Holy crap. I know 90s nostalgia is all the rage these days – a trend that I’m not super psyched about in any objective sense, to be honest, but to the extent that it will only fade when it’s replaced by the aughts varietal I guess you’d have to count me in favor – but never on my IF Comp bingo card would I have put the triumphant (?) return to the community of Rybread Celsius. His heyday was a bit before my time (02 was my first Comp), and I’m not sure if he was still rattling around the newsgroups at that point, but his legend definitely persisted: a maybe-troll famous for broken, buggy, sloppy, but sometimes oddly-compellingly-mind-bending games straining against their constraints. And now somehow, he’s returned.
The opening of Verb, Noun, Adjective sure seems of a piece with that reputation: it introduces itself as a thin Zork parody (you’re standing outside a miniature house, with a miniature mailbox, and told that you need to find some treasures without any diegetic motivation or plot to put things in motion), there are numerous typos immediately in evidence, plus confusing dream-logic descriptions (“there’s a regal pull to the south, and a holy one to the north” – unless wait, is “pull” just a typo for “pile”?), the listing of exits is haphazard and best and actively misleading at worst, and of course there are no testers listed.
And that’s just the first impression: as you progress, likely making frequent reference to the walkthrough (which is actually just an incomplete collection of hints, often missing the proper context), you discover that the game has not one but two underexplained and underleveraged key mechanics: first, in keeping with the game’s title, you find a machine that lets you swap some specifically-designated words from their noun form to a verb or adjective homophone, and then apply them to stuff in the world to alter their properties, and then you also discover that there are some items that allow the parser to recognize whole new actions. Either of these ideas are enough to build a robust game around, but in the half or so of the game I saw, they were only used once and then discarded.
Meanwhile, even when you have a sense of what you’re trying to do, the puzzles are often broken (I got the coin from the wishing well without realizing I was supposed to have unlocked the previously-referenced action before being allowed to retrieve it – whatever barrier was intended to prevent that never fired), overly difficult due to implementation issues (there’s a “dead adventurer” I had to search with TAKE ALL because I couldn’t figure out what noun to use to refer to it – turns out it was a “corpse”, a word nowhere else used by the game), have incredibly player-unfriendly constraints (one treasure can only be found if you’re in the right place, with the right item, on turn 127 – the game’s hints and paratext gesture towards justifying this by claiming it’s an optimization puzzle, you know, like in Sugarlawn), or just inadequately clued unless you count the magic book that occasionally spouts a cryptic hint about one of the treasures you’re looking for, which isn’t particularly satisfying.
So yeah, this is an untested first draft of a game with inadequate clueing, obtuse design, plenty of dead ends, and sketchy mechanics.
Also I kind of liked it?
There aren’t really any grounds on which I can justify that feeling: the above critiques are all spot on, and objectively it’s hard to claim that anyone should waste their time with Verb Noun Adjective. But there in fact is something about it that worked for me. Maybe it’s just that given the context I spelled out in that first paragraph, I went into this one with low expectations and no real intention of playing it through to the end: if I had been hell-bent on getting all the treasures down to the last lousy point, I would certainly have been intensely frustrated. But as an illogical congeries of unexpected stuff to poke at as long as it holds your interest, it’s good for an hour or so of fun. Like, there’s a hidden thief who talks exclusively in Victorian criminal slang, with the puzzle being to figure out what the heck he’s saying. There’s a corrupt priest, an overcomplicated washer/dryer (I got as fair as figuring out how to use DIY corn starch to make clothes super stiff), a monkey. Those abortive stabs at unique mechanics are fun when they show up. And the writing is loopily engaging, warts and all – like, here’s that priest:
The priest looks you up and down and sees cradle of sin. He casually mentions he has an indulgence you can buy to wipe that sin away.
Would I like Verb Noun Adjective better if it had been polished, tested, and sanded into something resembling a modern text adventure, rather than a relic of the rough-and-tumble 20th Century? Undoubtedly. But I still enjoyed coming across it in its present form too – maybe I’m not as immune to 90s nostalgia as I thought…
The political theorist Isaiah Berlin has a famous essay where he proposes that there are two kinds of thinkers: hedgehogs and foxes. Hedgehogs have one big idea, a totalizing framework they bring to bear on every phenomenon they encounter with maniacal, monotonous fervor. Foxes, by contrast, refuse to be pinned down, flitting from topic to topic, idea to idea, carrying perhaps a unifying vibe or approach to each of their latest obsessions but in it for the quick burst of novel insight rather than the grinding endurance of a monumental life’s work. In truth, human beings can’t be typified quite so neatly – though of course I’d say that, since I count myself among the foxes – but perhaps pieces of IF can, and if so, Devils of Terminology leaves me yearning for a fretful porpentine.
A recitation of the themes and elements this modest-length visual novel employs over the course of its breathless plot is only slightly less bewildering than experiencing them in gameplay. There’s a teenager who orphans herself by getting angry at her parents for forgetting her birthday, two different supernatural trains, a typewriter automaton named Nihil who can come up with magical names for places (and which is patterned after a human with maybe-related powers?), a seaside town called “Lost, the Clockwork City” and which plays host to a pair of Dark-Souls-style minibosses (he’s a giant, she’s a wizard), a horned she-devil who is allegedly also Dante Alighieri, paired trinities of past, present, and future, and hell, purgatory, and heaven, a fracture in the sky that destabilizes the world, a sword made of bone and sinew, and the world’s most confusing Sherlock-and-Watson double-act (right, this all allegedly playing in out in late-Victorian London).
I’m not so simple a rube as to require everything that happens in a game to have an explanation, much less one telegraphed to the player, but this cavalcade of stuff created two issues for me. First, there are few connections drawn between the disparate material, either thematic or narrative. Actually, almost as soon as one idea is introduced, it’s dropped in favor of the next: the Dante reveal is played as a big deal, for example, and despite it making no sense I was curious where the game was going with it, like were we going to get into the details of their travels to the underworld, or rhapsodies on their encounter with the divine, or at least some parallels drawn between the way the devil acts as a sort of guide to the main character, mirroring Virgil’s role in the Divine Comedy? No, everyone just goes “no way, you’re really Dante?!” and then never mentions it again. As a result, rather than a thematic bricolage where each new idea helps recontextualize those it’s placed next to, the game comes across as just a jumble of stuff, growing less compelling with each new twist.
The second issue is that the narrative stakes were never made clear. If Devils were a picaresque where a simple journey narrative took the player through a series of unconnected but memorable vignettes, with the ultimate destination clearly telegraphed, that might not be the most compelling thing in the world but at least you’d have a sense of where you were headed. But while the game feints towards such a structure by having the main character be a detective who investigates a series of cases, and allots a few of its portentous revelations to establishing the aforementioned trinities which at least give a sense of when the game is ending, the climactic plot elements felt just as much like rug-pulls as the earlier ones.
Now, I need to acknowledge the elephant in the room and point out that the game’s English text is a translation of the Korean original, so it could be that things are much smoother in the author’s mother tongue. But still, having to judge the game by the language in which I can engage with it, at both the macro and the micro levels the writing left me struggling. Like, here’s a bit of what I think is supposed to be playful banter between the main character and their devil sidekick:
Us: the person who returned claimed to have seen Heaven. Do you remember anything about them?
Renua thought for a moment, then answered readily.
R: They were called a genius, right? That’s all I remember~
Us: ..A genius.
She was always like this.
Always thinking about ways to play around, yet somehow useful at moments like these.
The deeper elements of the game’s design doesn’t help matters, unfortunately. It uses a custom system whose interface is superficially similar to VN-standby RenPy. But while I’ve figured out how to tweak that platform to my liking, here I was frustrated by the inability to set text to display instantly and the lack of a quick scroll forward/scrollback system (or easy undo), and small pieces of friction like long lines of dialogue being cut off and the redundant-but-not-identical Log and History features eventually added up. Meanwhile, the game’s only mechanics are a scant handful of choices, spread thinly across the game’s hour and a half running time, with the player’s input rarely feeling especially impactful – there’s an early bit where I took the option to press a client on some details before accepting their case, but actually clicking that led to some commentary on stuff happening outside the window and then yet more sidekick banter.
All told this means I spent most of my time with Devils of Terminology just clicking to see what was going to happen next, not especially invested in or comprehending whatever left-turn was waiting around the corner. This is a shame, because there is a lot of invention and imagination to the game, and the basic tropes and themes are I think appealing ones. But it’s ultimately too hyperactive for its own good – rather than desperately prancing about as though it were just one step ahead of the hounds, Devils would have been better off hunkering down, sniffing out a promising direction, and digging in.
I’ve been playing, reviewing, and rating the Comp for more years now than I care to contemplate, and while some thing have become second nature, I still do struggle with that last element when it comes to judging the incredible range of games on offer according to a single ten-point scale, especially where length is the primary axis of difference. Is there a principled reason to rate two games of comparable quality differently when one lasts five minutes and the other goes well beyond the two-hour judging window? Does it even make sense to talk about “comparable quality” when the difference in what a super-short game can do and be good at, and what a longer game can do and be good at, often yawns so large that it becomes a difference of kind, not degree? I dunno, man, it’s tough. But what I do know is that when it comes to these amuse-bouche style experiences, I’m more than content if I get a single moment of intense engagement, which could be an “aha!” at a clever gameplay trick, or a laugh at a committing-to-the-bit joke, or just deep appreciation at one or two haunting, poetic lines of writing. Even if I’m not sure how to score such things later, I’m clear that that’s more than enough for success in my book.
IF Derby confounded my well-honed framework, though, by offering two distinct experiences of intense pleasure. But before getting to those, I have to describe what’s admittedly a pretty baroque setup for a piece of micro-IF. See, this is a meta game that transposes the action of the Comp into a literal horse-race: upon opening up the game, you’re presented with an octet of game titles – some of which are recognizable riffs on real games or genres, some of which are pure, entertaining nonsense – each of which is assigned to a different, lightly-animated horse (the game runs in Decker, and makes good use of the system’s pleasing Game Boy aesthetic). You start with $500, and are prompted to lay some or all of your stake on the horse of your choice. To help make your choice more informed, you’re given a smattering of data, including the number of reviews the game has received, both overall and on IFDB, as well as the IFDB average rating, and the all-important length of the game. And then you see the race, and if your horse comes in first, you pocket the winnings and get to try again.
This is a pretty basic set of interactions, elevated by the way the names create a rooting interest (I was personally very invested in Manly Napoleonic High Seas Adventure’s success, and vacillated on whether it was worth taking a flyer on dark horse Flying to Sydney in Real Time) but still clearly the purest trifle. Except that somehow this trifle managed to make me smile broadly to myself two different times, for two entirely different reasons.
The first is because as soon as I saw the oddmakers’ sheet of data, I thought to myself “hang on, is this implementing Autumn Chen’s ranking-prediction algorithm?” But I didn’t content myself with a laugh, I went and tracked down the original spreadsheet, extracted the formulas, and created my own Excel doc that I could plug IF Derby’s entrants into in order to see whether this helped my luck (which I confess had been quite poor until I took this step). I won’t spoil the outcome of this little bit of extracurricular activity, but I will say that it’s always a good thing when a game makes me create a spreadsheet, so it wins plenty of plaudits from me on this score.
The second is perhaps more in line with the game’s intended effect. I won’t spoil this one either – though for those who just played a round or two and bounced off, it’s worth going back and looking for something that appears slightly different in the post-race screen after you’ve been around the track a couple of times – but suffice to say that there’s a bit of writing that constitutes the game’s real ending, and while it’s as short, funny, and allegorical as the rest of IF Derby, I still felt like it had something real and worthwhile to say about the Comp, authorship, reviewing, and why we all keep going around doing this crazy thing year after year after year. If anything, that means I’ll have an even harder time than usual coming up with a rating – but believe me, I feel very, very happy to be faced with this particular dilemma.
It’s easy to accuse IF of being a past-obsessed medium: much as the scene has evolved over the decades, to a certain degree we exist in the long shadow of mass-market successes of the 80s (Infocom and Choose Your Own Adventure looming perhaps largest), and practically from the beginning we’ve been commenting on what came before. The obvious, correct rebuttal is that this is an age dominated by remakes, reboots, and legacy sequels, so why should IF be so different? But “everyone else is doing it” concedes the point; as your mom always said, if everyone else was jumping off the Brooklyn Bridge, would you do it too?
All of which is to say that Escape the Wumpus, while a reasonably fun time on its own terms, didn’t truly justify its link to OG maybe-IF Hunt the Wumpus. The original is a seminal game of the 1970s, laying out a very specific gameplay paradigm for hide-and-seek as you navigate around a complex maze (famously laid out along the edges of a dodecahedron) and try to get the jump on the eponymous monster. Heck, it’s so seminal that it even has a seminal homage-game, Andrew Plotkin’s Hunter, in Darkness which sticks with the same overall setup but interrogates how an embodied player avatar and evocate prose would change the clinical math puzzle.
So to my mind making a new Wumpus game is a challenging proposition: there’s a high bar to clear, and also, the raw material (geometrically-precise maze, omnipotent monster) isn’t necessarily super compelling on its own. It’s both good and bad, then, that it doesn’t feel like Escape the Wumpus is trying very hard to link itself to this ongoing mythology. Rather than trying to track down and kill the monster, here you’re just trying to get out of the maze before it finds and devours you – but actually, you very much need to do that because this time out the Wumpus is entirely static, just hanging out in a single room and not pursuing you at all. The dodecahedron is correctly set up, so the navigation challenge is familiar, but the gameplay is a straightforward choice-based affair, with simple puzzles (locks, fetch-quests, etc.) scattered about the nodes. You do need to contend with gravity, since some connections leave you plummeting to the ground of a particular cavern, and many of the puzzles are a bit oblique, but in general, you mostly just need to take notes about which nodes connect to which other ones, and which still have an outstanding barrier to resolve, and you can just jog through the maze in a regular pattern, unlocking new doors and getting new items as you go.
There’s an entertainingly offbeat vibe to many of the specifics; the writing isn’t afraid to linger on odd details, presenting totally off-the-wall situations with a minimum of fuss or worldbuilding, and I liked the counterintuitive way the shiny key allows you to progress (it doesn’t unlock a door), but all this does mean that a combination of unclear prose and surprising mechanics often left me unclear of what I should be doing or where I should be going, leading me to run the aforementioned laps instead. Like, this is an engaging piece of writing, but I at least find it hard to picture what’s being described:
The opposite side of the room has another buttoned compartment, almost hidden with a large body of a stone creature. One of its wings covers the creature as a fluffy blanket, and another curtains the door leading to the next room. The creature seemingly sleeping wakes up a bit and tells me: “Hello, little stranger!”
This trend reached its nadir in the final puzzle, which required me to consult the walkthrough – turns out you need to attempt an action that leads to failure twice more in order to progress, which isn’t an approach that’s totally verboten but still one that often leaves me frustrated. Doing so allows you to escape, having never interacted with the Wumpus at all, which again contributes to my sense that this is a game that could have worked equally well on cartesian coordinates with no Wumpus at all. Admittedly, I didn’t fully explore a couple of rooms, making me wonder whether there’s a “true ending” that comments more directly on its inspiration. But given the experience I actually had, I think I would have preferred that non-Wumpus version, as the overhang of expectations (and, I admit, slight annoyance at nostalgia-baiting) didn’t do much to enhance my enjoyment of what’s otherwise a fun enough fantasy adventure.
It’s hard to talk about the Count and the Communist without focusing on how unique it is, and especially on its visual presentation. Taking Inform 7 as its foundation, the game reimagines basically every traditional element of input and output to create a lavishly-illustrated point-and-click adventure, with lovingly-crafted ASCII graphics providing the visuals and limited-parser menu-based interaction standing in for the mouse. Beyond that, per the title you’re playing a committed follower of Marx bent on defending the nascent Soviet state from a White Russian conspiracy by going undercover as a laundress at the estate of an émigré aristocrat; this means there are rather more lectures on dialectical materialism than in most Comp entries, but also that object-manipulation puzzles, while present, are de-emphasized in favor of stealth-based gameplay, as you snoop around the manor while trying to avoid arousing the suspicions of your employer or your fellow servants. I’m going to talk about all this novel stuff – as soon as the following paragraph, in fact! – but let me just note before we do that I don’t think it makes sense to stop there.
So, let’s lead off with the presentation. It’s great! The graphics are really well done, conveying a real sense of character and responding to state changes (there are slight variations to what you look like when you are and are not wearing an apron or carrying a laundry basket), while providing an impressive level of detail when you’re getting a close-up of items that are important to some of the set-piece puzzles. There’s a well-done map that conveys a reasonably complex, 3D space with aplomb, and the overall interface cleanly indicates what you can do at any given point in time. There are times when the graphics perhaps tempted the author to fly too close to the sun – I’m thinking here of a specific code-breaking puzzle that I found tricky because it was hard for me to keep my place in the message – but while I’m not an especially visually-oriented player, what’s on offer here still managed to impress me, while largely supporting some of the trickier elements of gameplay.
As for the interface, it’s similarly impressive but my verdict here is a bit more mixed. You have around a dozen verbs available to you at any given time, each abbreviated with a single letter, as well as a separate inventory screen where you can examine what you’re carrying or take action with those items as well. Once you decide on what to do, you’re often prompted to indicate the direct object of the verb via a numbered list (stuff in the location first, stuff you’re carrying listed after that), and then potentially an indirect object as well, with each step requiring you to input a number or letter, then press enter. This succeeds in retaining a lot of the complexity of a typical parser game – just check the post-game AMUSING option to see exactly how many interactions are accounted for – while avoiding guess-the-verb problems, and providing enough friction to prevent the player from simply lawnmowering through all the options they’re presented with.
There are places where it can feel awkward, though, since you can’t know what number corresponds to what object before you start taking an action, and how numbers are assigned to objects can shift as you uncover new stuff or interact with different items in your inventory; where in a typical parser game, you’d think to try UNLOCK X WITH Y and then just type it, here you need to select the verb, hit enter, look on the list to see what number corresponds to X, hit enter again, look at a potentially-slightly-different list to see what number corresponds to Y, and hit enter one last time. The mapping of verbs to letters also took a while for me to get used to, since the use of cardinal directions means USE is F rather than U, and CLOSE takes precedence over COMBINE, which maps to B (also, while usually you need to use COMBINE to have one item interact with another, there are a few exceptions where you just USE the first item and then pick the object). And scenes that play out over multiple screens can’t be advanced just by hitting enter – usually you need to type a period, then enter, except sometimes that switches to the number one instead. Overall it’s a solid system, but sometimes it does feel like it’s missing that all-important last 10% of polish.
Story-wise, I’m always a fan of a grounded, historical setting, and research has clearly gone into every aspect of the game, from the protagonist’s choice of reading material to the technology underpinning the set-piece puzzles. The protagonist is an appealing character, sincere and plucky, and the Sapphic overtones to her relationship with her handler were tropey but fun. There’s also a nice sense of escalation to the three main sections of the game – admittedly, I think the pacing of the last act is slightly off because the puzzles that come after your final confrontation with the Count are anticlimactic, but until then there’s a great ramp up as your mission shifts, and the stakes rise. The supporting cast are also appealing, from the aforementioned handler to your fellow servants, who are often preventing you from accomplishing your key tasks but nonetheless wind up being sympathetic. I do think the game’s politics are a bit wobbly at a few points – in particular, I’ve got no problem sympathizing with idealistic characters fired up about what Red October might mean for the plight of the working class, but having another character explicitly call attention to the future course of events in the Soviet Union by warning of the potential for horrors to come, only for the protagonist to argue them into thinking it will be fine, is a bit much, as is the bit where you get a pacifistic character to be more open to political violence. The fact that the specific historical backdrop for this is a proposed invasion of Ukraine also brought in some unpleasant real-world associations. Still, at a time when jingoism is de rigueur in blockbuster AAA shooters, a single Panglossian game about heroic Communists is hard to get too worked up about.
This all finally brings us around to the gameplay, and here is where it’s possible to judge The Count and the Communist according to the same standards one uses for most other pieces of IF. The puzzles are well-clued without being overly obvious, for example, with many of them hinging on interacting with seemingly-complex mechanisms that get much more intuitive after you’ve checked them out piece by piece. Similarly, sneaking around is always a concern – at least until the cathartic finale, which is a canny way of shifting the gameplay to match the narrative climax – but the game is actually quite forgiving; you’re typically given three turns of warning before an NPC actually moves, which is usually plenty of time to leave or hide, while still making you feel the pressure. There’s a nice variety of tasks to perform, and a pleasant day-by-day rhythm to the gameplay loop as you do your chores, do some spying, get to know the other servants better, and check in with your handler. Put baldly, even if you got rid of all the graphical bells and whistles and implemented this design as a regular-degular parser game, it would still be lots of fun, which is why I think the game is ultimately such a success: it’s unique, sure, and perhaps even innovative, but that’s no guarantee of a good time. We players are very lucky that Count and the Communist offers the whole package.
Bragging is, in general, pretty dumb, and bragging about being good at video games is specifically even dumber than that. As with most things, short of the truly rarefied heights “skill” here is largely just a matter of having the time to get good, which is a totally fine choice to make if you’ve got the requisite material privilege, but also, it’s no more inherently valuable than being really good at squash or knowing a lot about early 90s country music or being able to cook a killer vegetarian paella (OK, actually it’s much less inherently valuable than making a killer paella, those are great). And yet! Whenever the conversation turns to dungeon-crawlers, and especially to roguelikes, my toes start to twitch as I try to figure out how I can casually let slip that I’ve won Angband like ten times.
Angband is one of the classical trio of old-school roguelikes: we’re talking ASCII characters in place of graphics, permadeath, and a 100-level dungeon that takes something like 80 hours to work through even if you know what you’re doing. It’s objectively ridiculous, but for some reason it speaks to me in a way NetHack or ADOM or more modern, more forgiving roguelikes just don’t, and for a couple years in the late Obama administration I devoted more hours than I care to contemplate learning how dragons’ breath attacks worked (and which non-dragon monsters had them), to prioritize among the dozen or so elemental resistances, to run the odds on wand and staff failure rates, and how to take a deep breath in the middle of a high-risk, high-reward fight and see that it was time to cut my losses and run. These are not skills that are applicable to any other field of human endeavor (OK, maybe that last one is), and there’s no earthly reason anyone should care about this non-accomplishment, but still, I’m inordinately proud to have managed it.
All of this is just by way of establishing my bona fides in the sub-genre – not, I repeat not, a transparent excuse to casually let slip etc. – as we come to consider MAD WARRIOR. Bad luck for me, this is the second game in a row where the protagonist has been faced with the choice whether to execute a child, but at least here it’s all safely relegated to the backstory: you play the flunky to an evil overlord who finally reached you breaking point, and upon being cut down for your defiance, because you were such a bad dude the devil brings you back to life to work for him, with your first target being an archangel lurking at the heart of a consecrated stronghold.
Anyway of course none of that matters in the slightest, you start at the top of a dungeon and fight bats and skeletons and stuff. I would have liked a bit more of a commitment to the theme (Angband is an admittedly-inconsistent riff on Tolkien, but finding the Phial of Galadrial or working your way through the nine Ringwraiths definitely makes it more fun) but really, we all know how this stuff works, and MAD WARRIOR works that way… mostly.
There are weapon and armor slots, and HP and defense and attack values, and consumable items, and an inventory with limited slots and all the standard accoutrements of the genre, as well as only being able to save in specially-designated areas. And it’s clearly a text-based RPG rather than a piece of IF; you have a lot of commands for interacting with the various systems and bespoke verbs for different pieces of equipment, but comparatively few for engaging with the world. The dungeon has a tiny bit of set dressing, but the only interactive objects are monsters and treasure.
That’s all fine, even if personally I prefer my RPG/IF hybrids to be a bit more, well, hybridized. But there are a fair number of idiosyncrasies too, and unfortunately most of them make MAD WARRIOR less successful than a generic game of its type. For one thing, there’s some kind of omnipresent formatting error that makes each location description begin and end with a random jumble of numbers and symbols – since this is a DOS executable, I can’t imagine that there’s some formatting or rendering issue making this display oddly just on my machine, it seems like it must be an obvious, jarring bug. For another, it leans into the simulationist tendencies of roguelikes at the expense of playability, most notably in requiring you to have your carryall open before you can take loot or use your inventory, but then preventing you from leaving a room until you close it again, which adds so much friction that finding new equipment often provoked a sigh of anticipated tedium.
What’s worst of all, combat in MAD WARRIOR is frequent, gimmick-free, and unrewarding. Of course there are a bunch of monsters, and fighting is an integral expectation of this kind of game, but there’s nothing that makes it especially fun: you don’t have magic or special moves, so you just attack the bad guy until they die (in theory you can use items, but given the need to futz around with your bag that’ll probably just get you killed faster). And then once they do die – that’s it. I never saw a monster drop anything upon expiring, and there’s no experience system incrementally improving your stats either. And over three runs – most ending at level 5 of who knows how many – I didn’t find any especially exciting treasure lying around the dungeon either, it was all just the occasional consumable rather than weapon or armor upgrades. Oh, and while combat rolls are randomized, the location of monsters and treasure seems to be fixed, so this isn’t a game you get better at as you develop a strategy, it’s one you get better at as you memorize the map and decide which monsters to avoid or run away from.
Cutting the player off from the core reward-loop of the genre – number go up – is a bold choice, and one that could work if there was something, anything replacing it: an alternate, ability-based progression, maybe, or deeply implemented puzzles, or even just a well-integrated backstory. But in the absence of any of that, I found it impossible to muster the requisite commitment to progress in MAD WARRIOR. It did make me realize it’s been a couple of years since I’ve gotten back to Angband, though…
One of my worst habits as a reviewer is that I’ll occasionally play a game that I really enjoy but which has a couple of flaws or makes a few choices different than I would make, and write a review that harps on that stuff in excessive detail while throwing in a shrugging “yes, this is actually quite good” in a sentence or two at the end. Queenlash, for example, is a 10/10 game for me, one that over five years on I still regularly think about and recommend, and yet my review is a 2,500 word harangue. What was I thinking? I gotta stop doing this!
I’m not going to stop doing this.
I can at least make sure there’s a couple full paragraphs (plus excerpt!) of unvarnished praise rather than just a single begrudging line, though. GRIP is pretty good! It’s identifiably working in the Papers Please genre, putting you in the shoes of a case officer processing anomalously-powered kids in a well-imagined alchemypunk setting – sometimes they manifest with the wrong elemental-alignment, or they’re too strong, or the child (it’s always children) uses them to hurt someone else, at which point they’re brought in and it’s up to you to review the file, question them, and then decide on their fate. In between these set-pieces, you get slice-of-life vignettes like commuting to and from work, or seeing how your low-income neighborhood changes over the years you work the job, which is an effective structure. There’s a pleasingly worked-out interface for all of this, with graphical elements that look like folders and forms, and a sidebar with a working glossary and relevant stats. Best of all, the writing is assured, focused on concrete details and psychologically precise. Here’s your thought process at the beginning of the game, when you see the job listing that sets you on your new path:
You do not know what a Godborn registry is. You know what hiring is, and what paid weekly is. While standing there in the stair traffic with people pushing past you on both sides, those two things are doing most of the reading for you.
You copy the annex address onto the back of a ration slip, fold it into your coat, and go home to sleep on it, which is a thing people say when the decision is already made and they would like one more night of pretending it isn’t.
It’s all compelling, and consistent over a fairly long playtime (there are ten cases to work through). The interviews are taut high-points, and your relationship with your immediate superior – a bureaucrat who perhaps doesn’t have a heart, but is very good at describing the place where one should go – creates a strong through-line through these more episodic sequences. And having the key decisions reduced to stamping a particular column on a form makes for a strong diegetic match for the choice-based format, with graphic effects making those clicks have more weight than the quotidian choices you use to navigate the rest of the story.
[Exhales heavily] OK, just a couple more things to get out of the way before I can talk about the thing I’m excited to talk about. There are definitely some places where GRIP makes some missteps, so I’ll just note in passing that some of the lore is overcomplicated (the whole business about kids being emitters vs. sorcerers vs. anointers is confusing and kind of precious); the way the children talk in the interviews doesn’t ring true to my experience of little kids, and you can’t really tell the five year old from the seven year old from the ten year old; once those interviews end your choices are to order the execution of a child (lol no), send them off to join the military (again, these are children), or put them under a form of house arrest, which is usually what your boss recommends, so it’s a bit too easy to pick; the writing, clinical as it is, can start to feel a bit one-note by the time you get towards the end of the game; and speaking of the ending, mine seemed to come out of nowhere, as I was ordered executed for confusing reasons that didn’t match anything I remembered doing. But most of these critiques are no big deal, especially the last one (“is this a bug, or is this just how fascism works?” is a totally fine question for a game to raise).
No, the thing that’s most interesting about GRIP is how it understands bureaucracy. This is a game about being a cog in a machine, but part of the reason the wonkiness of the key choice doesn’t ultimately matter that much is that it’s got no illusions about agency: the bureaucracy is there to do a job, and you are there to do it. It’s more interested in exploring what that’s like than pretending that you can make major changes to society by stamping A instead of B on your forms. It’s careful to depict the various depersonalization techniques that are used – “you don’t answer subjects”, i.e. respond to the questions asked by the children you’re judging, is a constant refrain – but is also careful to allow you seemingly low-consequences options to either go along with them, or try to retain some humanity by bearing witness. The depiction of authoritarianism is nicely calibrated, too; there are no illusions about what’s being done to these kids, but in the early stages the state’s interventions are more tentative, more tied to legitimate-seeming concerns, before the force of its oppression – oppression you’re unquestionably actively complicit in, no matter what you do on the side – grows darker and darker. And there’s a late-game moment of clarity that I think is quite sharp on the distinction between process creating legitimacy, and creating the spectacle of legitimacy:
You understand, holding the pen, that this is what the whole apparatus has been the entire time, under the interviews and the readings and the three columns. Not a machine for deciding fates. A machine for making fates look decided-correctly after the fact. The stamp was always this.
But, wait, why is the government concerned with creating the spectacle of legitimacy, actually? In the real world, it’s because people want to think of their society as just, want there to be rules applied to reach consistent results, even if they’re consistently in favor of in-groups and consistently biased against out-groups. But the lumpenproletariat of GRIP seem uniformly hostile to the government (a shadowy oligarchy only glimpsed via glossary entries) while entirely devoid of opportunities to express that hostility; there are no elections, no sense of how what’s clearly a lower-income but industrially important community is represented, no clarity about what is emboldening the regime to act more and more directly against the interests of residents.
This is a bureaucracy without politics, in other words, and as a result in its weaker moments GRIP can be a collection of dystopian tropes unmoored from material conditions. There’s a recurring subplot about a man who repeatedly abuses his partner and her children, but who never faces any consequences from the authorities, for example. There’s no explanation given for this inaction, nor is it even commented on. This is a familiar story in our world because of the politics of patriarchy, of course, but there’s no on-screen indication that that’s a factor in the world of GRIP; the wardens seem efficient at carrying out their orders without personal sympathies for abusers depicted as a factor in their performance, the highest-ranking official is a woman… but because police in a dystopian society need to be useless, they’re depicted as useless, though we never see their corruption. Similarly, fascist regimes have stakeholders and constituencies. The bureaucratic maneuvering depicted here would be a compelling way of dramatizing the ways authoritarians build consensus around smaller attacks on the weak, then escalating when sufficient popularity and familiarity allow it. But we don’t see the people cheering on each new step, just the victims, so the escalation feels like it’s there to make the plot more tense as it progresses, rather than proceeding from shifting social dynamics.
The obvious rejoinder here is that we’re meant to assume all that stuff is there, and fill in the blanks with our knowledge of how things work here. And that’s fair enough so far as it goes; just because a fictional world has fantastic elements doesn’t mean an author should have to take time to specify “by the way, gravity exists, and people breathe oxygen.” So sure, if you fill in the blanks it’s not too hard to figure out some justifications and explanations for the pieces that don’t currently add up. But the problem isn’t that their omission leads to plot holes – who cares about plot holes? – but that leaving these blanks weakens what should have been one of the strongest parts of the story: evil bureaucracies can be compelling to read about, but without depicting where they come from and how they metastasize, they can seem more like boogeymen than a real thing to fear.
In my Thirst For Blood review, I attempted to play fair with my dislike of certain kinds of zaniness, positing that maybe I just call the stuff I like “whimsy” and reserve the z-word for things that, for whatever reason, rub me the wrong way. But now comes Caribbean Nightmare to make me think maybe actually there is a more objective typology here. Like, whimsy probably takes one out-there idea and takes it to a bunch of different imaginative places, while zaniness thrills to constant rug-pulls and reversals; puzzles in a whimsical work rely on dream logic, with puzzle in a zany game using moon logic instead. And since something whimsical can curdle into zaniness if it wears out its welcome, the successful ones usually know to bang out early.
Anyway, all this apropos of Caribbean Nightmare, a big, robust comedy adventure whose appeal I can easily understand, but which features pirates, pirate zombies, pirate zombies obsessed with fitness and dancing to techno, pirate ghosts, aliens, and Doc Brown from Back to the Future in a cameo role; has puzzles that rely on intuiting the thermogenic properties of random algae and currying the favor of a parrot who responds with pathological approval to the color yellow; and boasts two major puzzles requiring you to run all over the large map with only thin prompting as to what you’re looking for, which I found out about well after I’d let out a two-hour-mark groan at what I thought was the final puzzle (which requires you to run all over the large map with only thin prompting as to what you’re looking for).
To each their own: to those reared on Monkey Island and eager to dig into a sprawling adventure for hours and hours, this Caribbean Nightmare could be anything but. So I’m aware that some of my response here is just idiosyncratic grumpiness combined with the stressful time-limits of the Comp. Still, I think there are some real design issues holding the game back. For one thing, the game’s custom system has a lot of features, like fully-integrated hyperlinks, but can still a bit awkward at times, in the way bespoke systems often are – in particular, dialogue (or any menu-based interaction, like disambiguation) requires you to look over to the sidebar to see your options, then type your response and see the reply back in the main window. In theory, it shouldn’t be that big a disruption, but in practice I found it distracting every time, imposing constant interruptions in the flow of conversations whose pacing often already lagged due to overly-loquacious interlocutors. I also experienced slight output and input delays that weren’t too big a deal in themselves, but added up to more friction than one really wants in a giant game like this.
For another, some of the puzzle solutions really could use some tightening. In addition to the leaps of intuition mentioned above, there are too many places where a simple command requires an exacting syntax to work:
> take treasure
Without a container, I would have little joy with the treasure.
> put treasure in sack
I couldn’t put anything in the sack.
> fill sack
I didn’t want to fill the sack.
> fill sack with treasure
[finally works]
The worst puzzles combine both of these flaws, requiring you to make a non-obvious connection and then try to get your idea across despite three or four rejections just in case the parser is being overly precious. Oh, and despite a promise to the contrary in the about text, there is a maze: it’s a small one, but of course you don’t know that before you start exhaustively mapping it, and it does lead to multiple destinations so you can’t just rest easy once you’ve found one path. Plus in a game with so much required backtracking, it helps make the prospect of trying a new item out on previously-established barriers feel like a slog rather than an exciting opportunity to make progress.
Put it all together and this is a game where I was checking the walkthrough early and often. And despite my aversion to zaniness, I’ll confess that there was some fun to be had along the way. But even if, in the end, some of my negative reaction to Caribbean Nightmare was just down to taste, I still think a version of the game that cut about 30% of the padding and most out-there puzzles, added a bunch more synonyms, and rethought the approach to dialogue would be even more fun for the folks already inclined to enjoy it.
I always appreciate it when a game puts its statement of purpose right on the first screen you see – it makes my job as a reviewer much easier, for one thing, but it also helps me lock into the right mindset with which to approach. Sometimes this comes in the blurb, sometimes in the about text, but El Ruido manages the trick quite eloquently, by having the two verbs available to you in the opening passage be USE and GLOWER. USE shifts from scene to scene – sometimes it’s CONFIDE, sometimes SLAP – but GLOWER is a constant companion. Sure, I suppose practically speaking it’s just EXAMINE with some vibes on top, since when you run your sneering glance over someone or something, the game obliges you with more details on how they’re reacting to your stare (or backstory on how they came to be stared at by you), but man, those vibes are good.
See, the setup here is that you’re in a telenovela – and instead of the hero, you’re playing Yesenia, the villainess. There have been a few soap-opera IF games before – at least, I know of Craverly Heights – but it’s not exactly a well-covered niche in general, and the world of Mexican soaps has heretofore gone entirely unplumbed. I’m of course familiar with the overall conventions here, but I confess I haven’t seen any directly, so the game’s prompting for how I could act helped me get in character. And there’s a lot of fun to be had by leaning into your character’s vendetta against her two-timing former paramour, who’s decided to go straight and taken up with a bloodless, virginal waif:
Her frail hand shakes for the security of Alejandro’s grasp, who sits beside her hospital bed. Seeing them together makes your blood boil from your place outside in the hallway, especially that smile you see on Selena’s face through the glass and barbed wire. The doorknob is just an arm’s length away.
It would be easy for the prose to be so overheated it takes you out of the game, or conversely, so dry that it pushes you out of the mood, but El Ruido deftly occupies the middle space between the two extremes; I always looked forward to the next plot twist, the next outrageous opportunity to show off my malice.
That’s not the only area where the design is nicely judged, either. This is a Texture game, a system that’s a sort of parser/choice hybrid allowing you to drag a limited set of passage-specific verbs onto selected words in the passage to either move the story forward, or add more detail to the current passage. But while in theory the interface is flexible enough to allow for a variety of approaches, in practice most of the Texture games I’ve seen are fairly linear, with most interactions providing a bit of additional context but not providing much in the way of gameplay. El Ruido, by contrast, gives the system a workout: the first few scenes allow you to move around a bit rather than heading straight into confrontation, and there were a couple of times where using one verb on a particular word opened up a new word that could be usefully interacted with via a different one, making for a light puzzle mechanic. Add in some significant branching, and a finale sequence where too much futzing around can run down the timer, and there’s some solid interactivity here to engage the player.
Poking at the edges of the game instead of barreling straight through is a rewarding process, too. The protagonist has been haunted by a strange noise that seems to strengthen or recede depending on how much she commits to her role as a woman scorned and out for vengeance, and assessing exactly how and why that’s happening helps you make sense of a few out-of-place details and sudden, unexplained endings that can cut off the story before it fully develops. The ultimate twist isn’t hugely original, I’ll admit (Spoiler - click to show)(it’s basically telenovela-flavored Westworld) but it’s a satisfying one nonetheless. It all makes for a package that’s as much fun as it seems like it’s going to be, and much smarter than it needed to be, too (I bet that’s how Yesenia thinks of herself, too).
When I was a kid in the 80s and early 90s, I read a ton of classic sci-fi, sometimes for no other reason than that’s all that was left in the fantasy and sci-fi section of the library after a couple of years of voracious plunder. I suspect things are different in these days of endless content, where a nerdy kid can find functionally infinite books and fanfic to fit whatever their precise palette of interests might be, but back in those pre-internet times I picked over all the Asimov, Bradbury, Clarke, and Dick I could find, sometimes because it piqued my interest, sometimes because it was all I hadn’t read yet. And while I can’t say it qualified as my favorite sub-genre, then or now, I wound up at least respecting the way writers of that vintage took a premise and worked it out rigorously through their fiction, inspired by ideas even if they couldn’t always find themselves equally enthused by characters or a plot to give them live.
The name of BLOODRUST’s PROTAGO – sorry, protagonist – Harlan Heinlan isn’t the only reference to 50s and 60s sci-fi you’ll come across in the course of the game, but if it’s a statement of intent, it’s a veiled one. This short choice-based work is long on vibes, its downbeat text peeked at through a monochromatic TV-set frame, its repetitious bureaucracy illustrated by black-and-white photos of likewise-repetitious architectural squalor. Heinlan is a minor functionary in the bureaucracy of a post-apocalyptic regime that, of necessity or of choice, clings to rigid surveillance to maintain the semblance of order; he visits block after block of slum housing cataloguing their status, though he never recommends any action be taken to improve the obviously-terrible conditions. At least he has an outlet: after his shifts are over, he likes to visit an underground poker game where the stakes are parts of the players’ bodies, risking being maimed just to feel something.
There are some big themes at play here – consumption, complicity, cycles of abuse – but nothing is spelled out as didactically as it would have been in those books of my youth; BLOODRUST is elusive, content to communicate a feeling rather than impose an interpretation. The writing is a good fit for what the game is trying to do, maybe a bit overheated at times but effectively situating the player in the tortured subjectivity of the protagonist:
But already, I have suffered the atrocity of loss, again and again. My nerve endings are scorched and left numb, the throb within my brittle skull matched with the beat of my heart. What use is there in chasing irretrievables? My petrified will is best left to simmer in his own hot blood until it, too, turns stone cold.
Still, for all this rarefied sensation, I found the main character a bit of a cold fish. There are some glimmers of intrigue around his identity, from the brief snatches of memory he has about his mother to (Spoiler - click to show)the way his name flashes to “Harley” late in the narrative, perhaps bespeaking a gender transition or perhaps just invoking his namesake Ellison’s second-most-famous story, but in terms of what he actually does, he’s a fairly indolent protagonist, at his best invoking Bartleby the Scrivener’s metaphysical refusals, at his worst engaging in ostentatiously self-destructive behavior for reasons obscure both to him and the player. Sure, there’s something understandable about catching a glimpse of the abyss yawning below your society and then fleeing to self-abnegating helplessness, but it’s not as dramatically satisfying as screaming defiance, is it?
Truly visceral prose that conveyed the full horror of the situation could better motivate that outcome, I think, as could a more worked-out picture of Heinlan’s character – though another player who’s more susceptible to the impact of images and sound (I played with audio muted, natch) might disagree. Regardless, some great authors of sci-fi’s Golden Age didn’t lean too heavily on that stuff either, so you certainly don’t need them to succeed. But I wound up feeling about BLOODRUST like I felt about them: impressive pieces of craft on their own terms, but not the kind of thing I’d prefer if left to my druthers.