This game gave me all sorts of different reactions.  
 
First of all, it has nice visuals and sounds chosen from a variety of operas and symphonies. 
 
The text is slow during musical portions, but the game overall is relatively short. 
 
This game is a retelling of the Phantom of the Opera, where you can customize it in 6 different ways depending on the time period and the way you perceive the story of the Phantom. 
 
However, on replay, choosing entirely different options, I found myself with almost the exact same story. I checked the code of the game, and all the stats affect at most one or two paragraphs each.  
 
The writing is interesting and makes for a good retelling, with narrative twists. I felt that the characterization of Christine as seductress was surprising to me and didn't really gel with my version of the character, and then later events further differed, but I suppose that's the variety in retelling a story. 
 
So I honestly don't know. This is in no way what I would consider a bad game, but it has a lot of unusual choices that I need to sit and unpack for a while. 
 
+Polish: Everything worked well from the get-go. 
+Descriptiveness: The characters and locations were vivid to me. 
+Interactivity: Despite the small effects of choices, I felt like it was interactive, especially the first time. 
+Emotional impact: I'm a Phantom of the Opera fan, so it was fun to play it in Twine form. 
+Would I play it again? I don't plan on revisiting this.