Mansion Quest

by Walter Pooley

1992
The Quill

Go to the game's main page

Review

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
A Game That Carries Much Wait, November 18, 2026
by Canalboy (London, UK.)

Walter Pooley wrote several adventures, and they all conform to a pattern; obscure object manipulation puzzles interspersed with some genuinely clever ideas and a complete disregard for grammar and spelling. There are also a couple of bugs, but as far as I can tell neither are game breaking and I could never replicate the first one again. The back story has you aboard a speeding train, travelling to a tiny village to eye up your dead uncle's mansion and get your horny hands on his valuables.

Originally written and released commercially as part of a four pack pick 'n' mix collection, it is of medium size and, apart from the two stinkers that top and tail the game, is of medium difficulty too. I tried both the Spectrum version and the later Commodore 64 version (the latter after I had hit one of those bugs which lurks in the drain maze) and they are almost identical, including the bugs. After your egress from (Spoiler - click to show) the train (a timing puzzle) it is divided up into two sections, namely the village of Upper Puddleton and its environs and then inside your uncle's mansion, with booby traps and grammatical faux pas aplenty. Collect the five carefully secreted treasures that uncle has prepared for you and you win. Fail, and you will end up (Spoiler - click to show)electrocuted, dissolved in acid, spread thinly on a railway line, splayed awkwardly on the ground with a broken neck or in a state that similarly renders you unable to cash in your winnings . No pain, no gain and no familial warmth in this one. Where there's a will, there are a lot of nasty deaths.

The Quilled parser will come as no great shock to anybody versed in playing games written with it; the first four letters of a word are recognised and there is the usual inability to close objects once they have been opened or to insert anything into another container. This annoying feature of the vanilla build of the Quill has always drained away much realism from games written with it. In this one you also have a wallet full of money; you cannot of course interact with the money in any way beyond BUY in one place. The parser will respond to more than two words, but only recognises the first two. EXAMINE and SEARCH sometimes give different results. There are many walls in the game, but referring to them parses information about the wallet and there are several other examples of the four letter blues scattered throughout the game. It is also littered with inapposite apostrophes, many spelling mistakes and occasional capital letters in the middle of a sentence. Grammar appears to be someone who lives with your grandfather, not your uncle . NPCs are tenebrously constructed; the taxi driver, the vicar and the station master cannot be addressed and are purely meta objects, so all interaction is reactive. All but the taxi driver disappear when they have had their short cameos; clearly they need better agents to up their on screen time. The utilitarian Scott Adams style location descriptions do nothing to add any feeling of immersion. "You are on a north/south country lane" is about par for the course. Memory constraints could surely have allowed for a more lengthy and immersive experience. Some evidence in the mansion of your uncle's life and times would have helped, but there is none of this. Much of the difficulty emanates from sudden death scenarios. There are several places where just walking into a room means it's curtains. There is a fairly straightforward two-way maze which contains a bug, but if you do the right thing at the end of it the bug is not a game breaker. I also hit a bug in the road mender's hut the first time I entered (you are given the description of a different location) but I was unable to subsequently produce it. There are at least no light or hunger daemons although an annoying inventory limit of six items means you have to do a fair amount of dropping and picking up. TAKE ALL doesn't work but DROP ALL does. There is no HELP and no BACK here either. You can at least return to the village as many times as you want, it seems to me. The game also possesses an illogical morality; at times you are admonished for attempting to steal things, and in other places this is essential and passes without any parser demur. In a few places the game's continuity hinges on using the WAIT command. This might be a fairly clever construct for one puzzle, but when it is used three times it does tend to highlight the writer's paucity of imagination (or coding skills) in setting up any different types of puzzle. My advice to any player would be, if you find yourself in an area where nothing is happening, try waiting. Occasionally you have to perform a certain action in a room, then wait for something to happen. The puzzle involving the tool cupboard is just so unlikely as to be rendered unacceptable, and there are several unclued directions that had me stumped for a while. There are five treasures to be found but merely four of them deposited, as the last one is an automatic catalyst to the end of the game.

I feel I have been a litle harsh, as a few of the puzzles are quite good, but it would be difficult to recommend this above many similar games with better descriptions, better parsers and better testing.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.