Jolly Good: Cakes and Ale

On a scale of 1-8, I would rate this game outstanding. Strong replayability with a highly branching storyline and all the characters are distinct and memorable. The little bits of narrative meta are absolutely delightful and I love the nonlinear storytelling. As someone who can be quite paranoid about stats, failing stat checks are sometimes more desirable than succeeding them, because they're so entertaining.

For those who are fans of Kreg Segall's other works, the Jolly Good series shares a universe with Tally Ho!