This game (is it a game?) is set up as a google form in which you respond to somebody who has given your game a 1-star rating on IFDB. Play proceeds as you click options, about half of which are "I hope you die." At several points, you can also leave written comments on the form that are viewable in the public google sheet which collects form responses.
I appreciated the meta nature of this game, and generally speaking I enjoy this kind of thing. But my initial rating--based on a playthrough where I declined to click "I hope you die" no matter how many times it appeared--was in fact 1 star.
I upped my rating to two after going through one more time and reaching the (Spoiler - click to show)surreal 404 ending which as far as I can tell is the only thing in this game that is likely to appeal to me.
But, as the game puts it: "Why did you do this?"
1) The game's narrative voice quickly eroded my enjoyment. The narrator is instantly and excessively aggressive and in-your-face about everything. I suspect this is the point and while guess some people might find that funny it just makes me want to go do something else instead.
2) I dunno, insert some clever message here about the nature of reviewing and subjectivity.
For what is in the author's own words "a joke game" made with "reddit copypasta" and some python, it's fine and you can probably click through it a few times in about five minutes and be done. But don't expect it to be life-changing or anything. (I'm pretty sure I spent twice as long writing this review as I did on the game.)
major spoiler: (Spoiler - click to show)This game cannot be completed without also playing Enkii in the same browser at the same time. This review will cover both games, as the author requests judges to rate them as a single entity.
Who doesn't want to visit Scotland? In "Under Loch," you are an American tourist called Karen experiencing the splendor and beauty of the Scottish countrysi—oh no, wait. Wait. You've been tricked by overenthusiastic travel blogs into visiting an artificial pond in a humdrum park. Still, the sandwich is nice.
At first, it might seem this is literally just a "sit and eat your sandwich" game. You can click the "take a bite" link as many times as you wish, and nothing in particular will happen. Eventually, you will get a suggestion to come back later.
The rest of this review is all major spoilers. If you haven't already revealed that first spoiler and want to figure out the mystery of what lies under the loch for yourself, stop reading here!
(Spoiler - click to show)Once you've gotten tired of eating bits of sandwich, it's time to open up Enkii. In Enkii, you play a Scottish university student called Susan who's specialising in biology, and who is working in the room underneath the loch to study the fish, who are quite miserable and poorly. The only problem? You've somehow locked yourself inside, and don't have the key. All you do have is a walkie-talkie, which is miraculously charged and in working order. If only someone on the other side will answer it! Just like "Under Loch," you can click that "cry for help" link all you want and nothing will happen if you haven't opened the other game yet. (I actually played Enkii first, and ended up downloading the file to see what I was supposed to do.) From there on, it's a matter of switching between tabs in your browser to advance the story, as Susan and Karen make polite but awkward conversation while Karen tries to find the key and Susan tries to wait patiently until she can escape. The story is linear, other than the tab-switching. Although both pieces of the game sometimes offer you different dialogue options, none make a difference to how the story progresses.(all right, that's the mechanical spoiler. The rest of this is story-relevant spoiler!)
(Spoiler - click to show) As Susan looks for the key and the two talk, we start to get little hints that there's a tiny bit more going on than just "get Susan out of the fish observation room." A reference from Karen to the pandemic makes Susan think about Hong Kong, and Karen's comment that she's rereading 1984 make Susan laugh and comment that it's "the perfect time" to be rereading that. Eventually, Susan fishes the key out of the loch and unlocks the door, which has started to vibrate. But wait! There's nobody there! Was it all a prank? In fact, what we're dealing with is a time slip situation. Karen meets Susan, all grown up and older than her, and holding a walkie talkie.While the way the game is set up was interesting from a technical standpoint, and I did enjoy the concept and story bits, in the end I wanted a little more to do with this one.
Quackpond is an early-2000s website forum/community simulator that's about playing with cute ducks. But just like a smoothly swimming duck, there's more going on beneath the surface of the pond. (Spoiler - click to show)(the story involves an abusive relationship playing out through forum posts)
The aesthetic is 100% what it should be, down to the table-based layout (which makes me cry as a person who does web design sometimes, but is very appropriate for this game). And the story is well-handled and engaging.
Where the game didn't quite work for me is its mechanics. Every time you navigate to the "play with your duck" link, new forum posts or responses appear. You can respond to these, but it doesn't affect anything beyond the post in response to yours. After a couple of days, the story proper starts and after a few more it ends—(Spoiler - click to show)and so does the game. You will abruptly see a mocked-up "permanently closed" error after navigating to your duck after the final forum post appears.
Overall, playing this left me with the feeling that I was on the outside of things, watching total strangers interact and ignore me. Considering both the aesthetic and the story, this is probably by design! But as a game, it left me wanting just a little bit more.
I should acknowledge that I played this as part of IFComp, so I was expecting a bit more trickery behind the scenes. (e.g. the "rules" page warns you not to try hacking or accessing secret things and I was like "Aha! That Is A Clue!" but it was not.) Outside of that context, I think I would have had a different set of expectations and a different gameplay experience.
It's essentially an IFComp tradition at this point.
At least this year's has Bigfoot.
In Pegasus Crew you play the captain of a starship on a mission to recover her stolen memories from a pleasure moon.
Despite the space opera setting, this game is all about found family, and nearly all of your choices affect your relationships with your two crew members. That's not a complaint—in fact, quite the opposite! Space opera setting with found family themes is one of my favourite combinations.
The writing is smooth and polished, and each of the three main characters are unique and interesting. All that, an interesting setting, and an engaging backstory make this an enjoyable read, and it's well worth checking out on the strength of that alone.
Where the game falls down a little (but not much!) is on the Twine side of things.
In most cases, play proceeds in a straight line. You make a choice and move to a new scene, and those other choices go away. A few scenes, though, were optional, giving you another chance to talk to or interact with your crew or the people on the pleasure moon.
These scenes, unfortunately, would send you back to the previous scene when you were finished, with no changes or acknowledgment of what you had just done. You could even replay the optional side scenes word-for-word the same, which broke the immersion of the writing in a big way.
I also was not sure if the choices affecting your relationships were just for show, since there is no visible way to track character relationships that I could see, and I could not really tell if having better relationships with the characters did anything in particular. However, downloading the Twine file and looking through it, I see that these variables do play a key role in the end-game.
All in all, very minor flaws for what is otherwise a lovely and memorable experience!
Now that Ectocomp is over, I made some tweaks and updates based on comments here:
* Clearer room descriptions, including a full list of available exits in each room
* Made the opening more forgiving, with multiple ways to (Spoiler - click to show)say “trick or treat”
* Reduced the number of (Spoiler - click to show)actions you have to take in the first iteration of the time loop
* Slightly increased the number of (Spoiler - click to show)actions you can take in subsequent iterations
* Added an in-game hint system
* Fixed a few small oversights
This brings the total time I’ve spent on the game up to about 5 hours.