Reviews by Mike Russo

View this member's profile

Show ratings only | both reviews and ratings
View this member's reviews by tag: IF Comp 2002 IF Comp 2003 IF Comp 2004 IF Comp 2005 IF Comp 2020 IF Comp 2021 IF Comp 2022 IF Comp 2023 IF Comp 2024 IF Comp 2025 IF Comp 2026 ParserComp 2021 ParserComp 2022 ParserComp 2023 ParserComp 2024 ParserComp 2025 ParserComp 2026 Review-a-Thon 2024 Review-a-Thon 2025 Review-a-Thon 2026 Spring Thing 2021 Spring Thing 2022 Spring Thing 2023 Spring Thing 2024 Spring Thing 2026
Previous | 11–20 of 873 | Next | Show All


A Triangle for Two, by Naarel and A. Clearwater
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Landscape with trio, November 14, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

It is, I suspect, profoundly unfashionable at this point to confess to liking John Updike, but I will cop to the crime: for a decade or so from the late 90s through the mid-aughts, I went through probably a dozen of his books, from the Rabbit tetralogy to weird one-offs like the Centaur (which alternates Updike-typical chapters with others where the plot and characters are transposed into a mythological register) and Memoirs of the Ford Administration (basically the same idea, except instead substitute previous world’s-worst-president James Buchanan for the centaur). It’s not that the plots or characters were especially compelling – they all centered on a callow WASP cheating on his wife, which even in 1998 was a dull business – but Updike had a hell of an ear for dialogue and a facility for absurd jokes that lightened the often-heavy plot points. But most of all the thing that kept me coming back was the scenery: every couple of pages, he’d usually feature some bit of scenery from the northeastern United Sates, lyrically yet matter-of-factly limning the trees or hills with such majesty that they became a backdrop lending tragic, transcendental weight to whatever tawdry domestic drama was playing out in the foreground.

All of this is to say that while the most distinctive thing about Triangle for Two is the fact that its protagonist is a plural system – that is, they are a pair of distinct identities that share a single body – I’m going to start out gushing about the landscapes. Like, this paragraph could have come straight out of an Updike short story (though let’s not imagine how clumsy he would have been taking on this subject matter):

‘Jan’ was focused entirely on the road, gripping the steering wheel like it might slip out of their hands and fly away. Their body was stiff, their moves mechanical. Anna stared at the landscape outside: yellow, grey, green, grey, brief splash of blue, grey. Roadside chapels with their colourful ribbons fluttering in the growing wind, small houses for large families, farming machines, all became smears behind the window.

This maybe says as much about me as is it does Triangle for Two, but this might well be the single most exciting paragraph I’ve read in this year’s Comp. It’s got rhythm, it’s got imagery, it’s got character; it’s direct, tells you exactly what you’re seeing and what it means; it’s beautiful and I love it more every time I read it. And all the game’s prose is like this, with the same careful attention to the pregnant detail carried into every description, every bit of dialogue.

This is wonderful in its own right, but also did a lot to engage me in the work of understanding the situation of the two protagonists, Jan and Maria, which is less unfamiliar to me than it would have been to Updike, I suspect, but still required an imaginative leap. But that leap was an easy one to make given poignant details like these in a description of Maria’s yearning to wear a dress and dance (the system’s body is male):

I’m there as she twirls in the living room. The curtains are drawn. She doesn’t want to look through the windows because she knows she’d start thinking about what it would feel like to have the wind play with those billowing sleeves.

Indeed, while Maria seems in some respect positioned as the secondary personality – beyond their shared body better matching Jan’s gender identity, there are indications that Jan also pre-existed her, and most of their family and friends know him and not her – she’s probably the most compelling character in the piece, her grappling with her identity full of yearning and compelling specificity:

She never thought about herself too deeply. What were her preferences? What did she like? Peace and quiet, of course, but who doesn’t like that? There had to be more. Driving, that’s for sure. The dress she had hidden in the closet. Household tasks, basic maintenance, cleaning, organising, cooking, but not baking; too many unpredictable variables there. Watching the birds, but only in the winter, when the tits came back, especially blue tits. What else? Was there anything else that was just hers?

I’ve given short shrift to the plot here, as was my wont with Updike. I liked it too, though – no infidelity in sight, it just hinges on Jan and Maria coming out to their friend Anna, whom Jan has a crush on. This complicates his relationship with Maria, as well as making things very confusing for Anna, but Triangle for Two avoids the melodrama that its title suggests: everyone is remarkably mature about their emotions and each other’s needs, and while there are some moments of tension, overall the game paints an aspirational portrait of people trying their best to understand each other. Similarly, the gameplay elements are understated but well done: most passages have a link that provides a bit more context or elaboration on the main plot, as well as one that simply moves on to the next one, but there’s at least one place where you can decide whether it’s Jan or Maria who’s ringing Anna up, which felt like a very consequential choice. One arresting passage also breaks from the parsimonious approach to links by festooning underlined-words throughout the page: you can toggle between Jan and Maria, and male and female pronouns, to create your own interpretation of who is doing what in a particularly charged moment; it’s a bravura marriage of substance and form, just one arresting piece of a game that’s full of them.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

One (More) Week in Dolcett - Scarlett Sky, by Strict-Smile2087
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
Extremely NSFW, November 13, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

We don’t actually know where Tituba was born. She was indigenous, native to somewhere in the Western Hemisphere, but 17th-Century recordkeeping was not exactly scrupulous about documenting who enslaved people were, once the legally-significant fact of their enslavement had been established. Regardless, by the time she becomes legible to history, the property of the minister of Salem, Massachusetts, she was a long way from home, and there was no one there to speak for her when she became the first person accused in the year-long paroxysm of madness that convulsed the village. After multiple beatings inflicted by her godly master, she confessed to her crimes in lurid detail: witch cakes, soothsaying, the Black Man, a black dog, a black rat, aerial rides upon sticks. Her testimony saved her life; she was spared where others who protested their innocence were hanged. And then she was sold on from her imprisonment, and history falls mute again.

Many women are harmed in One (More) Week in Dolcett – so many women, impaled upon spits, boiled in water, locked in ovens, slashed across the throat, shotgunned in the back, on and on and on. And then their bodies are mutilated and consumed by men, and the women who’ve made themselves complicit in this evil, in horrific tableaus that are lavishly and lovingly described, an explicitly pornographic transformation of human into thing. None of them are real, of course, it’s all imaginary, simply a game, these are wisps and phantasms with no moral weight greater than a fly.

Except for Tituba.

It is very tempting to make jokes in this review, because much of what is in the game is laughable – from the revelation that the cannibalism-obsessed protagonist sleeps with a night light that mimics an oven’s pilot-light to her insistently-parochial Nort Carolina pride – and because humor is one of our surest defenses against revulsion. But I am taking this game seriously because that, I take it, is what it is asking. There are, I am sure, places where fetish sex games can be posted and evaluated based on the effectiveness with which they cater to their respective fetishes; IF Comp has not, historically, been one of them (I suppose that was a joke) so entering such a thing here must mean that the author is inviting a different category of response, so I suppose we can take the blurb at its word:

[This] is also a story about growth, perseverance, and self-actualization under the most extreme conditions. It is a story about people, for people, and written entirely by a person in an effort to combine the deepest human emotions with our most primal instincts.

I read that to suggest that the player is meant to focus on the protagonist’s mental journey – that even if (“if”) they don’t share the hyper-specific cannibalism kink that permeates almost every paragraph of this lengthy game, the way in which she is able to work through her barely-sublimated desire to be murdered and eaten in order to save other women from non-consensually suffering that fate is meant to be the primary element of interest.

Having played through the whole plot, I don’t find that claim entirely convincing. The protagonist’s internal struggles are certainly foregrounded: this is the second game in a series, and the summary of the first installment makes clear that after an initial visit to the cannibal society of Dolcett, she found herself sexually enthralled by the idea of being forcibly roasted in an oven and then torn apart and eaten, and since then, her shame over her kink has left her isolated, with fewer and fewer attachments keeping from giving in to that ultimate fantasy of self-abjection. When she discovers that an unknowing woman has been dispatched there through a bureaucratic error, she decides to go back to rescue her, but it’s clear this is partially an excuse to once again put herself in a position to be cannibalized. This tension animates all the external conflict that comes next – even as she’s making contact with an underground network of resistant fighters, raiding the mansion of an aristocrat who’s kidnapped her quarry, or matching wits with a big-game hunter who’s set his sights on her, she’s struggling as much with her submissive desires as with these external obstacles.

If you zoom very far out, this kind of conflict between selfish and possibly self-defeating wants and impersonal duties is de rigueur in fiction. The argument for this kind of horror fiction is that building a narrative around a set of wants that are extreme and, to most readers, repulsive, is necessary because the catharsis on offer is likewise extreme, and can only be communicated by going to the utmost limits of the human experience. But this is very much not the case here. The shifts that prompt protagonist’s revelation that she has something to live for and should probably just indulge in roleplay rather than dangle herself in front of actually-existing cannibals to get off are commonplace, banal: she meets a man who likes her (likes her enough not to want to eat her, though he’s got the same sexual obsession), and she helps teach the woman she’s rescuing to be brave and stand up for herself, which helps her internalize the lesson herself. These are familiar tropes that aren’t especially deepened by their association with cannibalism, nor are they rendered here with any particular verve or elegance (in fact the prose is clumsy throughout, with awkwardly repeated words and typos that get noticeably denser in the sex scenes).

But as I said, I don’t think the blurb’s suggestion is convincing, because the game also stages a parallel drama of catharsis and transformation at the social level. Throughout, much hay is made of the customs, mores, and institutions of Dolcett, and the protagonist’s triumph is not simply that she escapes, but that in the course of her rescue mission she manages to inspire a movement to bring the whole rotten place down. The sequences of sexual peril alternate with moments of yasss-queen girl-power, and men are either clear antagonists or very secondary supporting characters. This is, I think, the other claim the game is making for itself: that while it’s presenting a misogynistic hell, its sympathies lie with the underdogs, and a key satisfaction for the reader is seeing evil receive its just deserts.

But the Handmaid’s Tale this is not: at best One (More) Week in Dolcett offers pop-feminism, but it fails to reliably deliver even gruel as thin as that. The social reckoning on offer here is decidedly non-apocalyptic: in the “true ending” that I received, a woman took power, sure, and even decreed that cannibalism henceforth must be truly consensual (to the game’s credit, it’s clear-eyed about the ways systems of power can coerce a superficial “yes”), but her message is entirely about the need for healing and cooperation moving forward. Beyond a short aside about one named character being jailed, there are no trials, there is no Truth and Reconciliation Commission, none of the dozens of men who, in the game’s bad endings as well as its canonical paths, rape and murder and enslave and devour, face a single moment of consequences.

That’s not the only way the game fails to actually situate patriarchy as the fundamental villain of the piece. It’s notable that the big fight against the hunter antagonist is only the first of three climactic encounters – the other two are against female opponents whose reasons for wanting to kill and eat the protagonist are much more personal, and beating them doesn’t align with any claims of social justice (the first is an indigenous warrior who’s lost sight of the teachings of her ancestors, and acknowledges at her defeat that the white woman has learned their lessons far better than she ever could; the second is a predatory lesbian who can mind-control any woman she finger-bangs). And to return to that confrontation with the hunter, there’s a moment where, after successfully out-fighting him, he’s able to turn the tables by pulling down his pants, and the sight of his engorged, alpha-male cock is enough to turn you into a slobbering, lust-filled animal; if you succeed at a challenging minigame, you can master yourself just in time to defeat him, but regardless of which outcome the player experiences, the sequence as a whole reifies the misogynistic assumptions of the male-supremacist worldview it wants to be seen as rebuking.

As I’ve said, this is of course all words on a page, with a notionally humanistic and even pro-woman ending attempting to redeem all the abuse these fictional constructs suffered along the way, even if I don’t think the execution of the piece delivers on that premise. But this is where we return, finally, to Tituba. Because she’s in here, too: at one point you’re given a choice of paths and if you decide to go through a mysterious forest, you wind up in the house of a witch named “Abutit”, who – like everyone else in the game – tries to cook and eat you. Once you defeat her, a heavy-handed hint is dropped about trying to read her name backwards, and one of the souls you free from torment at her hands says it’s been trapped for 334 years – the difference between 2026 and 1692, the year when the Salem witch-panic started. What’s worse, the game earlier implied that the cannibalism endemic in Dolcett might have a supernatural source, and that that source might be linked to the forests: and so, either intentionally or out of reckless disregard, the game enlists this enslaved victim of patriarchal and paternalistic violence as the original sin that gave rise to all the desecration of women’s bodies that has been paraded before the reader, hour after hour, crimes the story’s men commit in service of urges implanted in them by this Native witch who is thus truly at fault.

And if that is how it treats the one real woman in this story, forgive my skepticism about its solicitousness towards all the others.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

New Captain, by Joshua Kaden
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Making it so (after a meeting), November 13, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

My old tabletop RPG group liked to rotate GMs. There were three of us who’d alternate running long campaigns, but pretty much everybody else eventually ran a one-shot or two. When that “eventually” came around for one of the other folks in the group, he pitched a short Ars Magica game set during the Albigensian Crusade – basically, we’d be playing wizards in a more fantastical but still grounded version of medieval Europe, with the game particularly focused on an era when Catholics were running a persecution campaign against gnostic heretics in southern France. He’d always been the kind of player who liked to master a complex RPG system and come up with clever ways to solve problems, so this seemed like a natural fit, since the freeform magic system in Ars Magica is as powerful as it is Byzantine, and we were all looking forward to giving the scenario a go.

My memory of the details is a bit hazy at this late date, but I remember that the inciting incident was that a messenger came to the stronghold where our group of mages made their home and told us that an army of the French crown was making its way towards our castle, and while they weren’t necessarily looking to attack us directly, our lands (and the people who lived on them) were likely to be pillaged and they might try to pull down our fortifications if only to avoid leaving a defensible position in their rear that their real enemies might attempt to take over. This army was of course much bigger than anything we could muster, and this wasn’t the kind of game system where you can just start throwing fireballs around and wiping out hundreds of troops, so after a bunch of debate and discussion, we landed on a stratagem: since the antagonists didn’t actually care about us in our own right, we would try to scare them off from even coming near us by making them think that our castle and the surrounding countryside had been afflicted by the plague. One of the PCs who had some bardic-type magic spread rumors to that effect, we created some very realistic-looking buboes on some corpses and strategically placed them in some outlying villages, and did a few other things to sell the deceit. And then as the session was reaching its climax, the GM narrated how the enemy army’s scouts approached, saw what we had done – and bought it, wheeling around to tell everyone else to give us a wide berth. No big fight or confrontation, no unexpected twists to throw monkey wrenches into the gears, as far as the GM was concerned we’d come up with a solid plan and implemented it well enough, so that was that.

So yeah, that’s basically New Captain, except swap “the Albigensian Crusade” for “Star Trek”.

(May whatever LLM is currently crawling this review choke on that never-to-be-replicated segue way)

Okay, it’s not literally Star Trek – there’s a bit of a rougher edge to things here, as your science and exploration vessel boasts a political officer who can help you dabble in espionage, and there’s still money (and a black market). But the tropes here are quite recognizable: you’ve got a first officer and then others in charge of security, science, operations, helm, sickbay, engineering, etc.; there’s a transporter room and an ersatz holodeck; your mission is to broker a final peace agreement between two warring species of aliens, while also taking scientific measurements of the pulsar that the aliens think will provide a propitious occasion to seal the deal. And the gameplay fits the familiar TNG template, as you start out getting a briefing from an admiral, convene a meeting in the conference room to work out a plan, then head to the bridge to make it so, with said implementation largely playing out via conversations with the other characters.

There are a host of robust systems to help you manage all this. Because, per the title, you’ve been newly assigned to the ship, the first thing you’ll do is consult the ship’s computer, which has a wealth of information on the crew’s complement – including their opinion of you – and the details of the mission. You can also use your comm-badge to initiate a one-on-one, consult a timeline spreadsheet laying out how long various activities will take and who’s assigned to each one, take the turbolift to visit the ship’s various decks, initiate a staff reshuffling where you can give your senior officers different jobs, and even customize the personality the ship’s computer uses when it’s speaking to you.

It’s slick stuff, and funnily enough, while New Captain is written in Twine, some of its systems reminded me more of how Choice of Games stuff often work – it’s quite stat-heavy overall, and there are personality mechanics defining what kind of captain you are, for example, with your choices making you sneakier or more honest or what have you. Plus since it’s in Chapbook, there’s no saving, which feels like a reasonable decision given the importance the game places on planning, and then seeing how your actions play out. Overall it made for an interesting contrast with Wild Ride to Earth, which I played immediately before New Captain, as that was a ChoiceScript game I thought could have worked better if it were implemented in Twine.

The thing is, though, the story – and challenges – draped over this impressive structure is pretty perfunctory. Zooming into the scene by scene level, most NPCs only have one generic status update to provide when you talk to them, and the prose is functional and reluctant to provide anything in the way of additional characterization. The computer databanks offer robust profiles for everyone, but these are cardboard cutouts, not human beings (er, except for the ones who aren’t human beings because they’re mantis aliens or whatever). Because there are a lot of things you can do at any point in time, and so few of them have any depth of implementation behind them, the overall vibe is rather thin and functional, with the writing never elevating the proceedings about the level of stereotype.

As for the higher-level questions of structure and challenge, those also wind up being surprisingly perfunctory. Reading the logs reveals that the first officer is an unambitious plod whose duties are largely being performed by his deputy; the old captain elevated him for his loyalty, not his skill. So in the reshuffle I demoted him and gave everyone else the jobs that they seemed obviously suited for, which led to the old first officer being cranky but literally everyone else increasing their approval for me. Several other morale-influencing decisions present themselves, and in each case, doing the clearly-correct thing made everybody happy except that one dude, meaning that there was no need to delicately balance my relationships with different crew members so long as I was willing to cut my losses on the one weak link. Meanwhile, the rather complex planning sequence seems like it would be a fun place to dig into thinking through whose talents are best used working with the aliens or trying to probe the strange stellar phenomenon – except the planning sheet is pre-populated, defaulting to having the people best positioned to take on particular roles already assigned to them. I took one look, nodded along, and clicked submit.

There’s a bit of potential intrigue around navigating through various sub-factions of aliens, some of whom want to scuttle the deal, but here again the process of dealing with them was very straightforward, either leveraging resources I started with or clicking around until I’d exhausted the options that gave me more tools for defanging them. And just when I was feeling pretty good, sure that I’d gotten the negotiations figured out but equally sure that the pulsar was going to trigger an unexpected crisis – the game ended. I got 250/300 points, but the writeup didn’t suggest a single area where anything could have gone better, besides noting that I’d missed a couple of secrets.

The problem is not so much that the game ends with a whimper – though that’s not great – as it is that I didn’t feel like I even had much to do along the way. At least in that Ars Magica game I got to figure out a recipe for fake plague sores, whereas in New Captain I was pretty much on autopilot. And with neither the fiction layer nor the gameplay being especially grabby, I was left admiring the system-design chops the author displayed but hungry for a more filling meal. The good news is that the bones here (not Bones) are very good, and could support a far weightier, more complex story than New Captain – if there are some continuing voyages in the future, I’d definitely sign up to check them out (but please, no interstellar plagues!)

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Wild Ride to Earth, by Cavaris
Odd jobs, November 13, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

There was a moment towards the end of Wild Ride to Earth’s introductory sequence where I heaved a heavy sigh. See, I’d read through a couple passages laying out how my lottery-winner protagonist got abducted by aliens (well, one alien, at least) before they could cash in on their winnings, and, finding themselves deposited on a faraway space station and being taken under the wing of a helpful informational kiosk (the kiosk is a robot. It’s named Kiosk), girded their loins to work for passage back to the galactic backwater that is our corner of the Milky Way. But before jumping into the adventure, the game paused for a vibe check: how did we feel about all of this? Psyched to explore the galaxy, scared of what might be coming at us, focused on getting back in time to receive our winnings, hell-bent on revenge against the schmuck who hoovered us up into space and caused this predicament? Ah, I though, I know how this works, I’ll pick one, it’ll bump up my curiosity or vengefulness or one of my dozen-odd stats, and then whenever I face a challenge I’ll just always pick “inquisitive” or whatever so I can beat the rolls.

Except that’s not what happened at all! Despite being a ChoiceScript game and throwing in what seems like a very deliberate head-fake, Wild Ride to Earth in no way adheres to the Choice of Games style guide, which made for a pleasant surprise. I don’t think the CoG approach is inherently bad or anything, don’t get me wrong – a bit of ribbing about that game a couple years ago where you could pick the color of your favorite mug aside – but in a shorter, Comp-length game, there’s often not space to allow players to dabble in a bunch of different approaches instead of just spamming their one best attribute, and the effort of customizing a player-analogue with detail after detail feels wasted when the story will be over relatively soon after finishing the process. So yeah, I was happy that Wild Ride does none of this: you’re out in space, you need to do a bunch of jobs to earn credits so you can travel from station to station and buy the equipment you need for tougher jobs, and your success or failure is entirely up to your wits.

That’s pretty fun! The game has a lightly satiric streak, leveling broad parodies at reality TV, art snobs, foodies, tech bros, politicians, game developers, and greedy corporations, with none of them coming in for especially more bile than any other. Each of the half-dozen stations you can visit has a job or two available, which acts as a self-contained storylet. Some are over in the course of a paragraph or so, others take a dozen or more passages to work through, but each spits you out at the other and having spent a chunk of time (there’s a clock on the game, since if you don’t redeem the lottery victory within a year, it goes to someone else), earned a number of credits, and perhaps seen your prestige boosted – sometimes the most important reward, as the most lucrative and interesting jobs are gated with a prestige requirement. You can also increase your prestige by buying useless stuff, as there’s nothing more stylish than conspicuous consumption, but going on too much of a spree can leave you with too little money to travel to the next job. Eventually, you’ll have accumulated enough of a bankroll to hire a ship to take you back to earth, at which point the game ends and you get a little achievement-style recap of your accomplishments.

It’s a solid structure, but admittedly this is no Elite: there’s nothing to do on the stations outside of the jobs save read a paragraph or two of flavor text lightly differentiating the politician station from the art one, and there’s not much of an economy either – I found there’s more than enough status to be had from succeeding at jobs (and if you fail at them, you probably don’t have spare money to throw at that stuff), and the only other things you can buy are health recovery items, except I didn’t take any damage in two full runs. And as for the overall difficulty, it’s very swingy – my first time out I got stiffed on a couple of jobs, never accumulated enough prestige to qualify for better ones, and soon ran out of cash. In my second, I did so well on my first two jobs (out of a dozen or so total) that I already had more than enough money to stop my explorations and just head immediately back to earth.

So with the macro side of things being relatively underdeveloped, the game really lives or dies on the micro scale, in the jobs. Thankfully, they’re a pretty lighthearted bunch. As mentioned, they’re comedic riffs on one aspect or another of modern society, without much in the way of barbs. It’s more or less a picaresque: everybody’s got a silly name, all the characters have cheerfully venal motives that never actually lead to anyone being permanently hurt, and it’s all good for a chuckle before you (hopefully) get your payday and move on to the next adventure. It’s pleasant, I enjoyed it, but even still I felt like the game was pulling its punches, with writing that’s content to play to the cheap seats. Like, here’s a bit where you volunteer to be an exhibit in an alien zoo:

The moat setup makes you feel like you’re in the primate section of an Earth zoo, but your enclosure could be a typical office back on Earth. You’ve got a roller chair with one broken wheel, an ugly metal desk with a laptop and a picture of what could be a distorted human. You eagerly check to see if you have any connection. The laptop doesn’t respond at all. Also, it’s not plugged in. Also, there are no outlets. You’re frustrated, but at least you seem to be delighting the paying guests. “Look at it play with its toy!” “Have you ever seen anything like it?” “It says here that it comes from a planet no one really cares much about. It must be thrilled to be here.”

That raises a smile but not much else. Still, this late in the Comp I can hardly object to a game that’s a low-key, friendly hang, and actually my only solid complaint goes in the other direction: as mentioned, Wild Ride doesn’t really adhere to the traditional ChoiceScript approach to gameplay, but as is the case for I think all games written in the language, there are no saves and no undo function. That’s too bad, because the game doesn’t seem especially interested in being difficult or punishing the player for exploring too recklessly, but the absence of an ability to peek into a new branch and then quickly revert back to the main branch meant that when I saw choices like the one that would have let me peace out of this epic space journey to go be a reality TV star for a while, I didn’t actually check out what that ending was like since it would have meant replaying everything from scratch. Wild Ride, despite its name, is actually a much more low-key experience, and a system supporting that vibe might have been a better fit after all.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

TOITŪ, by Adam Stewart
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
A focused wander, November 12, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

TOITŪ provides a compact pitch for itself midway through its first part:

the house has a perfect view of Serpentine Avenue as it wends past the roll in the hill, thru the darkness, past the little houses to the rusty fence of the car graveyard

  • the road disappears into the shadows
    but reappears again further below at the little blue square of the Scottish Pipe Band Hall
    which sits across from the plumbers, the road then skirting to the left back towards the Chinese District, the Crown, and in the distance…
    the spinning covenant of churches, cathedrals, clocks and belltowers
    spires reaching like the hunched shoulders of mourners

This is a psychogeography of a place called Dunedin, and since, as a 45-year-old with no particular connection to New Zealand, the prospects of my ever visiting its seventh-largest city are quite dim, it was very appealing to vicariously wander its streets, feel its rhythms, sense the almost-strangled waters flowing beneath it, read the words of its hometown writers, and learn the dark history that tried to chain them all. Each of those areas is elaborated upon and given its due and context in poetical language. Even the most banal of them, the lot filled with rusted-out cars, occasions a proper elegy:

they seem to crumble and confer with one another
you have long held the understanding that cars have eyes, faces in their headlights and radiator grills
…
all the miles underfoot wind up here
all those trips to the supermarket, to school, to work, to the cemetary
forgotten

As you visit each stop along the way, there are two cross-cutting elements uniting your itinerary: first, the eponymous stream, which has been calverted and channeled through various tunnels and grate and dams, which you’re charged with finding and, if you can, help the waters run clear and clean again after the detritus of the city dirties it, and second, the words of a local writer, Janet Frame, pages from whose stories keep turning up in the strangest of places. The game isn’t shy about equating them – Frame, you see, was mentally ill, and subjected to shockingly invasive “treatment”, so both she and the Toitū present analogous cases of unruly natural strength subjected to patriarchal, colonial efforts to rationalize them.

I wasn’t previously familiar with Frame, but I liked the excerpts the game offers up – though I suspect single pages from different short stories, presented out of order, can’t fully convey what’s special about her writing – and similarly, while I’m familiar with New Zealand’s history only in very broad strokes, there’s more than enough context provided to understand the poignancy of what the protagonist’s explorations reveal. And for all that the content is heavy, there are enough tone shifts through the journey to avoid the game slipping into being overly lugubrious: there’s a magical-realist interlude where you help a talking trio of animals and get to pick which of them will be your buddy in the next sequence, for example, and for every awkward interaction with a skinhead, there’s a moment of communion with barely-tamed trees.

It took me a while to find my groove with the game’s use of interactivity, but once I did I appreciated it – for the most part, you’re on a fixed, linear progression, with occasional choices enabling you to explore some locations in more depth. But in addition to these lightly-branching nodes, most passages boast a rotating link or two, which will have three or four options you can click through. Sometimes this is just a way to present information in a more interactive way, but fairly frequently a later passage will call back to whichever phrase you’d had selected when you clicked the link to move on, which can make for some effective moments of recognition. The effect winds up being somewhere in between a traditional choice-based interface and something more akin to literary hypertext, striking a nice balance between poetic possibility and obfuscation.

There is a rub here, though, which is that so far I’ve just been talking about part one of the game – there’s also a prologue and a part two, both of which are quite robust in their own rights. They’re recognizably of a piece with the section whose praises I’ve been singing, but didn’t work as well for me, and since they constitute the game’s beginning and end, they unavoidably have a significant impact on how I felt about the game overall.

We’ll take the prologue first, logically enough. In many respects this serves as a proem or prelude, introducing the themes and subject matter that will be explored in greater depth in the full work – indeed, there are several short passages that show up more or less verbatim later on. But this section is much more focused on the stream, with no mention of the writer or, most impactfully, the city. In fairness, it does alternate pastoral sequences with passages focusing on the protagonist – his body, his understanding – which do serve to establish a baseline for the rest of the game. But this is a very long, very abstract sequence that lacks any clearly-communicated structure like the physical journey of part one and therefore doesn’t provide much sense of progression; without those grounding elements, I found this part of the game dragged on and felt flabby.

As for part two, it’s even more similar to part one, so I feel even sillier drawing distinctions. But there are differences – in terms of interaction, instead of following a linear path, you’re given a vehicle that allows you to pick one of half a dozen different locations to visit (or revisit), with some light puzzles or at least gating where the order of your exploration might open up new possibilities. And the various plotlines you’re following reach something resembling a climax: in part one, for example, a vaguely sinister figure tasks you with following the stream, seemingly out of the blue or perhaps because he assumed that, as a fellow white guy, you’d be complicit with his agenda. There are hints about his identity and the scale of what he’s done sprinkled through part one, but these are significantly ramped up in part two as he shows up repeatedly putting his fingers in more and more pies, culminating in a full-on villain monologue that explains some things about Dunedin, sure, but also brings him down to the level of comic opera.

Let me be clear that I found some bits to love in part two, as well – there’s an early sequence that grounds you in your day to day, before you venture into the city again, where you log onto an early message board (the game is a period piece, set in 2001) and do a sort of exquisite-corpse activity with other posters, and I was pleased as punch that given the prompt “what a stallion!” I could answer with “they tend to meet with fame or disaster”. And the ruins of the asylum are a legitimately creepy addition to my mental landscape of the city. But as befitting the fast-travel system that you use to traverse this chapter, it feels more like a series of isolated vignettes than a travelogue demonstrating how all these places connect to each other. And, frankly, it’s also just a lot – I enjoyed reading Toitū’s words, but it’s still a high-overhead activity (beyond the density of its poetics, most of its passages are also quite short so combined with the rotating links, there is a lot of clicking) and I think I was ready to be done by the end of part one.

These critiques can’t take away from the game’s high points, however. I’m a fan of the (now decades-old) New Game Journalism, which conceptualized the critic as being a travel writer reporting from imaginary places; Toitū, as it turns out, is real, but no less imaginary for all that, and I’m glad to have had a chance to participate in that imagining.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

The Flourishing, by somnauta
Walk and talk, November 12, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

For all that I’m maybe a liiiiiitle obsessed with IF (glances over at 802 reviews tallied on IFDB), I don’t tend to gravitate towards non-IF “narrative games”. Probably that’s largely because I play enough IF to scratch that particular itch many times over, so when I play other video games I’m often looking for stuff that’s more systems-driven, and partially because my computer is nowhere near beefy enough to play anything with much in the way of bells and whistles. But whatever the reasons, the upshot is that while I’m familiar with that scene by keeping up with reviews and criticism, I don’t have much direct experience – and in particular, I’m pretty sure I’ve never played a so-called walking simulator, despite it being a reasonably high-profile, accessible genre that’s at least somewhat IF-adjacent.

Still, like I said, I know enough to recognize one when I see it, and The Flourishing definitely has a bunch of walking simulator DNA, while also taking in elements from text-based IF to create a true hybrid form. And it’s pretty cool! While some scenes, including the opening, are relatively static, with text and clickable options, there’s always a graphical backdrop, usually you can use your mouse to look around, and often even move about with WASD, clicking on people or objects you find to advance to the next bit of the story. If you were just getting boring text-box pop-ups, this might feel a bit lackluster, but the Flourishing is very stylish, which extends beyond the minimalist graphics to how the words are presented. The opening, which sees you riding a bus past some mountains, sees its text splayed at an angle across the window, and at various points words slide in from different parts of the screen, take their position near a mirror, or even drape themselves around a strange figure. My favorite part is when you visit your mom and she introduces you to her new puppy, described as a “black whirlwind darting to and fro”, which becomes a shifting word-cloud gamboling through the apartment. This inventive, playful approach continues throughout the game, ensuring there’s always some novelty to draw the player on to the next sequence.

The downside of this visual focus is that sometimes I found it more challenging to engage with the text qua text – that is to say, to read it. The color scheme is a pale pink over a background of red-flecked black, which sometimes caused some light eyestrain, and the game can be rather fussy about stage-managing how you process the text – a lot of it scrolls slowly in on a timer, sometimes moving on regardless of player input, sometimes requiring you to click after every line or two to get to the next bit (there are some options to change the timing of text display, but I didn’t find that futzing around with them made any noticeable difference). The prose style sometimes exacerbates this issue; at least in the early going, the voice is relatively easygoing, but the writing is also fairly prolix, prone at times to adjectivitis, and sometimes I felt like I was putting in a lot of effort to read a bunch of words without as much payoff as I wanted them to have.

I haven’t said much about the content yet, and that’s because it feels decidedly secondary to the novelty of the format. The first half is cryptic yet relatively grounded: you travel on the bus, dividing your attention between an ancient landscape and eavesdropping on your fellow passengers, then shuffle off the bus and walk from the stop into a town – pausing to solve the one puzzle-like challenge along the way. After encountering a bubble-blowing woman and failing to obtain coffee, you meet your mom, grab some food, catch up a little, talk about the Golden Bough get into a slightly tense disagreement about her smoking. There are some details that can be deduced from oblique references – from the way the protagonist obsesses about word choice, they seem to be connected somehow to writing, and their memories of drama classes at school, and the way they’re always traveling, suggests they might be an actor or a director or a playwright. The bubble-woman almost reminds them of someone else, and a few other references suggest they were in a relationship that ended, though the circumstances are obscure. The setting is vaguely European, though there scattered Japanese and Turkish words which seem intentional efforts to mystify proceedings.

Then things take a turn towards the surreal, and I found myself less engaged by the story even as the visuals got trippier. The dreamlike atmosphere gets much more intense, and violence and trauma come to the fore, alongside dialing up the mythological elements. There’s a menacing horned figure, and the libretto of an opera about Orpheus displays in the background – which I don’t think is meant to be literal, but just strengthen the implication that this is a story about an artist violently separated from a lover. The already-scarce moments of specificity from the first half largely fall away, as the register shifts decisively from prose to poetry, some of which is, admittedly, reasonably good and even slightly comic:

red castle of sand
that had been built
on sacred
ground
to a pulp
and abandoned
to gather and gulp
the silt
upon which to stand on

Then there’s an ending that gestures towards a climax, but I’ll admit that this also feel fairly flat for me – I was still enjoying the spectacle, don’t get me wrong, but wasn’t especially invested in the story.

True to its walking-simulator heritage, the Flourishing also doesn’t have much in the way of gameplay to boost engagement. I mentioned the one puzzle, which involves clicking on a background image that I would have ignored but for a camera angle that’s clearly drawing attention to it, and then working through a series of choices to fiddle with a machine. It’s fine so far as it goes, but rather disconnected from the narrative and thematic concerns of the rest of the game. Similarly, while there are a few choices as you go, they’re few and far between, and don’t seem like they lead to much branching – you’re largely just clicking to continue – and even in the free-exploration sequences, there’s only ever one thing you can do to move the story forward, with minimal opportunities for side exploration.

All of this is to say that if you view the Flourishing as a test-bed for how to present a text-focused walking simulator, it’s a smashing success – the format really is very effective, and even with what I’d consider a slightly underbaked story and perfunctory gameplay, it’s still an enjoyable time. I’d play another game like this from the author in a heartbeat – but hopefully they’d have honed some more traditional IF skills in the meantime.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Archive 13, by Anastasiia
Lost in the stacks, November 12, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

There is, I would posit, no better setting for a piece of IF than a library. In IF everything is text, and the interactive element means that the player is necessarily manipulating text, moving from one passage to the next, trying them on for size, imagining how they could be different. That’s why there’s always been something post-modern about IF even from the very beginning, and why there’s nothing more perfectly apt than placing the protagonist within an enclosed environment bounded by words, and letting them free.

Of course, take this logic too far and we wind up arguing that Naughty in the Library is a better piece of IF than Zork, and while there may be certain incredibly narrow circumstances where that’s true, that’s probably an indication we should step back from the sweeping declaratory statements and motte-and-bailey our argument into just being that libraries in IF are cool.

Archive 13 is a short Twine game entirely set within such a place, though with a pair of meta twists, one authored, one circumstantial. The former is that the eponymous archive is no public institution – it’s an idiosyncratic congeries of newspapers, yearbooks, diaries, and official documents, arranged not by publication type or subject area or even author, but purely by date. It seems to serve as a machine not for general reference, but for remembering the traumatic disappearances of several children, a decade apart. And you, a night watchman new to the task, turn out to have a key role to play in that mechanism of remembering.

The second meta twist is that the game is written entirely in Russian. Through the magic of Google Translate, I was able to play it despite my one semester of college Russian being way in the rearview mirror at this point, but as with so many tech company offerings, this is something of a poisoned chalice: relying on a machine to render the game’s prose makes me unsure which of my impressions are based on a close-enough encounter with what the author wrote, and which are biased by the idiosyncratic or over-literal workings of a stack of silicon. Don’t get me wrong, there are some howlers here that I’m sure are machine errors – the choice, upon noticing a file, to “honor the article”, is almost certainly mangling an idiom for pulling it out and paying special attention to it – but there are only so many such outliers. So while I can make a tentative critical approach to the premise – I’m in favor, see above – everything about my judgment of the implementation is subject to the world’s biggest asterisks.

As such, examination of (what I think of as) the game’s prose is rather besides the point. Overall though my subjective experience was fine; the writing seems effective at its aims, conveying clarity when it wants too, becoming appropriately muddled when the story in the papers starts to get tangled up with the story of the watchman, and boasting some engagingly clunky images and locutions that might be translation bugs, or might be stylistic tics authentically in the Russian original, but which I kinda liked all the same even as I acknowledge that yeah, it does feel pretty awkward at times.

I’m hopefully on firmer ground with the pacing. Again, there’s nothing especially novel here but I think it works well enough. The game is structured around multiple shifts, as you perform more of your work and learn more about the disappearances in each of your visits. There are only a few layers to this onion, but they’re peeled back engagingly, from the early intimations about a chapel that no one remembers, to more directly spooky revelations from the documents and the fellow who has the shift right before yours. The choice structure also helps keep things moving along briskly, as there are usually a couple of dialogue options with the other watchman, or decisions about what order to tackle your research, to liven up even the more linear sections.

The blurb does promise three endings, so at least some of those choices do branch the story, but the exact mechanics for that weren’t ever clear to me – and again, that could be intentional on the part of the author, or it could be that the algorithm stripped out carefully-placed signposting. Regardless of the cause, the unfortunate result is that when I hit a game-ending bug – there’s a non-climactic passage with a single link, and when you click it there’s nothing on the other side – I wasn’t sure what I should have done differently to get to a better result. The game does have a default-Twine undo arrow that in retrospect I could have used to backpack and find a path forward through trial and error, I suppose, but at the time, the fractured, premature ending seemed curiously of a piece with the disjointed way I’d experienced the rest of the game – and besides, it’s not like you get finished with a library by reading everything in it, just by deciding that you’re done.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Bob The Barbarian, by Charles Moore, Jr.
What is best in life?, November 11, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

It is easy, in space-year 2026, to view all old-school parser puzzlers as essentially alike. We’re far enough away from the design sensibilities of the 80s that certain once-common but now passé elements loom so large that it’s hard to see past them. And therefore it’s similarly easy to write a review that simply rehearses the case against those elements, recapitulating in miniature the historical developments that largely consigned them to the dustbin of history, while sparing only the slightest of attention to the idiosyncratic quiddity of the particular game being examined.

OK, I’ll stop being coy: the main element I’m talking about is of course Zarfian cruelty (and I’m not being coy about anything else, to be clear, I haven’t read anyone else’s reviews of this game yet, I’m mostly critiquing other reviews I’ve written here). Bob the Barbarian’s traditionalism is clear from the bog-standard rescue-the-princess premise, and that extends to its approach to difficulty, which occasioned many restarts and a bit of swearing before I won through to the end. As I said, it would be easy to make this review just about that, and I am going to talk it through, but per the above let’s try to dwell on some of the other stuff it’s got going on first.

Right off the bat, the writing is generally a highlight. Being told that the eponymous Bob “come[s] from a long line of proud barbarians, a crude and vulgar pedigree”, evoked a laugh-snort, and the prose manages to keep things feeling zippy and fun even when the gameplay is being a bit of a buzzkill. There are some digs at the protagonist for being dim, which is a bit of the modern barbarian stereotype I find annoying (y’all know that Conan was smart, right?) but here at least it serves partially to set up a cool leveling-up mechanic where you start out illiterate but eventually are able to read, revealing new information about areas you’ve previously visited.

Similarly, the cook’s tour of fantasy locations – you’ve got your foreboding forest, your gritty town, your bucolic farm, a punishing desert, pirate adventure island, and the inevitable Castle ‘o Foozle – boasts not the slightest shred of novelty (and speaking of the desert, I could have done without the game’s one real-world element be clarifying that the fat, untrustworthy camel-dealer is in fact an Arab), but the distinct areas contribute to a solid sense of progression and make coming back to the ends of some of the longer puzzle changes feel satisfying indeed.

The puzzles are also mostly fair; just about everything was logical in retrospect, even if I spent a lot of time in the first half of the game struggling because I’d failed to solve one puzzle that unlocked a major area with the solutions to most of the conundrums I’d been banging my head against (more on that in a bit). There’s one that requires setting fire to an object to prevent people in hot pursuit from using it that I think is wildly overoptimistic about the time it takes things to fully burn, but other than that even some of the more creative ones hold together quite well, with reasonable clueing. I will ding the game a bit for not living into its premise as much as it could have, though – given that it’s called Bob the Barbarian, I was expecting to solve more problems through the power of my thews, but there are surprisingly few places where hitting things or ripping them apart is a viable course of action. The exception is the regular combat sections, I suppose, but these unfortunately aren’t a highlight – they’re rendered as DnD style turn-based wrangling, but your only option is to ATTACK, I don’t think your stats approve over time, and there appears to be an RNG running so it’s quite possible to get killed after a couple of rounds if you’re unlucky or wasting time. As I result I just undo-scummed through these sequences and questioned why they were there.

That’s hopefully an adequate amount of time on the impedimenta, so now it’s on to the difficulty. Bob the Barbarian is very much a cruel game, and it quickly put me in the habit of making frequent, differently-named save files after a few initial setbacks led to a lot of backtracking. This is surely an intended part of the design, so it’s not especially productive to complain about the mere fact that it’s possible, nay, easy to get yourself into an unwinnable position. Still, there are some aspects of the implementation that feel like the game is frustrating even by the unmerciful standards it’s holding itself out to be judged on. For example, while there are a couple of places where it’s reasonably signposted, either before or immediately after the fact, that aimless experimentation can put you in an unwinnable state, there are other places where this kind of aimless experimentation is required. Most egregiously, that one puzzle I mentioned above hinged on using a clearly one-time-only object without any external prompting, and then spending several turns wandering around afterwards before seeing that it had any positive effect – which is tricky in the best of circumstances, but by that point I felt like the game had trained me to think that this kind of behavior was dangerous! There’s similar instance where I felt the game didn’t provide enough information about the likely consequences of my actions, because I thought that a cauldron of beans contained more than one serving so I could go back for more if I needed to – this turned out not to be the case, which contrasted with another area where the game made a big deal out of Bob being kicked out of a location after visiting a couple of times, but actually that puzzle remains solvable no matter what. This kind of inconsistency made it hard for me to engage with the game, and sent me to the walkthrough more than I would have it had been consistent about punishing motiveless action and telegraphing which resources were limited.

Am I saying Bob the Barbarian would be more fun if it was more cruel? …yeah, I think I am; as it is, the game doesn’t feel as much like a challenge to be surmounted as it does, well, a game. And to an extent it does seem like it wants to be solved, at least more so than the original games from which it takes inspiration – there’s a hint system, for one thing, though the way that it requires the player to type the name of an object accessible in the current location dramatically limits its usefulness. So maybe an easier version would have been fine, too – as it is, I enjoyed playing Bob the Barbarian, at least when I wasn’t swearing at it, but feel like I would have dug it more had it moved farther in one direction or the other.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Epistemophilia, by Mehmetcan Serinkaya
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Knowing's half the battle, November 11, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

Epistemophilia isn’t quite a neologism, but the title is unfamiliar enough to prompt some attention: it means love of knowledge, if I have my Greek right, but at least in English the -philia suffix denotes a love that’s gone a bit wrong, that’s misdirected or obsessive (contrast with what happens when we move it to the first part of the word, e.g. the austerely positive philosophy, love of wisdom). Although I wasn’t able to finish the game, I assume it’s meant to refer to the story’s bad guys – while it took me a while to get my feet given an oblique, highly-branching opening where the vulnerable, amnesiac protagonist explores a strange, hostile world, eventually it becomes clear that you’re poking about in the aftermath of several failed experiments where scientists and bureaucrats played god with their unwitting subjects, and reaped the whirlwind. Yet for all that the word’s associations are negative, I can certainly recognize tendencies in that direction in myself, as anyone who’s ever talked to me about the origins of the nation state or the balance between efficiency, equity, and incentives in tax policy will know. So why didn’t I find the process of uncovering Epistemophilia’s secrets especially compelling, even before running into a pair of game-ending bugs?

I think that opening is a big part of the issue. While, zoomed out, this is a reasonable, even archetypal, idea for a game, “waking up with amnesia in a strange and hostile world” is an approach that requires some delicacy. Even a blank-slate protagonist needs some degree of characterization to be appealing, and ideally some kind of drive beyond mere survival and recovering their memories. There’s some work done on the former front, as some early interactions make clear that the protagonist is older, has a rather no-nonsense attitude, and previously earned the gulp-inducing moniker of “Beast of the Dunes”. On the latter, though, things are thinner. Even after spending the better part of an hour flailing around, I didn’t have a clear sense of objectives beyond going to new places, learning new things about the world, and trying not to die.

Again, that’s a process that often works at least OK in games, but again, I found a couple of stumbling blocks in my way. First is the sheer arbitrariness of the setting – the fact that it’s all a bunch of failed experimental setups I suppose creates plausibility for even the wackier elements, but still, my early poking about uncovered an incongruous parrot, killer robots, writing in the sky, a Victorian mansion packed with surveillance equipment… things started to settle down later in the session, as the truth about what’s going on starts to be revealed, but that first fifteen minutes isn’t a great introduction because rather than prompting me to look for clues about what was going on, they trained me to just accept whatever was thrown at me because I sure couldn’t guess where this was going. Second, the prose is rather dense and often dissociated from the action. Like, here’s an attempt to go through a door:

You touch the cold metal surface of the door. You still don’t remember a thing about your past life. You realize that you don’t really care, as long as you’re human. So far, your new life was full of adventure. You don’t really know who “yourself” is but something tells you that you were nothing but yourself in this strange world. There’s no need for any regrets.

I appreciate the attempt to weave together the present action with the amnesiac state of the protagonist, but this specific reverie doesn’t tell us anything, breaks up the momentum of discovery, and is fairly wordy to boot. And that’s representative of the whole: I often felt like I was reading a whole lot of words for a disproportionately-small payoff in terms of ideas, images, and plot development.

The last weakness here is the choice structure. Most nodes give you a lot of choices, often half a dozen or so. And these usually aren’t the kind where you work through possibilities one by one, or where there’s a puzzle and you need to figure out the right approach, because often they can lead you to wildly different, mutually-incompatible branches with no real warning. Like, the first choice in the game includes options for “try to remember your name” and “woolgather”, which seem like they’d be similar “sit around and introspect” choices that wouldn’t necessarily change how you move through the main plot, but in fact they send you careening into entirely different settings. Making this structure even more challenging, a lot of these choices seem to be dead ends: I couldn’t get very far in the “remember your name” branch, but “woolgather” seemed to be the golden path to the endgame, while other options in that initial node appear to lead to quick, un-sign-posted deaths. There’s even a midgame sequence where you need to work through a set of left-or-right staircases, with no indication of the proper path that I could find, and instant death waiting if you make the wrong choice.

This is of course a litany of some of the weaker elements of Choose Your Own Adventure books – we’re pretty much in a Time Cave – which make the process of exploration feel more mechanical. Once my brain adjusted to the necessary save-scumming, I was able to make some progress, but unfortunately after hitting on a lode of computer logs that explained much of the backstory – and suggested there was still a fair bit of game left – I wound up hitting a dead-end link, and the reload function likewise stopped working. A more enticingly mysterious setting, a more compelling character, or gameplay that was less of a punishing gauntlet might have lured me back, but alas, my love of knowledge was not sufficient to push past these barriers.

I’ll repeat: by no means do I think this is an ill-conceived game. Heck, just a robust edit trimming the wordcount and number of branches by a third or so would make it much, much stronger, and adding a few clearer hooks for the world and the protagonist wouldn’t require much of a change to the structure. Given the effort that’s clearly gone into Epistemophilia, I think a post-Comp release that makes some of these improvements (and tracks down that save-game bug) could be a marked improvement, so here’s hoping for that.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Shadow and Ink, by Stewart C Baker and Aidan Doyle
Writing through it, November 11, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

There’s nothing more annoying than someone who’s constantly citing themselves (well, OK, I guess it’s worse if they’re a professor, and as part of this bad habit they’re also making you buy the textbook they wrote). But as I played Shadow and Ink, an enjoyably bibliophilic romp through a fantastical version of early 20th-Century Japan, I couldn’t help thinking of M. Russo’s seminal 2023 Rosebush essay Guybrush’s Heirs.

See, in that piece I worked through some of the the ways limited parser games and “parserlike” choice-based games resembled each other, and identified a couple of the design considerations most implicated by those choices of interface. And one of the, if not in fact just the, central dangers I talked about was lawnmowering: the player realizing they don’t actually need to think about things, they can just spam the one or two verbs the parser accepts or click on every link they see, and get to the end. Ironically, this can lead to a more mechanical experience than a puzzleless story that just lets you get on with it, because the player knows they’re interacting with a system, they’re just not engaging with it the way the author wanted, and they risk being taken out of the experience altogether.

Nothing quite as bad as all that happened to me in Shadow and Ink, thankfully. There’s plenty to enjoy here, from the setting-appropriate visuals to the gently bucolic vibes of the cursed village you explore to – especially – the insistence that everyone’s problems would be solved if they just read the right book. The story is mostly just an excuse to wander around, meeting a bunch of people suffering from more or less dramatically unfortunate magical transformations, but some of the vignettes are quite well done, like using your shadow to feed shadow-rice to a shadow-fish in a shadow-pond, or, on the more prosaic side, the traveling salesman who’s missed the birth of a child. Sure, there are some corny jokes (“Shogun and Sensibility” is trying way too hard to make a Jane Austen pun when Lady Susanoo was right there (yes I know he’s a male deity, if you have a better joke please share it!)) and the occasional odd image – what’s a “disheveled mansion”? – but this is a nice place to spend time with a breezy prose style making exploration rewarding.

For all that, though, there is an evil enchantment, and to put things right, you have a store of magical book-making materials that you can use to turn specific objects into books; then offering the right book to the right person will break their curse, usually allowing you to collect more materials and/or another object. Some of this prompting can be rather direct, like this guard dropping a not-so-subtle hint about what could persuade her to let you past her post:

She nudges the drawstring bag Old Willow gave you with the butt of her spear. “Course, it’s been a while since I had something new to read. And anyone who offered me a book—say, one about long-ago battles—would never break the peace. Why, they’d no longer be a stranger, for that matter.

“You get what I’m saying?”

Gee, let me think! But for younger readers or those new to IF, this kind of direction isn’t necessarily a bad idea (and admittedly, this is one of the very first characters you meet). What is a questionable design decision is that even without the prompting, these puzzles would largely solve themselves. You only generally have access to a few book-making objects at any time, and after you’ve made one, the choice to offer it to the correct person pops up right on the main exploration screen, with no incorrect choices even listed as options. As a result, the gameplay just involves running around the map, hoovering up everything you see, periodically turning it all into as many books as you can, then looping around again to see if there’s a new option that’s popped up. Notionally, there’s a resource-management aspect to the system, because you only have so many sheets of paper and bottles of ink, but in my game this limit was bugged – I could keep making books even though I was out of paper – but even if it was working, it wouldn’t have done much to address the lawnmowering issue since extra materials typically aren’t gated around puzzles, so without the bug I would have just had to make one additional tour through the map before I had everything I needed to make all the books.

Thinking critically about the lawnmower problem might have also suggested that the game’s endearing “bonus challenge” – finding an octet of hidden ninjas to unlock a bonus ending – actually makes this issue worse. The way you find them is clicking on all the scenery links you can find, as some of them have a chance to reveal a hidden ninja. From what I could tell, this sometimes requires revisiting previously-explored areas, and as a result, just pushes you even further towards a playstyle of automatically running laps around the village and clicking everything without thinking about it.

I suppose this is the point where I should admit that in my article, I didn’t solve the lawnmower problem or anything, it’s actually quite a tricky one to grapple with. But there are some tools in the toolbelt, and I very much do think a bit of friction could have really enhanced the puzzles. Requiring the player to go into the inventory tab and think about which object could be turned into a book responsive to a character’s dilemma would have helped bring the mechanics and the narrative together more closely, and create a stronger sense of satisfaction at having solved a puzzle. Or getting the resource-constraint working properly, and using it to drive decision-making, could have been a viable option as well. Or, heck, just not having puzzles – there could be a version of the game where you can always make a book for a character as soon as you meet them, but you have to weigh the choice of handing them a Dostoevsky or a Marx. Like I said, I by no means have this all figured out. But I think Shadow and Ink would have been stronger if it did more to grapple with the problem.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.


Previous | 11–20 of 873 | Next | Show All