Go to the game's main page

Review

Atmospheric and untested, November 21, 2026
by Mr. Patient (Saint Paul, Minn.)

Why Don't You Dance is an adaptation of a short story by Raymond Carver, about a man selling his possessions to a young couple. The perspective in the game switches between the man and the young woman. I'm not familiar with the original story, but the writing here is suitably atmospheric and melancholy, and drew me in. It's a story I wanted to explore.

Unfortunately, it's impossible to engage with it because of the implementation. It's never clear what you are meant to be doing in any particular scene, and there's a long list of mostly undescribed objects that invites (fruitless) inspection. And then the scenes draw to a close automatically with nothing accomplished.

Sometimes objects are completely inaccessible via their printed names.

In the record box are a record with a blue label, a record with a photograph on the sleeve, and a record with no sleeve.

>get record with a blue label
You can't see any such thing.

Even though perspective changes, responses don't.

>x me
A girl in a sundress, older now by some weeks, or it only looks that way, holding a drink she is not drinking.

>dance
There is no one to dance with, and no music, and you are not the kind of man who dances alone in his own yard.

I glanced at the source code and found the testing commands that spelled out what the author was expecting me to do: things like (Spoiler - click to show)PEEL FIRST GLASS, WANT FIFTEEN DOLLARS FOR TV, QUIT TRYING. No player will ever happen upon these commands by themselves. No testers are listed.

I think Why Don't You Dance is worth making, and I would encourage the author to give this another go. Step one will be to decide what the game is trying to accomplish. Are you simply re-enacting the short story? Allowing exploration of the space, and the characters' motives, beyond what's on the page? Something else? And step two will be to rustle up some testers and let them have at it.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.