Adapted from an IFCOMP26 Review
Ok, your party is at the entrance to the dungeon housing the goblin raiders, right where the townsfolk told you it would be. What do you do?
Take stock of our party. Who have we got again?
Three fighters - a human, a dwarf and an elf - and a sorceress. Between them, there are two magic swords, a bow, an axe, and a hair trigger fireball spell.
Hm. Nothing else? A little unbalanced, no? No Rogues? No healers? You know I wanted to play a Rogue. Which one of them am I again?
You’re all of them. Don’t worry about juggling their character sheets, your friendly neighborhood DM will handle that. The dungeon is fairly easy to navigate. You knock about a bit encountering goblins, ghosts, undead, that kind of stuff.
Got it! I attack the goblins!
No, sorry, as the sorceress, you’re not really built for front line combat.
I thought I was the human fighter? Can I be him?
Sure, for now. It takes a few actions though. Ok, you’ve dealt with everyone in sight, now there’s a locked door.
Be great to have a Rogue now! I break it down.
No, your elf fighter isn’t strong enough for that. Your dwarf is a fighter-rogue though.
Wait, now I’m the elf? And since when is the dwarf a rogue??? Ok, I pick the lock.
You find a room overflowing with goblins! Boy, are there a lot of them!
Ok, we quickly retreat, must need another way to resolve this. Re-explore the dungeon a bit.
You knock about for an hour, finding a flooded sub basement but nothing else new. Every attempt to reengage the goblins is foiled by the fortifications they have hastily thrown up.
An entire hour??? Am I in an unwinnable state? (Evil, ambiguous DM chuckling.) Sigh. Ok, let’s just restart, shall we?
Your party is at the entrance to the dungeon housing the goblin raiders, right where ..
I know, I know! This time we charge the goblin horde that waaay outnumber us. Y’know, swinging swords and axes, lobbing fireballs, the whole 9 yards.
You win! Only there is a bit more to the dungeon.
Great! We loot the bodies.
There are no bodies.
What? But… we just… ahh! Ok, we explore some more…
You encounter some undead!
And no cleric. Great.
If you want, you can cast a WALKTHROUGH spell, and I’ll give you a hint.
Fine. Cast WALKTHROUGH!
(Spoiler - click to show)The elf is sort of a fighter-cleric. Also, she has a magic ring.
You didn’t need to spoiler that for me. Also, why didn’t I know any of this? Dispel undead!
The sorceress can’t do that.
AAAH!
[some time later]
You have defeated the final evil of the dungeon. Good thing WALKTHROUGH was a cantrip and not a spell slot!
Well that was a LOT of confounding work that you could have cued a bit better. I liked the characters and foe variety, once I figured them all out though. Jumping roles was neat, but couldn’t we have smoothed the changing mechanism a bit? Had an indicator which one was current? Really wish you didn’t lean so hard into Evil DM mode. And what was up with the disappearing bodies?
You haven’t seen the final treasure. You have been traveling in the magical land of TADS this whole time!
TADS!!! I LOVE THIS ADVENTURE!!! Same time next week?
Played: 9/2/26
Playtime: 1hr, concluded I was in an unwinnable state, +45m with constant walkthrough goosing
Artistic/Technical ratings: Sparks of Joy/Notable cuing, noun, and identity mechanism gaps.
Would Play After Comp?: No, though I hope its followon games will address the sometimes opaque gameplay. Because if it’s in TADS, I WILL PLAY IT.
Artistic scale: Bouncy, Mechanical, Sparks of Joy, Engaging, Transcendent
Technical scale: Unplayable, Intrusive, Notable (Bugginess), Mostly Seamless, Seamless