Adapted from an IFCOMP26 Review
I’ve been to exactly one High School Reunion in my life. It was my 5th. What a weird thing that was. A collection of friends, enemies and acquaintances who were nowhere near fully formed people when they knew each other. Reconnecting post-college where SO much independent self-actualization had occurred. They all LOOK like people you should know, but whatever connective tissue bound you at the time was long since replaced with sturdier, long-term stock. Leaving vestigial knee-jerks of relationships largely tangential to new inner lives.
In a weird resonance, it has now been four years since I was introduced to Texture as an IF platform. At my first introduction, I was immediately smitten, like an adolescent first love. Its potential and novelty initially blinded me to its less admirable qualities. Now, four years on, with SO much IF growth behind me, I have to squint to remember that thrill. I mean, much like first loves, the memory is still accessible, but it is very much a snapshot of its time, a snapshot of ME at that time.
Also like a first love, there was an inevitable thrill to seeing it again (seems like its been a few years! Has its use waned? I presume there is still an avid community out there somewhere). The things I loved about her, ah, it came rushing back - the unique thought connection mechanic, the potential in its drag and drop subtext, the balloon flourishes that could offer refinements and complexity.
As this game played out for me, also inevitably, the seeds of our breakup came back too. The dynamic font size changes. The paragraphs appearing mid-page requiring excavation to find the new text. The all-too-often squandered potential. Towards the end of my relationship with the platform, I remained a champion of its possibilities, but could identify vanishingly few works that fully exploited it. I found even fewer that successfully mitigated its shortcomings.
I want good things for my exes, I really do. Even you, Jess*. It gives me no joy to see Texture not having moved forward, stuck in High School as it were, still bound in the dramas that beset her when we were less mature. This work suffers all the downsides: dancing text sizing, new text hide-and-seek. It doesn’t exploit the thought-connection mechanic in a satisfying way, something the setting could easily enable. Its drag-balloons are simple word repetition, no additional nuance. HSR even makes it a bit clumsier to use: rather than immediately advancing when the drag and drop is effected, it instead unveils a second arrow icon to move forward. Forfeiting even efficiency of UI.
I hope you are acknowledging the tortured lengths I went to to connect the platform and the work’s conceit. If we’re not already too extended, let’s reach a little further to include the work’s execution as well. In a few key ways, the work itself reflects a lack of.. I really don’t have a better word.. maturity. When examining the 10th reunion banner, the protag observes, “you know that because you’re an old man now”. At the ripe old age of 28??? That is some “Hope I Die Before I Get Old” stuff, the anthem of the decidedly NOT-OLD.
Then there is the matter of your limited options: (Spoiler - click to show)leave, enter or steal a classmates identity. By beating him up! Who is this protag? Were we really like this in High School? It doesn’t help that there is a seeming bug with the ENTER option, where the game just restarts, effectively refusing to allow you participate WITHOUT committing assault.
All of this reflection might seem to suggest the piece is self-serious and tone deaf. That’s a critique more appropriate to this review than the work itself. There is a read of the banner as wry humor. There are some paths that abruptly end in comedic death scenes. The assault itself is more slapstick than gritty. Its just.. instant, comedic deaths undermine our engagement here. We are laughing AT the protag, not with them. This disconnect persists as the narrative attempts to shift to more emotional realism. How invested can we be in a character that (Spoiler - click to show)MEDITATES HIMSELF TO DEATH? The tonal whipsaw here is missing a unifying theme or connective tissue to that turns this dissonance into complexity. Like we needed college to crystallize our adolescent identity search.
I am afraid to say I found this work and my reunion with Texture, much like my 5th reunion, more evocative of MY growth than an opportunity to improve on the past. Between its inexplicably Loony Tunes protagonist, its stuck-in-the-past storyline and its submission to Texture’s most Intrusive artifacts, I never breached a Mechanical experience here.
Maybe I’ll be more mature about it at our 10th reunion? Y’know, when I’m AN OLD MAN.
Played: 9/2/26
Playtime: 10m: 2 deaths, one abrupt restart, true ending
Artistic/Technical ratings: Mechanical/Notably intrusive
Would Play After Comp?: No, experience seems complete
*Jess: name changed, as no one deserves a legacy as my punchline. Not even… Jess
Artistic scale: Bouncy, Mechanical, Sparks of Joy, Engaging, Transcendent
Technical scale: Unplayable, Intrusive, Notable (Bugginess), Mostly Seamless, Seamless