Adapted from an IFCOMP26 Review
For purposes of IFCOMP, I render a work's score as a function of my Artistic and Technical assessments. This push-pull of two warring criteria begs a question: are technical problems a CEILING on this score, or is artistic impression a FLOOR? I’m not sure why I’m bringing that up here, he said disingenuously. Let’s drop that for now and look at, no, LISTEN TO Dear Anna.
Anna is a wonderful, fascinating audio experience. It is structured as a collection of audio clips: voice mails, audio diaries, interviews (of sorts), recollections. All hearsay reminisces of an enigmatic woman circling their lives. It is COMPELLING. The voice acting is terrific (with one quibble - the recollections do not carry the weight of knowledge we have not learned yet, but the characters have. Contemporary sound clips are not weighed down by this.) Ignore the parenthetical. Even with that qualification, the clips were uniformly transportive. I spent the majority of my 1.5hrs in my recliner, headphones on, eyes closed, just drinking it in.
The titular subject of these audio clips is a tragic, magnetic presence throughout it all. Her depths are revealed by contradictory and complementary anecdotes from those in her orbit, painting a fully realized character unable to escape her demons and not deriving meaning from a social circle that derives meaning from her. She simultaneously touches everyone around her, while remaining untouchable herself - a tragic isolation, profoundly communicated.
Late in the story, details start clashing. One narrator’s identity seems confused, some parent/daughter timelines get jumbled. It could be a nod to the transience of memory, of people remembering things differently, except some are contemporary audio artifacts that should not be so clouded. Instead of degrading the experience with ‘plot holes’ it rather has the effect of hyper-reality, of alternate life paths that while perhaps not true to conventional cause-effect timeline is somehow even MORE true to the central character. The timeline may muddy, but the character study sharpens. All in all, the audio storytelling was Engaging, nearly Transcendent. Were this a scripted podcast we would be done now.
Of course, were this a scripted podcast, I would not be reviewing it for IFCOMP. I found the least accomplished part of the work the interactivity itself. A few reasons for this.
For one, as a presumptive archive of audio clips, we are given vanishingly little control over how to consume them. This has no impact on the narrative per se, but the FACT that it doesn’t highlights how inessential the interactions are. For large swaths of the story, the clips will simply transition from one to the other. A click is available to do so, but if not it will forward anyway. Occasionally, we are invited to sample an additional audio aside or bypass it. As an audio mosaic, it is unclear WHY we would choose to bypass any of it, but choose we must. It seems to me if the game were structured as a massive collection of clips that we autonomously navigate, this might feel more organic, instead of screeching a flowing narrative to a stop for some token clicking.
Then there were the bugs. Peppered throughout the proceedings are notes or documents. Whether they have audio attached or not, they flash on the screen, linger for maybe two seconds, then forward to the next. This required a frenzy of backpage/read next sentence/auto-advance/repeat until fully read. A uniquely UNsatisfying way to consume lore. The audio mix had issues too: two characters (Mark and Sarah) were nearly inaudible against the (wonderfully moody) background music, requiring dynamic setting futzing, then REfutzing when another character steps in. Finally, some link options just silently did nothing when clicked. All of this technical wobbliness summed to a Notable intrusion into the experience.
So you see my opening dilemma? A wonderfully Engaging, complex character study, with Notably intrusive interactivity. What do I do with those lemons? I make lemonade, that’s what! This is a FEATURE, not a bug. I am empowered to decide WHICH of those criteria are dominant on a work-by-work basis. In this case, my IF COMP score tilted Artistic.
Played: 9/2/26
Playtime: 1.5hrs
Artistic/Technical ratings: Engaging/Notable technical gaps)
Would Play After Comp?: No, experience seems complete
Artistic scale: Bouncy, Mechanical, Sparks of Joy, Engaging, Transcendent
Technical scale: Unplayable, Intrusive, Notable (Bugginess), Mostly Seamless, Seamless