Reviews by Mike Russo

View this member's profile

Show ratings only | both reviews and ratings
View this member's reviews by tag: IF Comp 2002 IF Comp 2003 IF Comp 2004 IF Comp 2005 IF Comp 2020 IF Comp 2021 IF Comp 2022 IF Comp 2023 IF Comp 2024 IF Comp 2025 IF Comp 2026 ParserComp 2021 ParserComp 2022 ParserComp 2023 ParserComp 2024 ParserComp 2025 ParserComp 2026 Review-a-Thon 2024 Review-a-Thon 2025 Review-a-Thon 2026 Spring Thing 2021 Spring Thing 2022 Spring Thing 2023 Spring Thing 2024 Spring Thing 2026
Previous | 61–70 of 873 | Next | Show All


The Golden King, by Damon L. Wakes
All that glitters... is awesome, October 28, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

In most areas of IF, I feel very well-qualified to offer my opinions: I’ve played and reviewed hundreds and hundreds of games by this point, and I’ve written both a puzzlefest and a narrative-focused game, which are experiences that made me spend a bunch of time thinking about issues of craft that are pretty broadly applicable. I’m also a middle-aged white guy, which helps with the whole not-overly-questioning-whether-the-world-needs-to-hear-my-judgments thing. But there are definitely categories where I don’t have the lived experience or theoretical tools to feel like I have much of interest to share. And short, sharp aesthetic experiences that rely as much on graphics and audio as on writing and design are pretty much my kryptonite – so guess what The Golden King is?

At least this is a short game – I took about 7 minutes to play through it twice – so I was able to turn on the audio, which is good since there are no subtitles and you really need to hear the narration to get what’s going on. The game’s a retelling of the King Midas myth, in graphical form: you control a chess king and use the arrow keys to move it through a small checkerboard area, with the voice-over giving you the backstory and commenting on the action. There’s nothing to do but to go down the hallway and move through the three rooms one offer – one represents the palace grounds, filled with trees, another has other chessmen standing in for your courtiers and soldiers, and in the center is a high table piled with food, behind which stand a queen and pawn (your family). As you move, you turn everything next to you into gold, including the ground, the walls, and of course, the people and things you encounter.

The key twist here is that this is an unrepentant Midas: rather than falling into despair at seeing his loved ones turned to brilliant but dead gold, and unable to eat food that’s transformed into metal in his throat, he actually thinks this is great, somehow managing to sustain himself from pure satiated greed, and his powers wind up expanding until they create an ending very different from the canonical myth. The story is quite abbreviated, and more focused on O Henry wit than pathos, but it’s still well done, I think, and obviously has some contemporary resonance even if there’s not a lot to be done with it. The language is good, adopting an elevated register appropriate to the myth without being portentous. Since there are no subtitles possibly I’m slightly misquoting, but here’s a 90% accurate transcription of what you hear when you blunder into the forest area:

The king delighted at seeing the plants and animals in the palace grounds transformed into trinkets more lovely than any his craftsmen could cast.

The graphic and audio touches also help sell the arc – especially the sound, which sees different tracks of ambient noise drop off as you progress, replaced by an austere and dreadful wind.

It all seems to work well, but again, I feel I’m on thin ice as a critic; Golden King is more about mood and vibes than anything else, and the audiovisual elements are load-bearing ones, so I wish I could say something more useful than just “they seem good”. But they do seem good, albeit in service to a narrative that’s not especially robust or interesting in itself; if you turned just the words into a Twine or Inform game, I think most players would shrug at its simplicity and linearity (possibly there’s an alternate path through the game if you simply stay put and refuse to turn everything and everyone around you to gold, but having worked myself into a lather about the way Everyone’s Invited tried my patience, I didn’t have the self-control to give this a real go). That’s not a critique of Golden King as much as it is of my own limitations, though – I may not be champing at the bit to be the world’s second-most-prolific reviewer of highly-curated aesthetically bold experiences that engage all the senses, but I can’t object to seeing one or two high-quality examples of the form pop up in the Comp.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Everyone's Invited, by Will Beneteau
A long excruciating party, October 28, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

The eternal debate about whether fiction needs sympathetic characters is, I think, mostly wrong-headed – like, if you frame to the question in those terms, it’s easy to get muddled. It’s obvious that insisting that a story’s protagonist have a big “look, here’s the good guy” sign flashing over them is unnecessary and kin of callow, but at the same time it’s also obvious that anyone who’s read (or watched movies, or played games…) widely will have walked away from a book (or movie or game) annoying at what a waste of time and/or nihilistic mess it was, with that impression based largely on the characters all being utter assholes.

What squares the circle is realizing that what’s at issue here isn’t sympathy as such, it’s whether anybody is a good hang. I 100% do not sympathize with its nameless narrator, but Notes from Underground works because for all that he’s an irredeemable misanthrope, he’s got a way with words, he’s got something to say, there’s an odd anti-charisma in his self-abnegating antics. This isn’t a theory to endorse in real life, of course – sociopathic narcissists who are intermittently amusing so long as they’re not victimizing you are not good people to hang around with! – but it hasn’t steered me wrong in fiction (with the important caveat that the author can’t have been too charmed by the terrible person they’ve created).

The narrator of Everyone’s Invited is maaaybe sympathetic, if you squint: he (I’m not sure if gender is ever definitively nailed down, but let’s be real, this is a dude) may be pathologically unpleasant about pushing others away and have developed an incredibly off-putting superiority complex to cover for his antisocial tendencies, but when he goes to a party and gets overwhelmed by all the strangers he races for the bathroom, because at least he can be along in there for a little while, and buddy, I get it. There are also indications that he wasn’t always this way, and a bad experience with a close friend has led him to becoming this closed-off. So even though his head isn’t a fun place to be, it’s pretty clear that the author isn’t endorsing his awful opinions, and we’re meant to stand apart from them and, perhaps, pity him as he’s tested in a cosmic-horror phantasmagoria that’s also, as I mentioned, a totally normal apartment party.

So that’s all fine, but there are still two problems. The first is that, as adverted to above, he’s just a total drip. He’s constantly judging people for being vapid, but just does so silently in his head, with no withering bon mots uttered or even thought. He just goes along with whatever he’s prodded to do, protesting on the inside but drifting along in practice. He’s reticent to share his backstory, and speaks in direct language that’s largely devoid of insight or flair. And the second problem is that, for all that he loudly insists that he wants to be alone, you just can’t get rid of this motherfucker.

See, Everyone’s Invited is written in a custom, visual-novel style system that illustrates its story with pulsating, EGA-palette graphics, which helps provide some apt vibes for the low-fi horror here on offer. But it also takes a page from VNs in requiring you to page through short passages of text one at a time, each of which unscrolls in glacier-slow timed text that can’t be skipped through or even, contra the false promise of the about text, sped up (allegedly the C key will manage this feat, but couldn’t figure it out and let me tell you I was highly motivated to try).

It makes for a maddening experience the first time out, but what’s worse is that the game appears to be structured as a loop. After playing through the intro and reaching the surreal party full of strangers, I was given a choice of three places to go, and after picking one, a medium-length vignette played out, I reached an equivocal climax – and then found myself back at the front door of the party, forced to go through the lengthy and molasses-paced dialogue before I once more hit that three-way choice. And then it happened again, and again. From looking at the spoiler file that comes with the game, there might have been a fourth branch waiting for me, since one of the three core choices has two variants, at which point the experience might have blessedly come to a halt – but after spending 40 minutes on a game alleged to be 15 minutes or less, with half of that time hammering on the keyboard desperately wishing I could skip stuff I’d already seen and/or praying for death, I couldn’t muster the strength of character to go any further.

Again, I don’t mind a game with a protagonist who’s an awful person. But the combination of a design that’s contemptuous of the player’s time, with a main character who doesn’t say much compelling, either in substance or in style, when he’s got the floor, is deadly. Holden Caulfield, let me never complain of you again; Bartleby the Scrivener, your monomaniacal noncompliance is divine inspiration by comparison; Iris Murdoch, I apologize for everything bad I ever said about the Black Prince; Becky Sharp, I always thought you were amazing, please just take me away from this place!

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Black Thumb, by Bridget Hoang
Seeds of change, October 27, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

The identity of Black Thumb’s protagonist is never made that big a deal: this is a magic-realist game about the lengths you’ll go to to make sure your new succulent can get enough sun. There are no other characters to talk to, no moments of self-actualization or revelation, just a short series of object-interaction puzzles that escalate in delightful ways. And yet part of what I like about it is that it’s unmistakably teenaged. Take the game’s single full location: a messy room short on conventional decorations or well-appointed furniture, but full of the main character’s obsessions: half-completed knitting projects, piles of sketches, and plants. Here’s the description of the bed:

Your bed is pushed up against two walls. You like to sleep pressed up against that corner sometimes. The blankets — for there are many — for you are never warm enough — somehow managed to twist themselves up into tight spirals while you were asleep.

In just a few lines of lazily discursive text, and with just a few implemented objects, the game captures a very specific phase of life, when you’re brimming over with energy and relatively unburdened by responsibilities, free to jump into anything with single-minded focus and a lack of concern for proprieties. Like, when I examined the desk and was told it was super dusty, I of course tried to CLEAN DESK, only to face reproof:

It’s covered in dust. Even if you were to clean it off, it would just come back eventually.

Man, sometimes it feels like half my life these days is neglecting to make progress on the stuff I notionally care about because I’ve got to clean stuff that’s just going to get dirty again eventually. So I enjoyed the chance to leave that way of being behind, at least for a little while, and that early-established vibe helped me stay in sync with the wilder directions the game goes. See, what starts as a straightforward exercise in following the instructions on your new cactus’s care-card – get them out of the box, place them on a windowsill where there’s plenty of light – quickly shifts gears. The sun just isn’t sufficiently bright by your room, and the care-card encourages you to try an impossible action to remedy the situation. It doesn’t quite work, but you’ve got tools on hand that can fix that…

Games that require you to type something physically impossible to progress run a big risk, because while the payoff of seeing your out-of-left-field idea work is potentially huge, in practice it can be very tough to get the player to take that leap. There’s clueing both direct and indirect to help with this – beyond the care-card, the few interactive objects serve to prod you in the right direction – but it’s the pervasive mood of whimsy and potential set by the more quotidian elements of Black Thumb’s intro that helped make this moment land for me, in both puzzle-design and thematic terms. There are a few small infelicities of the kind that bedevil many authors making their Comp debuts – trying to TOUCH stuff gives you customized text as well as the default “you feel nothing unexpected” response, the special one-time thing that happens when you TAKE GLOVE fires on subsequent attempts too, and the logic of making a clay jar fireproof by stuffing it with paper eludes me. But who cares when the author is offering something so clever, lyrical, self-possessed, and absolutely committed to its vision?

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

WITHOUT corporation, by MAXFOG (from Without corp.)
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
In Limbo, October 27, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

It’s not actually a complaint to say that I don’t feel like I can remember a time when I wasn’t playing WITHOUT Corporation. It was the eighth entry the Comp randomizer handed to me, and most of the games that came before it were pretty short, so my initial transcript is dated September 3; “without mr.txt”, is the optimistic file name. Flash forward to today and that directory has added installments up to “without mr 7.txt”, plus “without XX mr.txt”, “without XX mr 1.txt”, and “without XX mr 2.txt” as well as three or four transcripts from the play-online option that I haven’t gotten around to downloading. Just about every week since the Comp has been one, I’ve taken a run at the game, gotten myself locked into this compelling, ambitious piece of meta parser horror, only to be stymied by crashes and progression-blocking bugs. I’ve gone through the main gameplay loop twenty or thirty times, at a conservative guess; I could quote chunks of the opening text from memory; even though I’ve barely gotten past the starting blocks in terms of the main plot progression, I’ve pretty much mastered the game’s systems and even tracked down an easter egg I don’t think I’ve seen anyone else even mention (hit me up if you want to know more about “the second puzzle piece”). But finally, yesterday, staring down the calendar and demoralized from yet another set of failed attempts at the prize, I gave up and just read through some other players’ transcripts so I could see what I was missing.

This should be a recipe for frustration, and I’m not going to lie, it kind of is – I’m a big fan of House of Leaves style fourth-wall-breaking horror, and the storytelling here is so wide-ranging and audacious that I’m bummed I only got to experience it in full second-hand. But even in all my flailing I still found plenty of moments of satisfaction, and, delightfully, in some ways the game itself had anticipated that I would run into these kinds of challenges – I won’t spoil the details, but actually said anticipation was remarkably personal and uncanny. If I didn’t get the intended experience, well, I still got something very memorable out of my five and a half weeks with WITHOUT Corporation, so what more can one ask for than that?

To attempt to summarize what this game is doing is a marathon in itself – but I’ll make the attempt all the same. At the most superficial layer, it presents itself as a horror game written, as is the package overall, in ZIL, called “Climbing Up the Walls”; the title’s of course a head-nod to Radiohead, and references to that band’s engaging yet ontologically threatening music are threaded through the substance of the plot. The protagonist starts at the bottom of a muddy hole in the middle of a thunderstorm, their husband looming above in the darkness, either vulnerable or strangely threatening, before this is revealed to be a nightmare; actually he’s safe in his bed, but now his child is tugging at his sleeve to wake him, because there really is a storm, and his husband really is missing. And after putting the kid to bed and getting ready to brave the elements, he finds that the events presaged in his dream are coming to new, and terrifying life.

You don’t play the protagonist, though! You, it appears, are some kind of temporary employee, tasked by the eponymous corporation to be the ghost in Climbing Up the Walls’ machine. The game was left unfinished and buggy by the untimely demise of its author – a fictionalized extrapolation of the thankfully-still-among-the-living Max Fog – and so your job is to lurk behind the curtain and keep things running, a digital dungeon-master triggering the appropriate timers, routines, and daimons to paper over the gaps in implementation. You can move objects and people from one location to another, or entirely off-screen; speed up or cancel queued events; stage-manage the various spooky special effects; and bury your face in your hands as the idiot player does everything except the one obvious thing that will move the plot forward, again and again.

And that’s not the only layer, because you’re not alone in there: all of this is explained by another entity who’s stuck in there with you, an LLM that’s been assigned to hold your hand, but isn’t otherwise sure of its origin or purpose – which doesn’t stop it from peppering you with questions and speculation about the game, itself, and the state of the world in amongst the tutorializing. And you can zoom back two or more steps further than that even, one of which I won’t spoil, but the other of which allows you to interact with a command-line shell to access other files and programs running alongside the game.

It is a whole whole lot to take in, but the game somehow manages to provide a reasonably gentle learning curve to the player while miraculously having writing engaging enough to keep the family drama at the center from being swallowed by so many coatings of pomo excess. And while the ideas are individually familiar – trauma, betrayal, artistic frustration, LLMs making a travesty of creative work – their arrangement into this particular constellation felt novel and enticing, leaving me eager to see how it all fit together.

Which is good because this is a game that does require some stick-to-itiveness. Even leaving aside the bugs I ran into, the player needs to run through at least a couple mostly-complete playthroughs of Climbing Up the Walls to see what’s really going on, and that’s not a mechanical task: while it certainly gets easier as you deepen your understanding of your capabilities, so much is dependent on the random decisions of the PC that you need to be patient and stay on your toes. I spent many, many turns waiting for him to just pick up the ^%$#^# flashlight I’d played underfoot, and then many more turns idly looking after the frustrated LLM decided I was being too passive and disabled Z. Sometimes multiple PC turns will trigger at once, but none will accomplish anything, and since you often need to keep hammering the enter key to progress the text, it can make for remarkably slow going. I also found that despite the initially-intimidating palette of controls you’re presented with, the player doesn’t actually have very much to do on most turns, which means this really is primarily a waiting game.

Still, I’m very aware that I spent probably ten times as long in this repetitive purgatory as I was meant to, which surely must be coloring my views. As mentioned, I spent a lot of time trying to figure out what I was doing wrong, and as best I can determine, you need to do some clueless floundering to set up some tutorial messages and necessary triggers that otherwise gate progress. Because I started over a couple of times due to progress-erasing interpreter crashes, I think I was unable to convincingly reinhabit a beginner’s mindset and used my knowledge from previous runs to jump ahead, over the gates I was supposed to progress through at a more plodding pace. With new plot revelations and gameplay elements coming into play, I think the baseline experience of playing Climbing Up the Walls would have been considerably enlivened.

This isn’t a game I can really fault for being buggy, though, given its incredible ambitions (did I mention it was written in ZIL?!), and even though the recipe was incomplete, the individual ingredients were satisfying to taste. Heck, given the themes it’s juggling, the story might actually be more compelling if it was meant to be fractured and cut off midway: we don’t know what the future holds for our families, we don’t know whether AI will be threatening or pathetic, we don’t know whether we’re going to drown in a pit of our own making or somehow, miraculously, struggle out. So perhaps there’s something apt, something with an aroma of grace, to be stuck forever arriving at that moment of decision.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Alana's Dungeon, by Alana Armstrong and Clyde Falsoon
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
A grand(child's) adventure, October 27, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

When I was ten or eleven, my parents put me in a weekend enrichment program at the local college. It involved doing something other than watching cartoons on Saturday morning, so I wasn’t super psyched about that, and I remember being very irked by this problem-solving class I took because the teacher was walking us through the steps you’re supposed to take when faced with a challenge, and while I don’t quite recall what the actual example was, I have pellucid clarity on the fact that during the brainstorming phase, another kid said that we could fix the problem by turning the earth’s rotation backwards to reverse time, like Superman does in the movie, and a) that’s now how time works, GREGORY (I’m not pellucidly clear on whether the kid’s name was actually Gregory but such are the vagaries of memory), and b) even if it was, you could solve any problem that way so it was a bad idea to offer in a class about how to solve different kinds of problems.

Anyway other than that problematic experience, there was a computer lab where you could mess around with BASIC, and after I finished the suggested assignments I would write my own little text adventures. I wasn’t rolling my own parser or anything, I was and remain a mediocre-at-best coder, but my skills were sufficient to create a “DO YOU GO LEFT OR RIGHT?” prompt and then use GOTOs based on string matching to the player’s input. I say “player’s” but I really mean “my” – because of course nobody ever played these things, maybe once or twice I saved them on a floppy to bring home but I wasn’t nearly self-assured enough to browbeat my sister or friends into giving them a spin. Not that they were missing much: there were a lot of entirely-unsignaled insta-deaths, with uninspired quest plots in entirely generic fantasy settings not offering anything to those willing to put up with the punishing gameplay.

Alana’s Dungeon, then, makes me kind of jealous. It’s a simple dungeon-crawling Inform game created by a grandfather based on his eight-year-old granddaughter’s ideas and designs, and if the play experience is rather pedestrian, I can imagine that the creative process was loads of fun. Having a grown-up sufficiently interested to work with you on something like this seems like a dream come true, validating in itself but also offering a chance to bring your brainstorms to life with way more sophistication than a child’s grasp of programming can achieve. I’m hoping this is a gateway to more games from this team – imagine what this kid could accomplish with ten more years in the game!

Turning to the game itself, I enjoyed the pervasive enthusiasm: when you put on your armor, you’re told “this is a perfect fit! I feel invulnerable”, and the armor is useful because there’s a DnD style combat engine, because why not. The fact that one of the puzzles centers around having to open four different drawers on a desk in order to find a key is ingenuously charming, too. I didn’t love that winning requires releasing an orc from a cage just so you can kill him, but eight is maybe a little young to have the decolonizing-DnD talk. Similarly, there’s one unfair puzzle here, since escaping from the dungeon requires examining stairs that you’re explicitly told are no longer present, since they retracted into the ceiling after you went down them, but given the paucity of stuff to interact with it’s not that hard to figure out, and getting to the answer made me feel clever as intended.

So yeah, judged as an exercise in puzzle-creation and prose-authoring, Alana’s Dungeon is okay even if it’s no great shakes. But judged as a time machine that recaptures a little bit of what it was like to be a kid and so excited to take something out of your head and make it real? There’s not too many games out there that can even attempt to do that.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Dear Anna, by Bijan Stephen and Eden Rohatensky
Audio diaries, October 26, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

I see that there are a number of audio-focused games in this year’s Comp, so I suspect I’ll be issuing this disclaimer several more times before this thread is through: since my time playing IF is typically snatched between taking care of my kid, doing bedtime, work-breaks, chores, and so on, I usually have my computer muted while doing so – being able to sit for long stretches and quietly contemplate voice acting or a soundscape just isn’t how things work for me these days. Dear Anna bills itself as an “audio-first narrative” boasting the cool gimmick that it’s playable entirely via headphones, with various ear-taps allowing you to select between the two choices that are occasionally offered up, but these focal aspects of its design were entirely lost on me – thoughtfully, the author’s made sure the game is playable without sound, via transcripts and a more traditional click-to-continue interface. I played through and am reviewing this version, but let me emphatically flag that that’s not the experience as intended and as hopefully most players will experience it.

Right, that’s out of the way, so let’s talk about Manic Pixie Dream Girls. It’s a trope that’s non-undeservedly come in for a kicking since it was first identified in the mid-aughts – one certainly rolls one’s eyes at the gender politics of a quirky, invariably beautiful woman who sweeps into a sad-sack man’s life in order to utterly transform it, while apparently lacking much in the way of interiority of her own. Yet I sometimes feel like it sometimes the label can be applied too broadly, or it gets more of a kicking than it’s due: it really is the case that there are people who can meaningfully shift our understanding of ourselves or how we’re living our lives, and often we actually have no idea what’s going through their heads as they do so.

This is the precarious terrain Dear Anna stakes out: it takes the form of a project the lead character, Sam, pulls together in the wake of the death of his partner, the eponymous Anna. His own narration and reminiscences form the glue, but there are excerpts from her audio diary, interviews with former roommates, and other ephemera. But whether my art or by accident, this is a memorial to the impact she had on others, not to who she was as a person: almost everyone she came into contact with directly states that she helped them realize something about themselves, or crystallize a decision they’d been wrestling with, but comparatively little of Anna’s actual character comes through, even in the parts where she’s speaking on her own behalf.

As to the other characters, this is plausible enough – people like to talk about themselves, film at eleven, and the game’s dialogue is definitely written for the ear and not the eye, with lots of meandering and long, somewhat saggy sentences. But there’s also a frustrating lack of detail. Like, one of several turning points Sam cites is a time in college when he reconnected with Anna, who he’d known since he was young but drifted out of touch with after graduation. She messages him out of the blue, while he’s feeling aimless and adrift, and he decides to fly from Florida to New York to visit her:

So of course I booked a flight. I emailed her back, expressing my feelings — because I wasn’t doing too hot then, either. The world was opening up before me in ways I hadn’t considered, and it felt more and more like there was a canyon opening up inside of me. Or something.

That flight was when I started reading for real. So in a sense, I guess Anna made me a reader. Another one of her gifts.

Given that Sam eventually makes a career as a writer, this is legitimately a big deal! But we’re given very little to go on: what was the book? Why did he pick it up? How did it make him feel? Did he talk about it with Anna? Had he never previously had a chance to have a couple hours of enforced downtime to make him appreciate reading?

It’s the same with the other characters, who are good at describing changes in their lives but vague on what exactly Anna had to do with it besides being there (I still don’t think I really follow the ex-roommate who credits Anna with the inspiration to quit her job and follow her dream of opening a Russian restaurant, because they went clubbing together and made out one night – the roommate just says “she helped me realize what I’d been missing”).

If the parts where others are speaking are overly bottom-lined and conversational, the Anna segments do make for a change of pace. These bits feel writerly, and in a way that I think captures the self-seriousness of someone early in their life who wants to live the life of letters but is still doing the work needed to develop their chops. Here’s an email she writes to Sam while she’s working at a publishing house:

The work is intense. So is hanging out with these people. They seem to expend no effort and yet get things done. They’re publishing things and hosting readings and writing chapbooks; there is an industriousness here that I find compelling. But the parties, man. Everyone out of their minds on cocaine and whiskey.

Later, she says – not writes, says – that someone’s face “betrayed no human emotion”, and in another conversation she says she’s considering taking up religion because she found God “in a disused shed”, and woo boy, putting “disused” there sure takes me back to some of the more pretentious moments of my mid-20s.

But the Anna sections also feel writerly in that she’s very clearly inhabiting a pre-ordained plot arc that’s more about narrative convenience than deep fidelity to character. She starts getting sucked into the parties, abusing substances, and dropping out of the world, to predictably bad effect. Then she gets clean, finally hooks up with Sam and lives with him for a year, and mends fences with her parents, before the inevitable relapse leads to her death by overdose. We’re not given enough granularity to feel a person beneath the melodrama, so Anna ultimately doesn’t come to life here, either, though there is an understandable poignancy to witnessing her sad end and seeing how it impacts those around her.

The strength of the climax is undercut by some frankly confusing structural decisions, though – I’m not sure whether they’re an indication of the game still being a work in progress (a disclaimer it issues in a few passages when it says some audio is being rerecorded), or are working as intended, but after the story comes to its natural conclusion, you’re given the option to either proceed to the credits, or keep things moving ahead. If you choose the latter, you get a short vignette of Anna’s last days from her dealer, who was with her when she died, and then the same question repeats. This time, you get what seems to be an abbreviated Sliding-Doors style alternate take on the plot, where instead of overdosing Anna comes down with cancer immediately after a life-changing first night with Sam, and then there’s one more, also short, but this time from the point of view of a new character named Elliot. It’s an odds-and-sods miscellany that doesn’t add much to what came before – perhaps the idea is to flesh these pieces out and then interpolate them into the main section of the story, which I think could work, but in their present placement they’re just baffling.

As for the gameplay elements, given the constraints of the format they’re fairly light. There’s one backstory-establishing choice early on but other than that and the ending-related ones mentioned above, they’re largely just “would you like a one-passage digression Y/N.” That’s probably the right call given how the player is intended to experience the game, but it does mean that there’s not much in the way of interactivity to engage the player.

The elephant in the room is that it’s obvious what’s meant to engage the player – it’s the audio, and the performances! Indeed, going back to the Manic Pixie Dream Girl, when the trope works I think it’s rarely because of anything the script is doing, but because an actor is able to imbue the archetype with a sense of subjectivity, while projecting the charisma that the other characters are meant to be feeling. So let me just end this review by saying all that could well be in evidence here, sweeping aside most of my critiques (save for the structural ones) aside – I’m looking forward to checking out other reviews to see what those able to come to Dear Anna on its own terms thought.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Meet the timesheet, by Zeno Pillan (as 'Garrulus (aka Jay)')
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Horrible boss, October 26, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

I have profoundly mixed feelings about it, but we are all living in the post-postmodern age. We’re all fluent in the may tongues of genre, reared on media that’s completely unselfconscious about the way it self-consciously displays its tropes and conventions. And as polyglots, it’s no surprise that we barely blink at the most outre of mash-ups – if everything is a signifier, why shouldn’t we lawnmower through the combinations until we happen across something that works? Thus it is that in space-year 2026, in the 32nd year of the Interactive Fiction Competition, we’ve got a [spins wheel] parser adventure mixing [spins wheel] absurdist workplace satire with [spins wheel]liminal-spaces horror.

This isn’t necessarily a bad idea or even one that’s especially off the wall, mind. As anyone who’s ever suffered under a bad boss knows, a work situation sufficiently messed up to evoke black humor can also readily be abusive, and whether you respond to any particular setback by helplessly giggling or helplessly sobbing can sometimes be a coin-flip. Meet the timesheet starts out on the former side of the genre lines, as the beaten-down protagonist is forced to duck out from a holiday party they’re not especially enjoying – though at leas it’s better than work – when they remember that they haven’t finished entering their hours for the pay period, and their supervisor is on the prowl. Once you’re in the cube farm, though, the stakes go higher: if the inhuman manager catches you, you’re literally dead meat, and the maze of identical office-cubbies takes on non-Euclidean dimensions.

It’s a cute conceit, and the gameplay cleverly realizes both parts of the theme: it’s split between the game of cat-and-mouse you play to evade the monster and find the few working computers you can use to update your timesheet, and the ridiculous magical-realist challenges you need to go through to keep each computer from booting you off due to a mandatory update or wake up a recalcitrant screen-saver or what have you.

The prose keeps up that theme of duality, but here I think there’s a clear winner. Compare this fine but uninspired horror bit:

From the west, they run and jump at you. You smell their garlic-flavoured breath as they fix their glasses on their nose. <You know, it is not personal,> they start slowly, <I know sometimes bureaucracy may look like useless extra work, but it is very important in reality.> It seems to go on forever, with a pedantic voice, explaining how it is the only way to analyse how you spend working time. As if an analysis on “easily fakeable” data could ever be more relevant than results and actual work. You are finally drained, but they go on and on, explaining the same concepts again and again.

To this comedy one, which to my ear has some awkward syntax that maybe suggests the author isn’t a native speaker of English, but which is energetic and entertaining all the same:

Your eyes are swollen, tired, and your sight blurs. You feel like the protagonist of an eye drops commercial. You close your eyes, and when you open them back, instead of the lifesaving claim of a brand, you realise you have overwritten the wrong cells.

On the puzzles, my judgment is more mixed. Both pieces have their virtues: figuring out how the map is laid out is satisfying, and the stalking mechanics are well-tuned, pushing you to keep moving without being too punishing or hard to read. There’s also a clever stakes-raising moment midway through that requires you to think creatively about how to keep track of the baddie when you can’t see him. Meanwhile, the computer-hacking (in the sense of “messing around”, not “running malware scripts”) bits are surreal in a good way, serving up distinctive weirdness that requires a lot of experimentation and outside-the-box thinking to progress. Some of the leaps of logic might go a little far for my taste – a bit clearer prompting to start trying to directly mess with the contents of the screen without worrying about the interface wouldn’t have gone amiss – but there’s a solid hint function that took the edge off these concerns.

This is an area where the two sides of the game do finally come into conflict, though. The part where you sneak from cube to cube is tense and pacey, relying on simple commands and a sense of danger. The part where you type seemingly-silly stuff into the parser until you hit on the command that, against all odds, logs you into a terminal requires an open, playful mind unafraid of making mistakes, and plenty of time to work through all your wacky ideas. Having to toggle between the two modes created a lot of mental tension for me – it’s frustrating to pause your trial-and-error explorations at a computer just because you see the manager coming, leading me to frequently push my luck and rely on UNDO draining the deaths of all impact (while the distraction would still lead me to lose my train of thought and get frustrated at the impenetrability of the computer-puzzle side of things). Each piece of Meet the timesheet works fine on its own terms – more than fine, in places – but despite the inarguable fact that this is a really fun set of concepts to throw together into a blender, the author probably would have been better off picking a lane and sticking to it.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Doppelgangers, by Benjamin Knob
Talk therapy, October 26, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

Creating NPCs who can be interacted with in relatively-freeform conversation has long been one of the white whales of parser IF. That’s partially because of the importance of characters to most pieces of fiction, but also because of the beguilement of open-ended text entry. Sure, we all know that promise is a lie, but when it comes to physical manipulation of the world, most games offer a wide range of stuff you can try whenever you want, offering quite a lot of player agency and expressiveness. ASK MAN ABOUT HAT. ASK MAN ABOUT WATCH. is better than nothing, I suppose, but still very constrained, and while menu-based conversation can make NPC interaction feel less mechanical, it surrenders all the power of the parser.

Galatea proved you can make some solid progress in this area if the author is just prepared to constrain their game to one NPC, one location, and one topic, while putting in an incredible amount of work, but experiments have of course continued. And it’s unsurprising that the increased sophistication of various AI approaches has perked up the ears of many authors – sticking with Emily Short, the Versu experiments described in 50 Years of Text Games seem intriguing as heck, though they’re unfortunately inaccessible now. But of course it’s LLMs that have been getting the most attention lately, given their omnipresence. I’m not aware of every effort in this area, but I admit to being pretty jaundiced from seeing a couple examples: sure, they allow the “type anything you want!” promise of parser IF to finally be fulfilled, but even leaving aside the broader issues many folks have with LLMs, the lack of authorial control of the substance or voice of what comes out of characters’ mouths is a very big hurdle to overcome if a game aspires to be anything other than a clever toy.

Doppelgangers lays out its design goals clearly in its about text: this is a run at that white whale of creating parser dialogue with responsive, conversational NPCs. There is an optional LLM plugin, but it’s optional – most dialogue is run through chatscript, which is a non-LLM, more hand-authored AI tool, but there are occasional “persuasion checks”, and a related section where the mental-asylum-patient protagonist undergoes a Rorschach test, where a plugged-in LLM can decide whether you’ve sufficiently met the NPC’s expectations, and returns a judgment of success or failure to the machinery of the game proper (if you choose not to use an LLM, you just always fail these checks, but the about text offers reassurance that winning the game is still possible).

All things being equal, this seems to me like a promising approach – I’ve had some positive experiences with chatscript games in the past (notably Thanataphobia and Cheree), using the reasoning abilities of an LLM while keeping it far away from actually producing text leverages the strengths and avoids the weakness of the technology, and making that part optional allows those who have strong objections to any LLM use at all to still play the game (or, who, in my case, have medium-strong objections to any LLM use at all and who are just really not excited about jumping through a bunch of hoops to give a new tech company more of my personal information just to make a piece of IF go).

So I went into Doppelgangers cautiously optimistic and interested to see how this would all play out, very curious about what the back-and-forth dialogue with other characters would look like. But – in an ironic twist worthy of the cosmic horror genre Doppelgangers appears to inhabit – actually the rest of this review is only going to glancingly mention all that, and focus much more on the regular-degular practices of parser design. There’s a whole lot to the game that doesn’t have much to do with conversation, as it turns out – you’re a mental patient who’s trying to escape an asylum, beleaguered by ambiguously-sinister staff, your fellow not-especially-sensitively-portrayed patients, and a convenient bout of amnesia, and there are a bevy of locked doors, hidden items, and fetch quests standing in the way of freedom. And weaknesses in those parts of the game mean I unfortunately didn’t feel like I was able to engage with the more interesting elements of Doppelgangers as much as I would have liked.

As to the parser qua parser, things are a mixed bag. I was pleased to see that shorthands like “X DOOR” work, because often experimental “just use natural language!” games disallow abbreviations, and indeed most typical IF commands work fine. But some default responses are confusing (TAKE BLANKET results in “you cannot take that”), and despite one of the strong points of the descriptions being their use of senses other than sight, SMELLand LISTEN never did anything for me, even when location text indicates there should be. I also ran into some gnarly disambiguation/guess the verb issues, like this blackly comedic attempt to open the door to cell number 2:

>unlock 2

You cannot do that.

>unlock door

Specify a direction. You can type OPEN NORTH DOOR.

>unlock east door

The door is locked.

>unlock east door with lock pick

The door is locked.

>pick east door

The door is locked.

>pick east door with lock pick

Pick lock on which door? You can type PICK LOCK ON WEST DOOR.

>pick lock on east door

You used Lock Pick.

Do you wish to pick the lock?

Gee, what do you think, game?

The most challenging idiosyncracy of the system, though, is the way that location descriptions are dramatically simplified after you’ve seen them once. Exits are usually – but not always – redescribed, at least, but important bits of scenery, up to and including puzzle-critical NPCs, can be dropped from the description, and even manually LOOKing won’t draw your attention to them. They’re still there and can be interacted with, but in a big game with a lot of confusing map connections, it’s very easy to miss a detail and never be in a position to notice it again.

The puzzle design is also fairly obfuscated. Admittedly, many challenges appear to have LLM-dependent persuasion solutions, meaning I was forced into the fallback medium-dry-goods pathways, which might have received less testing. But I don’t think this is actually much of a factor, as a large part of the trouble I faced was not realizing that I was even meant to be talking to some NPCs. Like, as mentioned, the asylum has quite a lot of other patients suffering from a variety of Hollywood-style mental illness, and the game makes very clear that they’re largely background and you’re not meant to interact with them, unlike the doctor who engages you in conversation as soon as he sees you. One patient tries to bite you, there’s another who just looks at you blankly no matter what you do or say, and there’s a woman who just doesn’t respond to anything you say, as if she couldn’t hear you. But actually it turns out the latter two have puzzles associated with them – you’re supposed to intuit that the second one is faking his illness and threaten to expose him, while the woman is actually deaf and will make a request of you if you mess with the pile of thread she’s made by unraveling the seams of clothing (better mess with it with MOVE THREAD, though, TAKE THREAD doesn’t do anything).

Just exploring the often-sprawling asylum also throws up a lot of friction. I ran across at least one one-way passage whose geometry was so confusing I didn’t understand it after walking through and around it several times, and wandering into the wrong location will have the orderlies accuse you of attempting to sneak into the staff-only areas, with no warning to the player whatsoever. What’s worse, they’ll bundle you into a compulsory mental health evaluation, and if you fail – which you will, without an LLM – you get a bout of electroshock therapy and lose your inventory. Possibly it’s findable again, but I couldn’t discover where my stuff wound up, necessitating a restart.

So there’s a lot here besides the marquee NPC system. Like, I haven’t even mentioned the RPG-style skill system that got introduced out of the blue an hour in, once I got my hands on some lockpicks and started trying them out (leaving aside the merits of this kitchen-sink inclusion, surely a persuasion skill surely could have allowed for these checks to be resolved with some die-rolling for those not running an LLM), or the way DnD alignment also gets introduced out of the blue – engaging in a lot of totally normal IF protagonist behavior led to an announcement that I’d shifted towards being chaotic neutral, which is fair enough. I didn’t find anything that shifted me to any other alignment, mind. It makes for an experience that feels unfocused and overstuffed, with most of the additional elements adding little to the experience besides friction.

When I finally did get a chance to chat with an NPC – interrogating the aforementioned doctor about my predicament – the chatscript system did at least throw up some positive results to some naturally-phrased questions. But even with this more sophisticated engine under the hood, the edges of the simulation were readily apparent:

>say what is this place

“You are in the McPatton State Hospital. This is where the mentally afflicted are brought to be treated or just kept safe from themselves.”

>say what am I being treated for

He makes no response to this. He simply marks some words in his book.

>say who are the other patients

“No one that I have talked to.”

Is this really better than good old ASK and TELL? Even if it is, Doppelgangers is a poor proving ground for the argument, possibly because all the time building a big, full-featured, but lackluster conventional piece of puzzle IF detracted from the time the author had to devote to the notional killer feature of the game. To be clear, I think experimental IF is great, and I think Doppelgangers correctly identifies an area where trying new approaches could be useful while proposing a potentially-fruitful course of action. But maybe that one-room, one-NPC, one-topic model would have been a better place to start than what’s actually on offer.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Out by Midnight, by Arthur DiBianca
Checking boxes (and chests, and cabinets, and...), October 25, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

At this late date, is there juice left to squeeze out of the Verdeterre-like? A baker’s-dozen years one from the inaugural entry in the subgenre, we’ve seen at least five or six other runs at the collect-treasures-under-time-pressure premise, from swapping out the pirate milieu for sci-fi (Dark Star) or Egyptology (Curse of the Scarab), making the map much bigger and more complex (Sugarlawn) or smaller and more manageable (Museum Heist). I don’t think we’ve seen a limited-parser take, though, so it makes sense that Arthur DiBianca would throw his hat in the ring.

The signature elements of the author’s recent games are all on offer here: there’s a slick map to make navigation a breeze; actions are limited to movement, observation, a general “use” verb, and various meta commands; and there’s a post-game achievement system that kicks once you’ve managed a basic win and encourages you to take on trickier challenges. It makes for a slick, easy-to-get-into experience, and the setup – you’re on a scavenger hunt in a spooky manor – likewise is immediately intuitive. Since this is an optimization game, your eyes will glaze over after the fourth or fifth time you read the same bit of prose, but the writing is certainly fun enough when you first encounter it (I liked the wry note, upon checking out the dilapidated surroundings, that “it would be nice if ‘dead plant’ were an item on your scavenger list, because it would be so easy to get”), and unobtrusive enough to get out of the way thereafter.

And there’s a whole lot of thereafter, as even getting to the basic winning condition requires a good amount of iteration. There are ten categories on your to-collect list, some of which can be satisfied by more than one item you can find in the mansion, but you need to collect all ten and leave the mansion before midnight. The game starts at 7, but time goes fast since working through the house’s various challenges – picking locks, untying knots, cracking a safe the old-fashioned way – can make 15 or 20 minute elapse in a single action. It quickly becomes clear that many of these barriers have workarounds: there are keys and tools that can make a task that otherwise would eat up 17 minutes take only 2 instead. But with something like a dozen keys and 7 or 8 tools to keep track of on top of stuff you need to collect, it takes a bunch of resets to run down all the permutations and figure out whether the lubricant, the paint remover, the grabber, or the magnet on a string would help you speedrun any particular “puzzle.” The game does offer some support – that map is super helpful, and there’s a RECALL command that gives you an instant download on everything you’ve learned about a room and its contents – but you definitely will need to take a bunch of notes, and might even want to consider a spreadsheet.

Now, I’m the kind of sicko who usually gets excited when I get to fire up Excel alongside a piece of IF, and have generally gotten most of not all of the challenge-mode achievements in the author’s previous games (even the sokoban one!) but I confess that while the bones of the design here are good, I wasn’t sure I’d have the motivation to power through to even the basic ending. Partially this is because the difficulty curve is steep: blundering your way through the house sufficiently fast to check off six or seven categories isn’t too hard, but close only counts in horseshoes and hand-grenades, not haunted houses. I don’t think getting to eight or nine, much less all ten, is possible without wrapping your brain around a fairly complex web of dependencies and choices: you need tool X to get treasure Y quickly, but that means finding key Z which is all the way on the other floor; or maybe you could go for treasure A for that category instead, which requires tool B which you know you’ll already need to get treasure C, so it might wind up being faster even though you’ll need two different keys to get to A. Or actually might it be the case that all this rigmarole is more trouble than it’s worth, and grabbing treasure Y the slow, no-tool-or-key way, will wind up being faster at the end of the day than jumping through all these hoops?

But the overall challenge level wasn’t the only factor for me – there’s also a real dearth of dopamine-hits along the way. In a typical Verdeterre-like, as you go through runs, you’ll find new treasures, solve traditional IF puzzles to get them, and unlock shortcuts. There’s a regular drip of discovery with your increasing knowledge opening up new options and opportunities: progress is usually binary (did you solve the puzzle, yes or no), with the impact on your score more granular (maybe the new treasure is worth $10, but maybe it’s worth $100!) – and at the end of that process, you sit down to chart the optimal path.

Here, by contrast, you can brute-force every puzzle the first time you encounter it; you’ll see everything there is to see in a room on your initial visit. Sure, much of the middle-game does involve tracking puzzle-like interactions like seeing which tool works on which barrier, but you’ll always know what’s on the other side of the barrier in advance: there’s no narrative reward, just the knowledge of how much time you can now save. And because you need to get one of each category of item, with all of them counting exactly the same, there’s no thrill from finding something especially exciting: it’s the reverse of the usual Verdeterre approach, with progress entirely granular (+24 to the timer to get an item rather than +41) and results completely binary (do you have one of these treasures Y/N).

For all these complaints, after a good night’s sleep I did put on my big-boy pants and despite the comparatively-arid mid-game, I compiled a full set of notes, charted out a plan of attack, and implemented it sufficiently well that I also wound up with the bonus achievement for winning extra-fast. Optimization is fun, and it’s satisfying to gain mastery of the complex web Out by Midnight offers up! But I don’t think I’m feeling up to going for any other achievements; for all that this is a heavily-mechanical subgenre, part of what made the original Captain Verdeterre’s Treasure so successful was its demented energy, with the onrushing waters and the abusive rat providing some narrative adrenaline to the bean-counting and the aforementioned regular unveiling of new stuff promising that doing the work would lead to even more fun. Out by Midnight is cleanly designed (and so far as I can tell, completely bug-free), but a bit too staid to reach my personal Verdeterre-like pantheon.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.

Ass in the Woods, by Alice Vartevanian
Bottom's up, October 25, 2026
by Mike Russo (Los Angeles)
Related reviews: IF Comp 2026

There’s been a lot of discussion of adaptation in the discourse recently: what, if anything, is owed to source material? Does that answer change depending on whether the author is still around, or if they’re long since gone? Is using an existing work as a lens on your own preoccupations a bracing way of demonstrating contemporary relevance, or an act of literary plunder? Both? Neither?

There probably aren’t any Shakespeare scholars waiting to charge into the discussion of Ass in the Woods the way that Emily Wilson went after Nolan’s Odyssey, but the dynamics aren’t actually that far apart. Despite initially thinking the title was previewing an entirely different experience, this choice-based work is a riff on A Midsummer Night’s Dream, placing the player as a nameless witness to some of the comedy’s key sequences. But much like a sirens-and-cyclops-only adaptation of Homer, only the flashiest bits of the plot are kept: there’s a bit of fairy king Oberon and fairy queen Titania squabbling, a lot of Bottom hogging the spotlight after he’s been transformed into his half-donkey shape, and the sprite Puck’s mischief-making sprinkled throughout, but the lovers whose travails are the central but arguably least-novel element of the original play are nowhere in evidence.

There’s a case to be made for the all killer no filler adaptation, especially since this is a sprightly bit of IF that says its piece and gets off-stage in twenty minutes or so – I can’t say that I genuinely missed Hermia and Helena or the noxious Demetrius, not when Ass in the Woods offers set-pieces like Bottom capering about to the delight of an audience of screaming fairies (I’m not usually one who overvalues graphics in IF, but the intentionally-clumsy photoshop of a dude with a giant donkey pasted over his face dancing on stage while fairies pasted next to spotlights hover overhead is hilarious) or gives you an opportunity to tell Oberon the home truth that he’s a crappy husband.

It’s not even theme-park Shakespeare, but there’s definitely fun to be had, even if the writing is a bit more typo-laden and pedestrian than I’d prefer. Like, here’s Puck’s introductory speech:

"How did I miss you? This is why I say, “All for one prank, one prank for all”. Now, you’ll ask “Who I am? - I’m Puck” and “Why am I here? - Pranks”. Questions done and sorted. Now, we can have fun."

Hopefully it’s not too snobbish to note that that’s not exactly improving upon “I am that merry wanderer of the night…”

More broadly, though, Ass in the Wood’s orientation towards Midsummer Night’s Dream strikes me as a bit confused. I don’t think it works well as an attempt to tell an independent story with these characters – my sense is that it would be mostly incomprehensible to those not familiar with the basic setup – but the game also doesn’t seem especially interested in engaging with Shakespeare’s play, either. Like, the plot here ultimately comes down to the effect Bottom’s ego trip is having on the other members of his troupe, and where most of the choices in the earlier bits are purely expressive or cosmetic, here your decisions about what to say can either lead to a bad ending where they go their separate ways, or a happy one where he tames his prima-donna tendencies and they all hit the road together. But beyond being an uncharacteristically maudlin note given what’s come before, this changes Shakespeare’s setup quite drastically – it’s a reasonable riff on Bottom’s behavior in the play, but a big part of the joke there is that he and the rest of the actors are terrible, moonlighting tradesmen whose po-faced attempts at tragedy leave the other characters reeling with laughter.

Is playing the conflict here straight an attempt to reclaim dignity for these working-class amateurs that the original play holds up as objects of ridicule? Umm, maybe, but I’m not sure what that has to do with the abbreviated conflict between Titania and Oberon, which is likewise significantly shifted (there’s no Indian page in sight, thankfully). And Bottom still comes off like a conceited jerk, just one who in some endings can get over himself – plus the whole crew sure seem like professional actors in Ass in the Woods, which undercuts some elements of the critique, if critique it is.

All told I’m not sure that the game is an updating of Midsummer Night’s Dream or a reimagining of it or an examination of its contradictions or oversights: it just feels like a bunch of funny stuff that uses some of the same characters and some of the same plot bits for its jokes without worrying too much about what it’s saying about what’s come before. And you know, maybe that’s fine – not every adaptation needs to launch a thousand think-pieces.

Direct link | Log in to comment, rate this review, or mute this user.


Previous | 61–70 of 873 | Next | Show All