Go to the game's main page

Review

What Fools These IF'ers Be, November 19, 2026
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

Adapted from an IFCOMP26 Review

At some point in everyone’s life, you’ve consumed more RIFFS on Shakespeare than the bard’s actual work. It’s really a single variable function: how much original Shakespeare do you engage? The culture at large (at least Western culture) is going to throw those riffs at you in a never-ending light rain of works, the numerator if you will. Your exposure to Shakespeare is the denominator and the only variable actually under your control. It’s a weird dynamic though. If your denominator is small enough, you end up encountering large swaths of work ONLY via its riffs. Midsummer Night’s Dream is one such work for me. I believe I have a functional grasp of its beats and characters without ever consuming the original. This is the benighted perspective this review will spring from.

See, culture has figured out the hack. Shakespeare’s originals are foundational to Western storytelling, exploring a daunting array of themes, tones and settings. And doing it really, really well! It is unfair to suggest derivative works are pirating the Bard’s accomplishments to achieve unearned impact. A more generous read is that those original works are just so INSPIRING that they become simultaneously beloved and the muse for further exploration. Like constructing a new house on a Frank Loyd Wright foundation. It’s hard to imagine a BETTER foundation, but the implicit challenge is that the building doesn’t pale before or betray its bones. (Actually, that’s a rhetorical ‘best’. In practice Wright’s work takes quite a bit of upkeep.)

The keys to a successful reimagining are 1) having something to say; 2) knowing what to carry and what to tweak to deliver that message; and 3) justifying itself against the original. Story and thematically, this work definitely does! It is kind of a light character study of pretentious ACTING, using familiar characters as chrome. It is sized quite well for its aims: it makes its points, name checks its inspirations in amusing ways, then gets out. And it has successful comedy beats, which, good. I think the 80s and 90s exhausted all our patience for the “gritty melodrama” reinterpretations of light entertainment. (Thanks Alan Moore!)

I would say this work fares pretty well in its aims, certainly against the first two criteria. The third is a more complex question. On the one hand no art ACTUALLY needs to ‘justify itself.’ It is enough that the artist wants it to exist. On the other, by explicitly invoking beloved, accomplished works, you are not just ASKING for comparison, you are practically DEMANDING it. For me, I think my lack of direct familiarity with MND ended up being a missing push needed to propel the work from Sparky to Engaging. Not for a lack of wit or pacing, just an insidious, looming ‘what resonances am I missing?’ Look, the only quote I know from the original work is “What fools these mortals be,” and I have failed to figure out a way to build that into my review. So you see what you’re working with here.

Overall, the interactive crafting of the piece was satisfying - playing with dialogue colors, text pacing and experimental UI elements. While most of it was amusing and fun, there were wobbly bits. In particular my most and least favorite flourish was a ‘crowd babbling’ implementation. The work sometimes presents a flow of conversation as text overwriting itself, complimented with a player response link ALSO overwriting itself. The INTENT is to encourage the player to interrupt an ongoing gabble of a conversation in a really nifty, innovative way. But it doesn’t quite land because this is not how reading works. We are biased to READ words put before us. Most stories implicitly assume you read everything, in the order presented. Why else would the author put them down that way? This UI choice of changing text in multiple planes confounds our ability to read it, making our engagement with it more ‘can’t follow what you’re saying’ than ‘lemme stop you there.’ Too, while the work’s use of timed text was reasonably effective for most of its runtime, towards the end it seemed to drag proceedings a bit.

So. AitW is a short, fun lark, trying some interesting things. For me, I peaked out at Sparks of Joy, and found its implementation glitches Notable to the experience. I think I was missing JUST enough context to cap it there. “What fool this reviewer be.”

Oh, wait! I DID get the quote!

Played: 9/2/26
Playtime: 15m
Artistic/Technical ratings: Sparks of Joy/Notable tech intrusiveness
Would Play After Comp?: No, experience seems complete

Artistic scale: Bouncy, Mechanical, Sparks of Joy, Engaging, Transcendent
Technical scale: Unplayable, Intrusive, Notable (Bugginess), Mostly Seamless, Seamless

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.