Code Name Silver Steel

This game came to my attention via tags linking it to Spider and Web, which is one of my all-time favorite works of IF. It didn't sound quite as interesting, but I've enjoyed a couple of spy-themed works lately (like Moonbase Indigo and Zodiac), so it seemed worth a shot.

It wasn't.

This is probably the "best" of any game I've ever rated as 1-star. It functions, after a fashion. It can be completed, and in fairly short order. The spelling and punctuation are satisfactory. The premise seems sufficiently promising. Unfortunately, it lacks any aspect that would make it a worthwhile play experience and thus qualifies for my "no redeeming qualities" criterion.

This game would have qualified for at least two stars if there were any indication of sustained effort on the part of the author, but there is none. More than anything else, Code Name Silver Steel is just plain lazy in its production value. There are probably a dozen or fewer significant interactions, maybe twenty objects, and not quite a half dozen rooms. After finishing, I was surprised to see that it was published in 2017, and that it was written using Inform 7. The 3-star average awarded by the handful of registered players made me assume that it was written in Inform 6 about twenty years earlier.

The overall scale and complexity of this work is probably no more than twice what would be required to implement Cloak of Darkness. If I were going to recommend this work to anyone, it would be on similar basis, i.e. not as something to play, but as a basic scenario to implement as a test of capabilities (though in this case authorial capabilities instead of system capabilites). This game could be done well enough to be worth playing -- why not give it a shot?

[After writing this I remembered One Night in San Francisco, which is a close cousin to this game. See that for a somewhat improved implementation of the same basic idea.]