearted vibe. I think there could have been ways to weave some of these themes in, as racial issues aren’t exactly alien to Lovecraft (please feel free to submit this aside to the Understatement Oscars), but it would have certainly shifted the story in significant ways, and at any rate I found the acknowledgement gave me sufficient permission to enjoy poking around this floating recreation of a corrupt culture – and foil some comfortingly inhuman evil, to boot.
(I beta tested this game)
Interactive fiction, I think most would agree, isn’t a great name for a video game genre. The label manages to be both dramatically overinclusive and underinclusive at the same time, and gives off a snobbish vibe to boot. But we can count ourselves lucky compared to the lineage of RPGs descended from Dungeon Master, which go by the unlovely term “blobber” – see, the idea is that you’re controlling a full party of characters, but they all occupy the same tiny square of the map and never move or act independently, so in effect you’re playing an undifferentiated blob of adventurer bits, a twelve-armed, six-headed heap of flesh rolling through the dungeon.
The Two Seasons is a traditional piece of IF per its systems, but its dual-protagonist hook sees a pair of high school students work to thwart a vampiric plot while joined at the hip, thankfully in the metaphoric rather than the literal sense. You traverse the hallways, research supernatural weaknesses and solutions, and deal with bullies and other occupational hazards, always as a duo. And unlike most blobbers, where each character silently plays a mechanically-defined role in the gestalt, here the two are constantly bantering, commenting on what they’re doing, hatching plots, considering their actions and then rethinking them…
These hyperverbal youngsters are long on personality, and the robust dialogue plus the subject matter mean the game unavoidably recalls Buffy the Vampire Slayer, but that’s no bad thing: there’s a bit more zaniness and a bit less angst here, sure, but it’s a sturdy formula that the game further plays out by adding other allies and adversaries beyond the core duo, each of whom are just as talkative. This winds up providing a lot of color enriching the main plot, which is a sturdy but not exactly novel collect-the-spell-ingredients scavenger hunt; the individual puzzles boast a good mix of challenge and make clever use of the high school setting, but could feel a bit disconnected from each other but for Maddy and Matty chatting and chattering away – still, one hopes they eventually split up to go home once the mission is done!
(I beta tested this game)
It is a truth universally acknowledged that Batman’s villains are way more fun than the man himself. I’m sure the good people of Gotham are glad there’s the one person maintaining the social order against a tide of gibbering chaos – it’s nice to be able to go out to a concert without being fear-gassed or laughing-gassed or choked by a vine or choked by a luchador or blown up by a penguin-bomb or immobilized by a freeze ray or … whatever Clayface does to people, in the animated series it kinda looked like he could fire mud-streams? Anyway it would be deeply unpleasant, sure, but safely ensconced in fiction, the libidinal excess of the villains is way more engaging than Bruce Wayne’s emotional constipation. And how much more would that be the case if the villains had a point?
The Rat is a distaff counterpart to 2024’s Comp winner the Bat, exploring exactly that reversal. The Bat saw you playing as a knock-off Alfred catering to the every need of a knock-off Batman, who in this version of reality was an addled collection of tics barely managing to resemble a human. The Rat sets you up as crew of hardened criminals bent on boosting some of the Bat’s valuables, with the main obstacle to your plans the aforementioned super-butler. And your best weapon to distract him? Pure, unbridled chaos.
What that means is that the Rat is a very systems-driven piece of IF – it has situations, not puzzles. After a brief tutorial sequence, you’re let loose on what are more or less a series of escalating levels where you need to figure out how to keep the butler busy for longer and longer periods of time, enabling the crew to ferret out more and more loot. You’ve got a number of tools in your repertoire, but primarily these are spatial challenges as you figure out how to make messes and mischief in far-flung rooms, forcing the butler to yo-yo from one wing of the mansion to another to try to restore them to some semblance of order. And as is typical for the author’s work, the interface is designed with numerous felicities and features, most notably a constantly-updating map, that makes it easy to set and execute plans.
There’s a pleasant sense of mechanical escalation as new tools get added into the toolkit and the degree of difficulty increases, but what’s even more engaging is the personality of the baddies: each member of the team has a codename and a specialty, and they all do some kibitzing – and reveal a bit of their supervillain origin stories, many of which are quite sympathetic – as the heists proceed. As in the original game, the satire is quite broad, but entertaining nonetheless, providing a pleasantly anarchic chorus as you take the world’s worst Batman to the cleaners.
(I beta tested this game)
Rarely has a game made me feel like so much of a rube. I had a lot of fun testing Demon Game for Sophie and played it through several times – the RPG-lite elements of this story of an assassin sent from Hell to kill a corrupt prelate mean that leaning into stealth rather than deceitful words lends a distinct flavor to some key moments, as well as making the combat sequences play very differently. And my first time exploring the downbeat early-modern squalor of the city where the priest lurks left several of its deeper mysteries intact, which made going back and taking another run at them all the more enticing – there was an enigmatic, incomplete tarot reading, a maze puzzle I didn’t fully wrap my head around, and the tantalizing prospect of a non-combat solution to dealing with a bereaved specter. On top of that, the prose was wonderful, leaning into the devil’s cynical view of human nature while expressing real outrage at the injustices and petty cruelties it witnesses:
You approach a pawnbroker, a woman who strips memories like paint, cleaning wedding rings, lockets, and tobacco cases of everything they once meant so they can be sold on clean to matter less to their next owner.
So I wrote up my feedback on balance and builds and progression and clueing and cheerfully sent it off, mentioning that I felt like I hadn’t quite plumbed the last mystery but found it a very fun, satisfying game nonetheless, only for the author to inquire whether I’d played with the sound on, which is emphasized as a critical element of the game on the opening screen. Of course I’d blithely ignored it, lots of games say that but listening is so slow compared to reading and I usually don’t have the luxury of just sitting around for an uninterrupted hour with my headphones on.
The final game, perhaps because of idiot players like me, boasts the same announcement on the opening screen but also a hard of hearing mode that I activated with a somewhat guilty conscience, so I could see what I was missing. It was a lot! In fact there’s a whole additional layer to the story, in fact the primary one, an autofictional tale of horror where the author’s (“the author’s”) depression, Weltzschmerz, and romantic fecklessness lead to a slow slide towards shocking, bestial acts. It’s as well-written as the more nakedly fictional one, especially in the early, more grounded bits which are interspersed with the RPG – once it takes over fully and starts barreling along to the conclusion, the memoir-ish conceit starts to fray, though there’s undeniable momentum to these sections.
But regardless, completely missing such a major element of the game makes me feel rather oblivious. What’s worse, the voiced narration often critiques the fiction layer, decrying it as vapid, an empty power fantasy of unquestioned obedience. I can see the point, and of course the narrator is in a bad state so we’re certainly not supposed to accept his pronouncements uncritically. But still, I feel a bit like a rube because I did like Demon Game for Sophie quite a lot even when I was just playing the Demon Game part and had no idea what “for Sophie” meant; now that I understand that, I like it even more.
(I beta tested this game)
In the pantheon of names for Indiana Jones rip-offs, “Galilee Bones” is good but not great – I’ve told the story about making my friend name his Dr. Jones-ish RPG character “Tennessee Williams”, right? – except I only realized significantly after I started playing the eponymous game that it’s a double pun, since it also calls back to the author’s Galaxy Jones dyad of games. That’s not the only moment when a game that at first seems to be a straightforward archaeologist vs. Nazis romp throws a feint.
For one thing, there are the puzzles: while there’s a satisfying mix of sneaking, fighting, and thinking in what initially seems like a small, contained area eventually reveals itself to contain multiple layers of challenges that require readjusting your expectations to surmount. While working through this may involve trial and error for some players, even the trickier bits are well-clued, meaning that several times I smacked my head, impressed by how well the game sets up even distinctly counter-intuitive actions like (Spoiler - click to show)handing the priceless occult treasure to a Nazi.
Then there’s the plot, which again begins like every Indy pastiche imaginable but quickly starts complicating itself: a series of short flashbacks begin interrupting the action, providing some fun backstory but also introducing another character into what’s otherwise a mostly-solitary adventure. These flashbacks also set up a final twist that reveals that the actual conflict, and Dr. Bones’s role in the story, was different than it first appeared.
And this isn’t a game that denies players the pleasures of the thing it’s emulating: for all these reversals and rug-pulls, you still get to clock unsuspecting Nazis on the head, delve into lost tombs, decode hieroglyphs… it’s a neatly-accomplished balancing act, making Galilee Bones a game that does a bunch more than it needed to.
When I say that Ryan Veeder’s Agatha Christie’s etc. etc. etc. really reminded me of a game from a previous IF Comp, the obvious one that springs to mind is last year’s The Little Four, a loving piece of fan-fiction that imagined the retirement life of Orient Express sleuth Hercule Poirot, depicting him amid a found-family that loved him, vain foibles and all. But actually, despite their shared central character that game has little in common with this one, which is decidedly larger, decidedly less respectful towards Christie’s creation and canon, and decidedly less of a detective game, too. No, the game I wound up thinking about was Swigian, a decade-old experiment by @mathbrush to see how a large-ish cleanly-coded and designed game with simple puzzles and the sparsest prose imaginable would be received.
As the title perhaps indicates, the prose is not sparse in Ryan Veeder’s Agatha Christie’s etc. etc., so it’s more precise to say that it reminded me of an inverse take on Swigian’s goals: this is a large-ish, cleanly-coded and designed game with simple puzzles and the most florid parody of Christie’s style imaginable. And, actually, it’s a pretty good approach! The jokes at Poirot’s expense are good for more than a few chuckles:
Without relish I consume the final morsel of croquette mignon de boeuf; with the white serviette I dab at my lips and my moustache. I rise from the table with great dignity. Nothing in my manner betrays the immense weariness of a man who has been witness to so, so, so many murders.
There’s also a truly groan-worthy pun on “little gray cells” that I loved to death (and won’t wholly spoil here). Admittedly, some are hit and miss – I felt like the game belabored its shifting of Poirot’s nationality from Belgian to French, where a quick blink-and-you-missed-it reference would have been funnier – but the batting average is certainly quite high.
I did find myself laughing a bit less as the game went on, though, since the humor is generally pretty one-note: Poirot explores a new area, happens to meet an old acquaintance, engages in a short exchange of banter that mocks his vanity, and repeat. The structure also gets repetitious. See, this isn’t at all a close adaptation of the novel (that extraneous “the” in the title might be a clue) – the initial set up of a murder on the train is preserved, but you spend as much time off the train as on, since in addition to exploring each car in turn, you also visit stations from France to Constantinople. You’re always on the hunt for clues, since they act as gates unlocking new parts of the train, and new corresponding station stops, but these are a wholly abstracted affair: a “clue” is simply a token with no description or other characteristics, each new one adding to your accumulating pile and eventually allowing you to access the doors that require 10, or 15, or 30 amassed clues to open.
The clues are almost always hidden in plain sight – you just need to examine all the scenery in all the locations and open any likely containers and you’ll find most of them. There are a few exceptions that require some puzzle-solving, but these are likewise almost all straightforward: in a few places examining the scenery will get you an item or a combination you can use in an entirely straightforward way to unlock another location or clue, or obtain another item or combination you can use to work further down a chain. When explained at that level of generality, that’s how just about all puzzle-based IF works, of course, but the contrivances felt rather more direct than usual to me here: there’s a place where you find a series of directions and then a trackless desert you need to navigate, a safe combination and a series of numbers, and so on – you’re almost never in a position of figuring out how to solve a puzzle, rather the typical experience is to stumble on the solution and then retrace your steps until you get back to the place where you can implement it.
Again, that’s not necessarily bad, but it does lend the game’s systems a mechanical vibe, and turns the exploration of the large map into a species of lawnmowering: go everywhere, examine everything, then go back to places you’ve been before to see if the clues unlocked someplace new, examine everything… and if you pick up something that’s not a clue along the way, check to see if it cleanly lines up with an obstacles you’ve previously encountered (and if not, just keep playing, since you’ll surely stumble on it soon). Admittedly there are some later items and puzzles that mix this formula up a bit, but some of them just mean you need to re-mow grass you’ve already visited, like the guidebook that has critical information if consulted in many locations, but which requires wandering back over the full map to exhaust its hints. And this means there’s no real mystery to solve: you need to reach a certain clue threshold to unlock the ability to accuse someone and end the game, but the clues provide no indication of who is really at fault, so you’re just left to pick someone you prefer (or someones, if your appetite for lawnmowering is starting to run dry – I confess I only tried a few, as I couldn’t muster up the enthusiasm to work through the couple dozen possibilities).
I am somewhat giving Orient Express short shrift here – there are a few more secrets and layers that I haven’t fully divulged, and I was having a good enough time to persevere through them to reach an amusing secret ending (as well as consult the helpfully-included source code to track down one last easter egg I couldn’t quite crack). It’s an amusing game, I’ll repeat, and I’ll also repeat that it’s solidly designed and coded. But for my taste it’s a bit too samey for its longish running time, and the challenges and systems are kept at arm’s length from the fiction. It makes for an archly entertaining and smooth game, but I confess I wished it had done more to remind me of the tight, sentimental Little Four.
The thing about patterns of behavior is that they’re patterns for a reason. Like, absent some very intensive work on mindfulness and self-awareness, they will recur despite one’s best intentions. Here’s a hyper-specific case in point: outside of the true giants in the earth, I think of current participants in the IF scene it’s pretty much just Brett Witty and myself who were also active in the first years after the turn of the millennium. Funnily enough, we directly crossed paths in the halcyon days of 2005 because I reviewed his debut game. Mix Tape, I think we’d all agree with the benefit of hindsight, was a noble attempt to write a parser game focused on characters, grounded situations, and emotions that didn’t fully succeed for a variety of reasons. And my review enumerated those reasons in I think a fair-minded way, but did so after a snarky opening establishing my indie-music-snob dominance by saying the game’s preferred cover of Leonard Cohen’s Hallelujah (Rufus Wainwright’s) wasn’t as good as my preferred cover of Leonard Cohen’s Hallelujah (Jeff Buckley’s).
The aughts were a foreign country and we were all a lot snarkier then, and of course many, many (many, many) years have passed since then. Still, I sometimes think with regret of how I gave into my more sneering instincts, and resolve to do better, but it’s a pattern of behavior, so I know I sometimes repeat it nonetheless.
I mention this in finally getting around to See You Around because it presents about the most naked test-case imaginable for whether I’ve learned anything over the past 21 years, because a disturbing portion of my raw notes are yet more nit-picking snobbery, much of it focused on music. Should I give it vent, or try to be high-minded and ignore my impulses?
Well, I think I’ll split the difference (this too is a pattern of behavior) and do the thing while trying to ground it in a principle less idiosyncratic than personal taste. So: this is a short game with only two real characters, and one and a half scenes: the protagonist is a musician living in a St. Paul art collective who sometimes resorts to sex work to make rent, and we follow her as she heads out on one such excursion. But it’s interrupted by an encounter with an ex, another resident of the collective with whom she’d had a fling a few months previous; we get a brief flashback to their meet-cute, then pick up the action from there. We get a big of deeper backstory and a short jump forward at the end, with interspersed lyrics from songs written by both characters (these work about as well as any lyrics do shorn of their natural habitat, which is to say they’re not super compelling but generally not embarrassing either). None of the plot beats are especially surprising, and the gameplay is entirely straightforward – the player is clicking to continue with the occasional opportunity to get a bit of additional context.
All told this means that the game is setting itself up to live or die on its texture: the strength of its writing, and its ability to provide concrete details that can take a familiar plot and make it raw and visceral. And here is where I’ll levy complaints about some of those details, starting with the music: I’m not super acquainted with the mid-90s Twin Cities music scene, but these characters are embedded in it and sure should be conversant with its key figures. But the touchstones the game offers up are the Goo Goo Dolls and Del Amitri and the Smashing Pumpkins – which were in heavy rotation on radio stations in suburban New York, where I grew up – instead of, I dunno, Husker Dü or the Replacements or Lifter Puller or other more locally-relevant folks.
The other detail in this vein has to do with the protagonists’ names. See, the meet-cute involves the ex, Amir, buttonholing the protagonist, Jasmina, by her mailbox: he’s seen her name around the building and his excuse for striking up a conversation is wondering whether it means that she’s Persian, like he is. But “Jasmina” isn’t really a Persian name; it would be “Yasmina” or “Yasmin” in Farsi, but we know he’s pronouncing it with a J because the game specifies that he says it a different way than she does.
I am very aware that I am carping here. But it’s not that the bands the game name-checks are lame and the ones I mentioned two paragraphs up are cool, or that there’s anything inherently interesting about the wonky phonetics of the English J. It’s that these were real missed opportunities to make the game feel distinctive – and See You Around isn’t robust enough to be able to afford not to swing at many pitches. The way it depicts its central relationship is basically fine, but not especially deep on its own: we get the fumbling beginnings of a relationship, a hint of its first complication as Jasmina’s defensive barriers cause her to drift away from Amir, and then a moment of reconciliation as his embittered take on what happened between them triggers an aggrieved attempt to set the record straight. The plot is fine as melodrama – and the sex scene struck me as solidly written, which is no mean feat – but didn’t wind up deeply engaging me in the characters or situation. Perhaps the story of how they broke up for good would be a more interesting one, but since that’s only adverted to, rather than depicted, I can only say that what’s on offer here is a bit too normcore to make a deep impression – heck, with the perspective of 20 years, I might have even preferred it if Amir had paused proceedings to wax lyrical about his love for Rufus Wainwright, misguided though it might be.