Bronze

This might be the longest parser game I've played so far, although that does not say much since I can still count the number of parser games I've played on both my hands.

I know the author has stated that they intentionally wanted to convey a vast castle that is empty, and I know the convenience command GO TO was implemented to help not make that annoying, but the problem was not going to known locations – the problem was when I didn't know where to go next, and had to blindly search for clues. Then suddenly having nearly 40 rooms, mostly with just flavour text, to explore became a chore.

Maybe all this flailing about the big empty map is just my lack of problem-solving skills. It is possible there were obvious hints about where exactly to go, only I missed them. But that sort of makes me wonder whether this is really a good beginners' game, or if it ought to be more of an intermediate players' game? (Similar concerns with a large number of items that do not fulfill a function. Beginner me felt the need to carry them with me in case they become important, because I don't trust my memory with all the items I've seen lying around. But that gave me a huge inventory to try to sift through when I vaguely remembered some item I had seen.)

That said, the castle does really convey its castliness very well and it was a joy to map all parts of it, even before I had access to a light source and I could only label many of the rooms "darkness", "darkness", "dry sifting", "dripping", "darkness", "open space", "darkness"! To see a spoilerful map from when I had managed to lift the darkness, go to https://i.xkqr.org/bronze_map_spoilers.png

The narrative itself was interesting and very well presented. I have no idea how the Beauty and the Beast is traditionally told, but I don't mind making Bronze my canonical version of it going forward. It is rich, personal, and makes sense.

In total, I'm trying to figure out whether I will give this game three or four stars. Part of me think I'm inclined to give it four stars only because I'm worried of deviating too much from the crowd consensus. I think three stars is my honest rating.