Go to the game's main page

Review

Dante's Least-Loved, November 20, 2026
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

Adapted from an IFCOMP26 Review

Purgatory delivers a looping tale of horror, the player/protag repeating an abstract ‘day’ of violence and turmoil. I really respect what it is trying here, and am confounded that this premise, this execution did not land for me. I love horror AND time loops! As I tossed this dilemma around, I think I came to the conclusion that this particular story would be better served without the interactivity. Or at least THIS implementation of interactivity. Here’s how I got there. I guess a numbered list is as good a framework as any.

  1. The player-protag disconnect. This is probably the biggest one. The work’s central conceit drives straight into this artifact. We are asked to drive a protagonist in a day at the office. The options we are presented with are extreme, coercive, and unnatural. And we are asked to make them without context of any kind. Nothing about those choices invites us to merge with the protagonist, quite the opposite. We take choices because we HAVE to, but are resisting their stark illogic the entire time. This ends up being narratively justified, by the way, but only after the player-protag gulf has yawned impossibly wide.

As the day goes on, we learn more about the protag, and everything we learn is repugnant and distancing. Then the day restarts. Ok, so now we are incentivized to try something new, meaning the NEXT LEAST REPULSIVE option. And sure enough, they are worse! Eventually, the cumulative effect of these loops and decreasingly convincing choices paint a picture of our protagonist and the fate they are suffering. Thing is, every step of the way we are given details and choices that underline how NOT US this protag is. Every loop gives us less reason to empathize with them, more reasons to think their fate is deserved, more reasons to resent the choices we are becoming complicit in.

  1. The looping mechanism itself. When looping games reuse text, there is an effect on the reader. “I’ve seen this before, where is the new stuff?” Our eyes glaze over, and the mechanics of repetition pull us away from the text. This is an artistic choice other media have conquered. Happy Death Day is a wonderful time loop-slasher mashup that I have infinite affection for. It gets its looping exactly right. The Final Girl protagonist is looping, experiencing the same events repeatedly throughout the movie. Crucially, her REACTIONS to those loops evolve throughout the story, going from incredulous to comedic to tragic. No two loops FEEL the same because our protagonist is on the same discovery journey we-the-viewer are. Her compounding reactions are both relatable and entertaining. Despite the common events, the narrative still feels propulsive. Here, by reusing vast swaths of text with only slight tweaks it feels much more wheel-spinny, repetitive, and less engaging. A non-interactive implementation of this would not rely on looping text, it could move forward against its repeating set pieces. I grant that this repetition has a narrative function, arguably a critical one for the aims of the piece. It’s just, this function is prioritized over player engagement.

  2. The repellent nature of the protagonist, once fully revealed. The title of the piece is spot on. As the loops progress, it becomes clear the loop is (Spoiler - click to show)a trial, a punishment, a reckoning that might someday lead to redemption. Thing is, as we grow to understand WHAT needs redeeming, the loop is either too harsh (because the infraction was symbolic) or too generous (because… it wasn’t symbolic at all, meaning redeemed how?), and neither of those possibilities resonate for the PLAYER who has only committed infractions because of the game’s inflexible architecture! If the theme of the piece is to be honored, the infractions at the heart must be internalized, not mentally rejected.

Looking at those three observations it really comes down interactivity. It is OUR presence, our outsider mindset that is the jarring component here. The protagonist, the setup, the chain of events are all poetic and justified and suitably horrific. By putting us in the protag’s shoes, with none of their inciting motives or guilt, we feel unfairly chained to the proceedings. We are selecting among dire choices that make no sense to us, and the ultimate protag revelations come too late to justify the journey.

As an interactive experience, it kept me at an arms length, Mechanically clicking links because I had to. If I had instead encountered this as an episode of, say, Twilight Zone, this would hit so much harder. There, we get to be the dispassionate observer of bad choices, bad actors, and poetic justice. Character revelations and surprises come from a place of new information, not complicit choices. Actions justify consequences. By being railroaded into actions, the consequences never feel like OURS, and come across as punishment for someone else’s transgressions. What develops into Justice for the protagonist is INjustice for the player.

Postscript: It doesn’t fit cleanly into the thesis of my review, but I wanted to acknowledge that the line “His bald face vaguely reminds you of the punchballs hanging at those funfair machines” is my favorite of the Comp, four games in.

Played: 9/2/26
Playtime: 15m
Artistic/Technical ratings: Mechanical/mostly seamless
Would Play After Comp?: No, experience seems complete

Artistic scale: Bouncy, Mechanical, Sparks of Joy, Engaging, Transcendent
Technical scale: Unplayable, Intrusive, Notable (Bugginess), Mostly Seamless, Seamless

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.