Go to the game's main page

Review

1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
A bunch of infodumps and bad puzzles, November 20, 2026
by rabbitking (Moscow)

I'm baffled by the discrepancy between this game's reputation as one of the pinnacles of the genre, and it's actual quality.

The game starts with an infodump, lives by the infodump and dies for an infodump.
I consider Infodumps one of the most lazy, unimaginative, uninteractive and overall boring ways to tell a story. Maybe some stories just can't do without them. But when infodump is the only narrative device the game knows, a question rises. Couldn’t the story have been told in a more elegant way? And if not, is it even worth telling, then?

Major narrative set pieces and gameplay elements turn out to be nothingburgers.

The setting, Benthamian-Foucauldian asylum, looks promising at the start. But in fact is reduced to a small six-chamber country hospital, of which only one chamber is actually relevant to the story. Then, what is the point of having this whole panopticon thing in the first place?

The Triage presents itself as a major gameplay mechanics and follows you wherever you go, but in practice is only needed to solve one single puzzle.

The puzzles overall are rudimentary and badly articulated, and, as the other reviewer pointed out, «feel like they are there only because "IF must have puzzles"».

Moreover, even 2013/4 rerelease still has major bugs. Items are disappearing. I've been able to unplug the radio enhancement module without even wanting to do so, and while being in some other part of the map.

Between infodumps, rudimentary puzzles, underutilised set pieces, undercooked gameplay mechanics, red herrings and bugs, what is even there to actually like?

Makes me wonder if people who praise this game have actually played it since it's initial release in 2003.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Comments on this review

Previous | << 1 >> | Next

Rui Pires, November 20, 2026 - Reply
"Makes me wonder if people who praise this game have actually played it since it's initial release in 2003."

<raises hand>

It's ok for you to want different things from IF. You seem to prefer a different kind of IF. For someone who enjoys a more narrative experience and doesn't feel that IF must be a collection of rooms and puzzles, this game offers quite the experience.

This is hardly worth mentioning, because it boils down to "you and I have different tastes", and in such cases it's usually best to say nothing, so I normally wouldn't have, but you _did_ involve other people with that last comment, so, I figured I'd reply.

Also, honestly, praise from 2003 isn't inherently wrong and doesn't invalidate modern criticism. In those 23 years, a lot has changed (and a lot hasn't) in players expectations. I'm not saying you should consider what this game brought at the time it was released, I'm definitely not saying that. But I am saying that some people do, because they were there at the time. And they remember what it was like. And on replaying they can still see what made a splash back then.

Personally, it was one of the more vivid pieces of IF I had played, and it make a deep mark on me. Again; we simply have different tastes. Again; I normally wouldn't be commenting just to say that. Again; you did kind of ask for a reply with your last paragraph.
Previous | << 1 >> | Next