Ryan Veeder's Agatha Christie's the Murder on the Orient Express

by Ryan Veeder profile

2026
Fun
Inform 7

Go to the game's main page

Review

The Great Public Domain Mystery, November 22, 2026
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

Adapted from an IFCOMP26 Review

A review in two parts. Part 1, JJMcC’s Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes’ “The Accumulated Clues”.

In these annals, we have become familiar with the peerless, singular mind of my colleague, my friend, Sherlock Holmes. All manner of malfeasance and cupidity, awash in deception and mystery, all of it falling before his mental ministrations, carved away like so much dissembling gristle before his impossibly sharp scientific method. There is an unseen foe to this method, as often introduced by Lestrad as Moriarty himself: the implacable ticking of the clock. In his latest consulting endeavor, on behalf of the formidable Dame IFCOMP, this foe proved… but let us interrogate it from the beginning.

Dame IFCOMP lit on our doorstep with a deceptively simple request. Might the detecting mind of our age assist another mental major in solving a train-bound murder, under the relentless advance of a 2hr timer? Sherlock paused only to secure the fortifying presence of his well-used snuff box, donned cap and cape, and charged forward. The Game was Afoot!

Our new partner, the renowned Hercule Poirot whose sharp mind was only outstripped by his fussy culinary preferences and opinion of himself, set a furious pace, at once impressive and detailed. It was not long before clues were wrung from passenger cars, weigh points, and explorations of the journey’s Capitals. So numerous were these clues their details blurred, their simple presence spurring our investigations onward. What a delightful variation of our usual, though Sherlock may disagree, plodding approach! Compounding the novelty of constant clue-finding, what Sherlock is perpetually ill-prepared for, was the delightful wit of the thing. It seemed no location failed to be populated with our partner’s social circle, all of them both suspect and ally. And clues showering every stop! The whole thing became a wonderful, amusing scavenger hunt, with locations gated by sufficient clue counts or more traditional ciphers, locked doors or passcodes. I confess I must have tested the Consulting Detective’s patience as I could scarce restrain a near-constant laughter at our partner’s antics. Anachronisms, puffery, self-satisfaction, all of it conspired to reduce me to a tittering mess.

The allotted two hour span sped by distressingly fast, propelled by our indefatigable sleuthing progress and the bubbling wit that, but for the discipline of my companions, might have confounded my comparatively limited capabilities. The experience was Engaging and Seamless, and simply a joy to participate in, however unequal the partnership. Puzzles satisfying both in their cleverness and their crisp, contained design. A feeling of momentum that encouraged our ever-deepening investigation amidst an explosion of suspects.

And here, reader of these chronicles, I report a historical anomaly no less portentous than the Great Flood itself. Sherlock Holmes failed to close the case at the two hour mark! Not through lack of progress - 33 separate if somewhat indistinct clues had been assembled to that point - but through the sheer magnitude of the mystery. Did our patron, sly Dame IFCOMP know this? Was her mission to accomplish what none before her could, of confounding the peerless Sherlock Holmes? Such was the breathtaking pace of the mystery I gave no thought to the Walkthrough that might accelerate our work. Why cheat ourselves of the Great Game? Yet without that crutch, expire the timer did, the mystery unresolved even as multiple paths of inquiry yet lay before us.

Per our patron’s strict instructions, we had no choice but to render our verdict on this adventure, and such we did. I leave it as a postscript to this entry, along with this considered advice: if, unlike the Great Detective, your heart is moved by levity, by momentum, by puzzles abstract and specific, do not forego opportunity to accompany Poirot on his journeys. As to Sherlock, I fear this experience may only deepen his relationship with the snuff box.

A review in two parts. Part 2, JJMcC’s Dashiel Hammet’s Sam Spade’s “SPOILERS and Rotgut”

She’d entered my office in a blur of leg and lipstick. She left in swirl of stiletto and silk. “I expect your involvement ends here, Mr. Spade,” she said in a purr over steel. I let her leave without challenge. Solving someone else’s mystery, especially someone whose loafers could use some lead like H.P., is like courting a married dame. But something about this case just stuck, like gum behind a secretary’s ear. If I made a habit of listening to women like Femme IFCOMP I’d be a lot more sober and a lot less interesting.

I poured myself three fingers of coffin varnish and reviewed the case file. Something didn’t quite sit right. Was this the first case where the mystery outran the paycheck? Maybe. Yeah, I can’t change Femme IFCOMP’s 2hr assessment, but this case just refused to loosen its grip. Knocking back my best instincts with devil’s candy, I bent right back to it.

So I got back on the train, reconnected with Mr. Moustache. For a guy with a rap-me face, he could pound some pavement, I’ll give him that. Not shortchanged in the confidence department for sure. It took another 15 minutes to assemble a few more clues then accuse a suspect. Nailed it in one. Is what a clock-puncher with more confidence than imagination might say. HP seemed content with the result, but that was probably just the dessert tray talking. Me, the sweet was still too sour. Yeah, I hammered on another half hour. The puzzle and clue space had exhausted, 40-odd clues assembled, 5 mystery levers pulled. Because unpulled levers are like sparkly engenues - you don’t know who they are until you handle them. Then there was the matter of Door 50. Still out of reach.

Pride is a liability in the gumshoe game. It never got anyone anything but underestimated. Pride stopped being one of my poisons around the time I discovered whiskey. I knew where the Walkthrough was, and had already wrung it dry. Still short of 50 clues. You don’t get where I am in this business leaving Oz behind the curtain. If the Walkthrough clammed up, there was another snitch outside HP’s meaty grasp. Yeah, at 45 minutes I popped the cork on the Sourcecode.

Do I regret it? I regret a lot Dollface, but that ain’t one. I already knew the confessions were suspect. There were gonna be a lot of them and it’d be easy to get distracted. Everyone was having fun, the yucks kept coming, all that I knew. Still, cabin 50 and the levers dangled like a kid’s clacker ball and the source code exposed all of it. The answers lay in the source code, and I was just the flatfoot to extricate it. Boy, did that not disappoint. Cabin 50 showed HP had more flex to his rod than I gave him credit for. Good for him. And the shoe drop on the levers was an all timer.

Thing is, the machine kinda broke down on the way. Crucial details buried behind deceptive descriptions or magic uncued commands. In one case a lever’s presence only detectable through the source code. I’m not moaning, Fairness takes it on the chin every moment of every day. Yeah, I did expect more though. If I had one suggestion it would be to either alias SEARCH to LOOK UNDER or better cue search failure when more’s afoot. That one change woulda saved me so much shoe leather. Behind all that inadequate and missing text, it does feel like the endgame stuff got shortchanged.

Femme IFCOMP was crystal clear. None of my subsequent investigations were admissable. Yeah fine, but I don't work for her no more. Did a 4 hour limit change anything? Not for me. There’s a BONUS point for sure in the crazy endings, somehow popping even against the white-knuckle red-faced initial investigation. There’s a pretty big penalty point there too. I’m not so sure any of that late stuff is even possible without my brand of tenacity. Yeah, I’m not the sharpest gumshoe out there. Got a mind for speak’n’spell and a face for radio. What I sometimes have, when it seems worth it, is just enough perversity and gumption to plod my way through, narrative be damned. This time, the effort was worth it. Now am-scray. My ticket’s punched for the Bottle-Bottom Express.

Played: 9/4/26
Playtime: first accuse at 2:15; 5 levers, 46 clues, opened source code at 2:45, finished at 3:45
Artistic/Technical ratings: Engaging/mostly seamless
Would Play After Comp?: Kinda already did.

Artistic scale: Bouncy, Mechanical, Sparks of Joy, Engaging, Transcendent
Technical scale: Unplayable, Intrusive, Notable (Bugginess), Mostly Seamless, Seamless

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.