Go to the game's main page

Review

IF by Gibli, November 22, 2026
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

Adapted from an IFCOMP26 Review

So, about that saying “when you only have a hammer, everything looks like a nail.” Regarding Japanese culture, “when you don’t consume much anime, everything looks like Spirited Away.” That’s a problem, though, right? If your only touch point for black and white movies is Citizen Kane, what do you even do with Plan 9 from Outer Space? What I am scrabbling at is that this Japanese folktale-reminiscent IF reminds me of that highly regarded Japanese folktale-inspired movie because my cultural currency is IMPOVERISHED and it's all I’ve got.

It’s all super unfair anyway, right? By invoking Spirited Away I have probably burdened SaI with expectations, while simultaneously casting doubt in you the reader that I have any kind of proportionality here. All fair takes, for what I’ve given you so far. And yet, that is STILL the hook that best anchors my response to this choice-select work.

This is a relatively short work of mythical fantasy. It is permeated with melancholy atmosphere, casual acceptance of the truly bizarre, wry humor, and gameplay reflective of its dreamy unreality. Not unlike the comparative work I am desperately downplaying. Our protagonist is rescued from a river plunge, then given a quest to magically create books from artifacts. This as a way to satisfy the varying needs of an isolated community to whom your presence is no more noteworthy to them than theirs is to you. Uncanny acceptance is the overall vibe of the piece.

This is a Twinesformer-y choice-select work, taking gameplay cues from parser paradigms: navigate, collect, attach, give. All the inventory manipulation work is done through hyperlinks, and this has a flattening effect on the gameplay. Meaning that rather than DEDUCING what needs done (making leaps of logic for example to figure out which artifacts can satisfy which characters), instead the link architecture does the work for you. It makes it less of a logic puzzle than a lawn-mowery one. This artifact is not unique to SaI by the way. In many cases, this is an indictment against a work - that its challenges are simply clicking until something happens, requiring little brainpower from the player.

Honestly, this is kind of a fair criticism of this work. I think maybe that misses the point of it a bit though. Here, that compromise presents less as railroading the player and more as a reflection of this dreamy, off-kilter world we have become immersed in. Take for example narrative introductions. They are variations of

NPC: "Ah, my problems would be resolved if you could X for me. Will you?"
YOU: "Of course."

All in non-interactive dialogue! The game is answering on your behalf. On the one hand it has to - there isn’t really a game otherwise. On the other, this narrative flow folds the protagonist into the mythical, dreamy reality at play here. Yes, you’re talking to a monkey or whatever, and yes you presumably have to finish your taxes back home or somesuch, but OF COURSE nothing would be more urgent than to explore this dreamworld for the monkey thing. In another setting, this kind of railroading might feel constraining or single pathing. Here it just becomes the folktale-ish norm, which the player is just as beholden to as the NPCs. The novelty comes from the narrative, not the gameplay.

Its fetch-quest/object manipulation gameplay becomes more of the same. Yes, you need to do some exploring work to uncover objects of interest. Yes, some of it is straightforward (though some is pleasant if mild puzzle-solving). All of it just flows from the setup, simultaneously unpredictably quirky yet still smoothly inevitable. More than any detail specifics or character resonances, it is this inevitable, uncanny acceptance vibe that most reminds me of Spirited Away.

For me, the ultimately unchallenging gameplay resonated with the casual bizarrity of the setting and it all settled into a cozy, intriguing experience. It helps that it feels perfectly sized for its aims. The cast is wildly varied in preoccupations and character, the tasks diverse in detail if not execution. And all of it warmly witty. I grabbed this line, but the entire work is stuffed with quips like this: “Every day I measure the size of my ego. Soon it will only be visible with specialized laboratory equipment.”

As I wrestle with my response to this piece, the mechanical side is not in question. It presents a tabbed UI that operated Seamlessly for me: never confusing itself or losing context. This is a quiet achievement, as I can’t think of a TWINE piece that so successfully pushed its quasi-parser UI into the background. In this case NOT calling attention to itself is the highest praise. Artistically I found myself teetering between Sparks of Joy and Engagement. The prose cast a spell, married itself to the gameplay quite well. But I cannot say I did not once or twice question the limited, hand-held initiative I was allowed. I think if just ONE MORE STEP had been taken graphically it could have tipped the balance for me. The layout is attractive - a side banner with evocative calligraphy buttressing the text space; pleasantly moody music. But then default cold Sugarcube formatting for the text body? This is a piece that cried out for custom colors and font, evoking the dreamy, pre-Gutenberg power-of-books vibe.

So, in the spirit of things, I give you a choice that isn’t really one. My score is EITHER Sparks of Joy with a bonus point for wonderfully mythical storytelling, or Engaging with a penalty point for gameplay and presentation that felt ever so slightly shortchanged. Your “choice”.

Played: 9/5/26
Playtime: 50m, 3 endings, 6/8 ninjas
Artistic/Technical ratings: Engaging OR Sparks of Joy/seamless; Penalty OR Bonus point as above
Would Play After Comp?: No, experience seems complete

Artistic scale: Bouncy, Mechanical, Sparks of Joy, Engaging, Transcendent
Technical scale: Unplayable, Intrusive, Notable (Bugginess), Mostly Seamless, Seamless

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.